lgamma test failing (nan) with clang 19 on arm64

[drew-parsons]

The lgamma test at

xsimd/test/test_xsimd_api.cpp

Line 631 in a9d021a

CHECK_EQ(extract(xsimd::lgamma(T(val))), std::lgamma(val));

is failing with clang 19 on arm64,
see debian test log https://ci.debian.net/data/autopkgtest/unstable/arm64/x/xsimd/54522214/log.gz
from https://ci.debian.net/packages/x/xsimd/unstable/arm64/

2885s     Start 1: test_xsimd
2885s 
2885s 1: Test command: /tmp/autopkgtest-lxc.8mniqst8/downtmp/build.OlH/src/test/run_test_clang_complex/test_xsimd
2885s 1: Working Directory: /tmp/autopkgtest-lxc.8mniqst8/downtmp/build.OlH/src/test/run_test_clang_complex
2885s 1: Test timeout computed to be: 10000000
2885s 1: [doctest] doctest version is "2.4.11"
2885s 1: [doctest] run with "--help" for options
2885s 1: ===============================================================================
2885s 1: /tmp/autopkgtest-lxc.8mniqst8/downtmp/build.OlH/src/test/test_xsimd_api.cpp:755:
2885s 1: TEST CASE:  [xsimd api | float types functions]<xsimd::batch<float>>
2885s 1:   lgamma
2885s 1: 
2885s 1: /tmp/autopkgtest-lxc.8mniqst8/downtmp/build.OlH/src/test/test_xsimd_api.cpp:631: ERROR: CHECK_EQ( extract(xsimd::lgamma(T(val))), std::lgamma(val) ) is NOT correct!
2885s 1:   values: CHECK_EQ( -nan, 0 )
2885s 1: 
2885s 1: ===============================================================================
2885s 1: [doctest] test cases:  320 |  319 passed | 1 failed | 0 skipped
2885s 1: [doctest] assertions: 8293 | 8292 passed | 1 failed |
2885s 1: [doctest] Status: FAILURE!
2885s 1/1 Test #1: test_xsimd .......................***Failed    0.55 sec

So, apparently xsimd::lgamma(2) is returning -nan instead of 0 when compiled with clang 19 on arm64. Perhaps it's a bug in clang, not xsimd.

For comparison, the same test is passing with gcc 14 (at 1733s in the same test log). clang 19 is passing on amd64.

Separately, I'm concerned that many tests, nearly all in fact, use equality (CHECK_EQ) to make floating point comparisons. They would want to be used with doctest::Approx, as a couple of the tests are doing. Using equality for floating point comparison inevitably fails. However in this case the bigger problem is the nan value returned, not the floating point comparison.

[MiroslavR]

I noticed that 6c86b23 fixed undefined behavior in lgamma, and the fix hasn't been released yet. Could this be it?

[serge-sans-paille]

@JohanMabille you usually handle releases, can you do this, or do you want me to make that one?

[drew-parsons]

I can confirm that patch fixes the issue

https://ci.debian.net/packages/x/xsimd/unstable/arm64/
https://ci.debian.net/packages/x/xsimd/unstable/arm64/54747163/#L8543

Edit: wait, no another Debian developer set it back to clang-18. Will have to test separately.

[drew-parsons]

And confirming now the patch does fix it for clang-19
https://ci.debian.net/packages/x/xsimd/unstable/arm64/55038636/#L8536

[serge-sans-paille]

we made a new release that integrates the patch, let's close?