feat(MPDZBS-877): zmscitizenapi into next #674
Conversation
#574) * endpoint working * fix unit tests * one working test for post-reserve * some clean up * feat(ZMS-2517): fix up response for the reserve post request * feat(ZMS-2517): add more unit tests for validations * feat(ZMS-2517): add more unit tests for validations * feat(ZMS-2517): Zmscitizenapi Refactor Part 1 of 3 move controllers back to root * feat(ZMS-2517): Zmscitizenapi Refactor Part 2 of 3 create ZmsApiFacadeService ZmsApiClientService ValidationService MapperService UtilityHelper and delete fragmented services * feat(ZMS-2517): Zmscitizenapi Refactor Part 3 of 3 clean up validations and unit tests --------- Co-authored-by: Thomas Fink <[email protected]>
…by github commit history
* (feat MPDZBS-877) readd citizenapi to htaccess * feat(MPDZBS-877 ZMS-2517): Working Appointment update with too many emails exception * feat(MPDZBS-877 ZMS-2517): Test rendering working for update appointment test * feat(MPDZBS-877 ZMS-2517): Add 63 validation unit tests for appointment update * feat(MPDZBS-877 ZMS-2517): Refactor exception appointmentNotFound * feat(MPDZBS-877 ZMS-2517): Add two new edge case exception tests * feat(MPDZBS-877 ZMS-2517): Remove error_logs --------- Co-authored-by: Thomas Fink <[email protected]>
ThomasAFink
force-pushed
the
feature-MPDZBS-877-zmscitizenapi
branch
from
b57e687
to
1a34881
Compare
ThomasAFink
force-pushed
the
feature-MPDZBS-877-zmscitizenapi
branch
from
1a34881
to
c15dea6
Compare
|
@coderabbitai full review |
✅ Actions performedFull review triggered. |
WalkthroughThe changes in this pull request primarily introduce a new module, Changes
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
Documentation and Community
|
|
Tip For best results, initiate chat on the files or code changes. @ThomasAFink: After analyzing the codebase, I was unable to locate any existing validation methods within the If there are specific validations in Alternatively, we might consider refactoring common validation logic into a shared service within 🔗 Analysis chain🏁 Scripts executedThe following scripts were executed for the analysis: Script: Length of output: 187 |
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Caution
Inline review comments failed to post. This is likely due to GitHub's limits when posting large numbers of comments.
🛑 Comments failed to post (121)
zmscitizenapi/public/index.php (1)
1-4: 💡 Codebase verification
Security configuration needs enhancement
The verification reveals several security considerations that need attention:
- The HTTP 403 protection for direct API access is commented out (lines 2-5)
- While body parsing middleware is added, there's no explicit security middleware for headers
- Error handling is configured but security headers are not explicitly set
Recommendations:
- Uncomment and review the direct access protection block
- Add security headers middleware (e.g., CORS, Content-Security-Policy, X-Frame-Options)
- Consider adding rate limiting middleware for API protection
🔗 Analysis chain
Verify security headers and error reporting configuration
As this is a public entry point, ensure that:
- Security headers are properly configured in bootstrap.php or middleware
- Error reporting is appropriately configured for production
Let me try to locate the bootstrap file and security configurations with a different approach.
Let me check the specific security configurations in the relevant files.
Let me try one final check with corrected syntax to look for middleware configuration.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check for security-related configurations in bootstrap and related files echo "Checking for security configurations..." rg -l "header|error_reporting|display_errors" ../bootstrap.php # Check for any existing security middleware ast-grep --pattern 'class $_ implements \Slim\Middleware { $$$ }'Length of output: 280
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Find the bootstrap file location fd bootstrap.php # Look for security-related configurations in PHP files echo "Checking for security headers and error configurations..." rg -l "header|error_reporting|display_errors|ini_set" --type php # Look for middleware configurations echo "Checking for middleware configurations..." rg -l "middleware|->add\(" --type phpLength of output: 2796
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check security configurations in the citizen API bootstrap file echo "Checking zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php:" rg -A 5 "header|error_reporting|display_errors|ini_set" zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php # Check security middleware implementations echo "Checking security middleware implementations:" rg -A 10 "class.+implements.+Middleware" zmsslim/src/Slim/Middleware/HttpBasicAuth.php zmsslim/src/Slim/Middleware/SessionHeadersHandler.php zmsslim/src/Slim/Middleware/OAuthMiddleware.php zmsslim/src/Slim/Middleware/IpAddress.php # Check if these middleware are added in the bootstrap echo "Checking middleware usage in bootstrap:" rg "->add\(" zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.phpLength of output: 1205
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the bootstrap file content echo "Checking bootstrap file content:" cat zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php # Check middleware usage with proper escaping echo "Checking middleware configuration:" rg "\\->add\\(" zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.phpLength of output: 1491
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirmTest.php (2)
9-12: 💡 Codebase verification
⚠️ Potential issueBased on the gathered information, I can now generate the final response:
Enhance test coverage with additional test scenarios
The current test implementation is insufficient as the AppointmentConfirm endpoint should return a message property according to the schema (zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/appointmentConfirm.json). The test should verify:
- Successful confirmation returns a message (schema compliance)
- Invalid/missing request parameters handling
- Error scenarios for non-existent appointments
Looking at AppointmentReserveTest.php as a reference, the test class should include validation of:
- Required request parameters
- Response format against the schema
- Error handling for invalid inputs
- Edge cases like confirming already confirmed appointments
🔗 Analysis chain
Enhance test coverage with additional test scenarios
The current test only verifies that a POST request returns an empty array, which seems insufficient for testing appointment confirmation functionality. Consider adding tests for:
- Successful appointment confirmation
- Invalid appointment data
- Error scenarios
- Edge cases
Let's verify what we're testing against:
Let's gather more information about the AppointmentConfirm implementation and related test patterns:
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Find the actual AppointmentConfirm class implementation fd -e php AppointmentConfirm.php # Look for similar test patterns in other appointment-related tests rg -l "class \w+Test extends Base" "zmscitizenapi/tests" # Check for any existing appointment confirmation fixtures fd -e json -e yaml appointmentLength of output: 2126
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the AppointmentConfirm implementation cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirm.php # Look at the appointment confirmation schema cat zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/appointmentConfirm.json # Check other appointment-related test implementations for patterns cat zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserveTest.php cat zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentPreconfirmTest.php # Check if there are any appointment confirmation fixtures fd -e json confirmLength of output: 16056
10-10: 💡 Codebase verification
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add test data and use available parameters in renderJson method
The
renderJsonmethod accepts several parameters with default values:
$arguments(array): for route arguments$parameters(array): for request parameters/payload$sessionData(array|null): for session data$method(string): HTTP method, defaults to 'GET'$assertStatusCodes(array): expected status codes, defaults to [200]public function testRendering() { - $responseData = $this->renderJson(method: 'POST'); + $responseData = $this->renderJson( + parameters: [ + 'authKey' => 'test-key', + 'appointmentId' => 'test-123' + ], + method: 'POST' + );🔗 Analysis chain
Document test method parameters and add test data
The
renderJsonmethod is called with amethodparameter, but it's unclear what other parameters might be available or required.Let's check the base class implementation:
Consider adding test data and documenting the method:
+ /** + * @test + * @covers \BO\Zmscitizenapi\AppointmentConfirm::handleRequest + */ public function testRendering() { - $responseData = $this->renderJson(method: 'POST'); + // Prepare test data + $testData = [ + 'appointmentId' => 'test123', + // Add other required fields + ]; + + $responseData = $this->renderJson( + method: 'POST', + data: $testData + );🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Find and examine the Base test class ast-grep --pattern 'class Base { $$$ renderJson($$$) { $$$ } $$$ }'Length of output: 81
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's try to find the Base test class with a broader search rg -l "class.*Base.*extends" --type php # Then let's look for renderJson method rg "renderJson" --type php -A 5Length of output: 2840
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's examine the full Base class implementation to understand the renderJson method better cat zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/Base.phpLength of output: 943
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentCancelTest.php (1)
10-13:
⚠️ Potential issueEnhance test coverage for appointment cancellation
The current test implementation is insufficient for validating appointment cancellation functionality. Consider the following improvements:
- Add test data setup to create an appointment that can be cancelled
- Verify that the cancellation actually occurred in the system
- Test error scenarios (e.g., invalid appointment, already cancelled)
- Add assertions to verify the system state after cancellation
Here's a suggested structure:
- public function testRendering() { - $responseData = $this->renderJson(method: 'POST'); - $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing([], $responseData); - } + /** + * @test + * @dataProvider appointmentDataProvider + */ + public function testSuccessfulAppointmentCancellation($appointmentData) + { + // Setup + $appointment = $this->createTestAppointment($appointmentData); + + // Execute + $responseData = $this->renderJson( + method: 'POST', + params: ['id' => $appointment->getId()] + ); + + // Verify + $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing([], $responseData); + $this->assertAppointmentCancelled($appointment->getId()); + } + + /** + * @test + */ + public function testCancelNonExistentAppointment() + { + // Test handling of invalid appointment IDs + } + + /** + * @test + */ + public function testCancelAlreadyCancelledAppointment() + { + // Test duplicate cancellation attempts + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentPreconfirmTest.php (1)
10-13: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance test coverage with additional test cases.
The current test only verifies the successful case with an empty response. Consider adding:
- Test cases for different input scenarios
- Error case testing
- Documentation for the test method
+ /** + * @test + * @testdox Verify appointment pre-confirmation returns empty response for valid POST request + */ public function testRendering() { + // Arrange + $testData = [ + 'appointmentId' => '123', + 'email' => '[email protected]' + ]; + + // Act - $responseData = $this->renderJson(method: 'POST'); + $responseData = $this->renderJson(method: 'POST', data: $testData); + + // Assert $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing([], $responseData); } + + /** + * @test + * @testdox Verify appointment pre-confirmation handles invalid input correctly + */ + public function testRenderingWithInvalidInput() { + // Arrange + $invalidData = [ + 'appointmentId' => '', + 'email' => 'invalid-email' + ]; + + // Act & Assert + $this->expectException(\InvalidArgumentException::class); + $this->renderJson(method: 'POST', data: $invalidData); + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php (1)
7-7: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add error handling for bootstrap file inclusion.
The bootstrap file inclusion lacks error handling and path validation.
-require(dirname(dirname(__DIR__)) . '/bootstrap.php'); +$bootstrapPath = dirname(dirname(__DIR__)) . '/bootstrap.php'; +if (!file_exists($bootstrapPath)) { + throw new RuntimeException(sprintf('Bootstrap file not found at: %s', $bootstrapPath)); +} +require $bootstrapPath;📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.$bootstrapPath = dirname(dirname(__DIR__)) . '/bootstrap.php'; if (!file_exists($bootstrapPath)) { throw new RuntimeException(sprintf('Bootstrap file not found at: %s', $bootstrapPath)); } require $bootstrapPath;zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirm.php (3)
10-16:
⚠️ Potential issueMissing implementation for appointment confirmation logic
The current implementation returns an empty array without actually confirming any appointment. This endpoint should:
- Validate the appointment data from the request
- Perform the confirmation logic
- Return appropriate success/error responses
Consider implementing the confirmation logic like this:
public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) { - return Render::withJson($response, []); + try { + $data = $request->getParsedBody(); + + // Validate required fields + if (!isset($data['appointmentId'])) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Appointment ID is required'); + } + + // TODO: Add appointment confirmation logic here + // $result = $this->appointmentService->confirm($data['appointmentId']); + + return Render::withJson($response, [ + 'status' => 'success', + 'message' => 'Appointment confirmed successfully' + ]); + } catch (\InvalidArgumentException $e) { + return Render::withJson($response->withStatus(400), [ + 'status' => 'error', + 'message' => $e->getMessage() + ]); + } catch (\Exception $e) { + return Render::withJson($response->withStatus(500), [ + 'status' => 'error', + 'message' => 'Failed to confirm appointment' + ]); + } }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
12-15: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add logging for appointment confirmation actions
For an important operation like appointment confirmation, it's crucial to log the action for audit and debugging purposes.
Consider adding logging:
public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) { + $logger = $this->getLogger(); + $logger->info('Attempting to confirm appointment', [ + 'method' => __METHOD__, + 'appointmentId' => $request->getParsedBody()['appointmentId'] ?? null + ]); return Render::withJson($response, []); }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
1-16: 💡 Codebase verification
Based on the gathered information, I can now provide the final response:
AppointmentConfirm endpoint needs proper integration with ProcessStatus and notification system
The current implementation returns an empty response
[], but should:
- Update the appointment status to 'confirmed' using
ProcessStatus::writeUpdatedStatus- Trigger confirmation notification via
ProcessConfirmationNotificationRequired changes:
- Integrate with
\BO\Zmsdb\Helper\ProcessStatus::writeUpdatedStatus()to update status- Add notification handling using
\BO\Zmsapi\ProcessConfirmationNotification::writeNotification()- Return proper response according to
appointmentConfirm.jsonschema🔗 Analysis chain
Verify integration with appointment service and event system
The confirmation endpoint should integrate with the appointment service and potentially trigger notifications.
Let's check for related appointment services and event handlers:
Let's gather more information about the appointment confirmation implementation and related code.
Let's check the implementation of the appointment confirmation process and notification system.
Let's check the schema and notification implementation details to complete our verification.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Look for appointment service implementations echo "Searching for appointment service implementations..." rg -l "class.*Appointment.*Service" --type php # Look for event handlers related to appointments echo "Searching for appointment-related event handlers..." rg -l "class.*Appointment.*Event" --type php # Check for other confirmation-related endpoints echo "Searching for other confirmation-related endpoints..." rg -l "confirm.*appointment" --type phpLength of output: 549
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the routing configuration for appointment confirmation echo "Checking routing configuration..." cat zmscitizenapi/routing.php # Look for appointment-related classes and methods echo "Searching for appointment-related implementations..." rg -A 5 "class.*Appointment" --type php # Check ProcessStatus helper for appointment confirmation logic echo "Checking ProcessStatus helper..." cat zmsdb/src/Zmsdb/Helper/ProcessStatus.php # Search for any notification or event-related code echo "Searching for notification/event handling..." rg -l "notification|event|notify" --type phpLength of output: 54735
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the ProcessStatus helper implementation for confirmation logic echo "Checking ProcessStatus confirmation implementation..." rg -A 10 "setStatusConfirmed|writeUpdatedStatus" zmsdb/src/Zmsdb/Helper/ProcessStatus.php # Check for notification implementations related to appointment confirmation echo "Checking notification implementations..." rg -A 10 "ProcessConfirmationNotification" --type php # Check for appointment confirmation schema echo "Checking appointment confirmation schema..." fd "appointmentConfirm.json" --type fLength of output: 4849
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the appointment confirmation schema echo "Checking appointment confirmation schema content..." cat zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/appointmentConfirm.json # Check the confirmation notification implementation echo "Checking confirmation notification implementation..." cat zmsapi/src/Zmsapi/ProcessConfirmationNotification.php # Check for any mail template related to confirmation echo "Checking for confirmation mail templates..." rg -l "confirm.*mail|mail.*confirm" --type phpLength of output: 3774
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentPreconfirm.php (2)
12-15:
⚠️ Potential issueImplement proper request handling and validation
The current implementation returns an empty array without processing the request data. This could lead to security issues and undefined behavior.
Consider the following improvements:
- Add return type hint
- Validate request payload
- Add error handling
- Document the expected request/response format
Here's a suggested implementation:
+ /** + * Process appointment pre-confirmation request + * + * @param RequestInterface $request The HTTP request + * @param ResponseInterface $response The HTTP response + * @param array $args Route parameters + * + * @return ResponseInterface + * @throws \InvalidArgumentException When request data is invalid + */ - public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) + public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args): ResponseInterface { - return Render::withJson($response, []); + $data = $request->getParsedBody(); + + if (!$this->validateRequestData($data)) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Invalid request data'); + } + + // Process pre-confirmation logic here + $result = [ + 'status' => 'pending', + 'message' => 'Pre-confirmation processed' + // Add more relevant response data + ]; + + return Render::withJson($response, $result); } + + /** + * Validates the request data + * + * @param mixed $data The request data to validate + * @return bool + */ + private function validateRequestData($data): bool + { + // Implement validation logic + return true; + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
1-16: 💡 Codebase verification
Based on the collected evidence, I can now provide a final response:
Empty implementation needs attention in appointment workflow
The
AppointmentPreconfirmendpoint is currently returning an empty response ([]), while being part of a complex appointment booking system that includes reservation, confirmation, and cancellation flows. The implementation is incomplete as:
- The endpoint is properly registered in the routing with POST method and documented in Swagger
- Related classes (
AppointmentReserve,AppointmentConfirm) have proper implementations with validation and business logic- The test only verifies the empty response, suggesting this is a placeholder implementation
🔗 Analysis chain
Verify integration with appointment workflow
The class seems to be part of a larger appointment booking system. Let's verify its integration points.
Let me gather more information about the appointment workflow by checking the test file and related classes.
Let me check the routing and API documentation to understand the expected workflow better.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for related appointment handling classes and workflow # Look for other appointment-related classes echo "Related appointment classes:" rg -l "class.*Appointment" --type php # Check for usage of this endpoint in tests echo "\nEndpoint usage in tests:" rg -A 5 "preconfirm-appointment" --type php # Look for workflow documentation echo "\nWorkflow documentation:" fd -e md -e txt | xargs rg -l "appointment.*workflow"Length of output: 3230
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the test implementation and related classes # Look at the test file content echo "Test file content:" cat zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentPreconfirmTest.php # Check the implementation of related appointment classes echo "\nAppointmentReserve implementation:" cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php echo "\nAppointmentConfirm implementation:" cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirm.php # Check README for workflow documentation echo "\nREADME workflow section:" rg -A 10 "appointment.*workflow" README.mdLength of output: 6298
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check API documentation and routing # Look for API documentation echo "API Documentation:" rg -A 10 "/preconfirm-appointment/" --type yaml --type json # Check the routing implementation echo "\nRouting implementation:" rg -B 5 -A 10 "/preconfirm-appointment/" zmscitizenapi/routing.php # Look for any middleware that might be involved echo "\nMiddleware checks:" rg -l "middleware.*appointment" --type phpLength of output: 1021
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentCancel.php (1)
12-15:
⚠️ Potential issueImplementation is incomplete and potentially unsafe.
The current implementation has several critical issues:
- No validation of request payload
- Missing actual cancellation logic
- No error handling
- Returns empty response without status indication
This could lead to silent failures where users think their cancellation succeeded when it didn't.
Consider implementing the following structure:
- public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) - { - return Render::withJson($response, []); - } + /** + * Cancel an appointment. + * + * @param RequestInterface $request The request object + * @param ResponseInterface $response The response object + * @param array $args Route arguments + * @return ResponseInterface + * @throws \InvalidArgumentException When request payload is invalid + * @throws \RuntimeException When cancellation fails + */ + public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) + { + try { + // 1. Validate request payload + $data = $this->validateRequest($request); + + // 2. Process cancellation + $result = $this->processCancellation($data); + + // 3. Return success response + return Render::withJson( + $response, + [ + 'status' => 'success', + 'message' => 'Appointment cancelled successfully', + 'data' => $result + ], + 200 + ); + } catch (\InvalidArgumentException $e) { + return Render::withJson( + $response, + [ + 'status' => 'error', + 'message' => $e->getMessage() + ], + 400 + ); + } catch (\Exception $e) { + return Render::withJson( + $response, + [ + 'status' => 'error', + 'message' => 'Failed to cancel appointment' + ], + 500 + ); + } + }Would you like me to help implement the
validateRequestandprocessCancellationmethods?Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/CaptchaServiceInterface.php (1)
5-22: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider avoiding static methods in the interface design
Static methods in interfaces can lead to several issues:
- Reduced testability as static methods are harder to mock
- Limited flexibility in implementation
- Prevention of proper dependency injection
Consider this alternative design:
interface CaptchaServiceInterface { /** * Gibt die Captcha-Konfigurationsdetails zurück. * * @return array */ - public static function getCaptchaDetails(): array; + public function getCaptchaDetails(): array; /** * Überprüft die Captcha-Lösung. * * @param string $solution * @return mixed * @throws \Exception */ - public static function verifyCaptcha(string $solution); + public function verifyCaptcha(string $solution): bool; }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.interface CaptchaServiceInterface { /** * Gibt die Captcha-Konfigurationsdetails zurück. * * @return array */ public function getCaptchaDetails(): array; /** * Überprüft die Captcha-Lösung. * * @param string $solution * @return mixed * @throws \Exception */ public function verifyCaptcha(string $solution): bool; }zmscitizenapi/config.example.php (2)
2-3: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance environment variable handling for security and robustness
The current implementation has several potential issues:
- The hardcoded localhost URL could accidentally be used in production
- No validation of the API URL format
- Direct use of
getenv()without checking if the variable exists firstConsider this safer implementation:
-define('ZMS_API_URL', getenv('ZMS_API_URL') ? getenv('ZMS_API_URL') : 'https://localhost/terminvereinbarung/api/2'); +$apiUrl = getenv('ZMS_API_URL'); +if (!$apiUrl) { + if (getenv('APP_ENV') === 'production') { + throw new \RuntimeException('ZMS_API_URL must be set in production environment'); + } + $apiUrl = 'https://localhost/terminvereinbarung/api/2'; +} +if (!filter_var($apiUrl, FILTER_VALIDATE_URL)) { + throw new \RuntimeException('ZMS_API_URL must be a valid URL'); +} +define('ZMS_API_URL', $apiUrl);Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
5-16: 💡 Codebase verification
Constants should be moved to static properties for consistency
The current implementation defines constants that mirror functionality already handled by static properties in the parent class. Specifically:
MAINTENANCE_MODE_ENABLEDis redundant withApplication::$MAINTENANCE_MODE_ENABLEDZMS_API_URLshould follow the same pattern as other HTTP-related configurations in the parent classSuggested implementation:
class App extends \BO\Zmscitizenapi\Application { /** * Base URL for the ZMS API endpoints * @var string */ public static string $ZMS_API_URL; /** * Static initializer extension */ public static function initialize() { parent::initialize(); self::$ZMS_API_URL = ZMS_API_URL; } }🔗 Analysis chain
Consider improving class structure and documentation
The current implementation could benefit from some architectural improvements:
- Consider using private constants or class properties instead of public constants
- PHPDoc comments could be more descriptive and include @var annotations
Consider this enhanced implementation:
class App extends \BO\Zmscitizenapi\Application { /** - * HTTP url for api + * Base URL for the ZMS API endpoints + * @var string */ const ZMS_API_URL = ZMS_API_URL; /** - * Flag for enabling maintenance mode + * Controls whether the application is in maintenance mode + * When enabled, all requests will return a maintenance page + * @var bool */ const MAINTENANCE_MODE_ENABLED = MAINTENANCE_MODE_ENABLED; }Let's verify the parent class existence:
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if the parent class exists in the codebase rg -l "class Application" --type phpLength of output: 387
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's verify the specific parent class content cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Application.phpLength of output: 1743
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopesList.php (1)
14-16:
⚠️ Potential issueAdd error handling and array access safety checks.
The current implementation lacks error handling for potential failures from
getScopes()and doesn't verify the existence of the 'status' key.- $scopes = ZmsApiFacadeService::getScopes(); - - return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $scopes, statusCode: $scopes['status']); + try { + $scopes = ZmsApiFacadeService::getScopes(); + + if (!isset($scopes['status'])) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Invalid scope response format: missing status'); + } + + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $scopes, statusCode: $scopes['status']); + } catch (\Exception $e) { + return $this->createJsonResponse( + $response, + ['error' => $e->getMessage()], + statusCode: 500 + ); + }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.try { $scopes = ZmsApiFacadeService::getScopes(); if (!isset($scopes['status'])) { throw new \RuntimeException('Invalid scope response format: missing status'); } return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $scopes, statusCode: $scopes['status']); } catch (\Exception $e) { return $this->createJsonResponse( $response, ['error' => $e->getMessage()], statusCode: 500 ); }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesList.php (2)
16-16: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Validate status code before using it in response.
The code directly uses the status from the response array without validation. This could lead to invalid HTTP status codes.
- return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $offices, statusCode: $offices['status']); + $statusCode = isset($offices['status']) && is_int($offices['status']) + ? $offices['status'] + : 200; // Default to 200 OK if status is invalid + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $offices, statusCode: $statusCode);📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.$statusCode = isset($offices['status']) && is_int($offices['status']) ? $offices['status'] : 200; // Default to 200 OK if status is invalid return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $offices, statusCode: $statusCode);
14-14: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider dependency injection instead of static facade call.
The direct use of static facade method
ZmsApiFacadeService::getOffices()creates tight coupling and makes the code harder to test. Consider injecting the service as a dependency.class OfficesList extends BaseController { + private $apiFacadeService; + + public function __construct(ZmsApiFacadeService $apiFacadeService) + { + $this->apiFacadeService = $apiFacadeService; + } + public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) { - $offices = ZmsApiFacadeService::getOffices(); + $offices = $this->apiFacadeService->getOffices();Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesList.php (1)
12-17: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve error handling and input validation.
Several improvements are needed for robustness:
- Add error handling for potential failures in
getServices().- Validate the status code before using it in the response.
- Consider dependency injection instead of static service call.
Here's a suggested implementation:
+ /** + * Retrieve and return the list of available services. + * + * @param RequestInterface $request The incoming request + * @param ResponseInterface $response The response object + * @param array $args Route arguments + * @return ResponseInterface + * @throws \RuntimeException When service retrieval fails + */ public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) { - $services = ZmsApiFacadeService::getServices(); + try { + $services = ZmsApiFacadeService::getServices(); + + if (!isset($services['status']) || !is_int($services['status'])) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Invalid status code received from service'); + } - return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $services, statusCode: $services['status']); + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $services, statusCode: $services['status']); + } catch (\Exception $e) { + return $this->createJsonResponse( + $response, + ['error' => 'Failed to retrieve services: ' . $e->getMessage()], + statusCode: 500 + ); + } }Additionally, consider refactoring to use dependency injection:
class ServicesList extends BaseController { private $apiFacadeService; public function __construct(ZmsApiFacadeService $apiFacadeService) { $this->apiFacadeService = $apiFacadeService; } public function readResponse(...) { $services = $this->apiFacadeService->getServices(); // ... rest of the code } }zmscitizenapi/public/doc/index.html (1)
20-21: 💡 Codebase verification
Required assets are generated during build process
Based on the documentation and configuration files:
swagger.jsonis generated during the build process vianpm run doccommand- The documentation README indicates that UI files (including
redoc.min.js) are fetched during CI process and stored at a CDN locationConsider updating the assets URLs to use the CDN version instead of local files:
- <redoc spec-url='./swagger.json' lazy-rendering hide-hostname></redoc> - <script src="./assets/redoc.min.js"> </script> + <redoc spec-url='./swagger.json' lazy-rendering hide-hostname></redoc> + <script src="https://eappointment.gitlab.io/zmsapi/redoc.min.js"></script>🔗 Analysis chain
Verify the existence of referenced assets
The implementation references local assets that need to be present for the documentation to work properly.
Also consider adding integrity checks for the JavaScript file:
- <script src="./assets/redoc.min.js"> </script> + <script src="./assets/redoc.min.js" integrity="sha384-YOURHASHERE" crossorigin="anonymous"> </script>
Let me try a different approach to verify the existence of these files by checking the entire repository, as the specific paths might be different.
Let me check the documentation README and related configuration files to understand how these assets are managed.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check if the required assets exist in the correct locations # Check for swagger.json in the same directory echo "Checking for swagger.json..." fd -t f "swagger.json" "zmscitizenapi/public/doc" # Check for redoc.min.js in the assets directory echo "Checking for redoc.min.js..." fd -t f "redoc.min.js" "zmscitizenapi/public/doc/assets"Length of output: 236
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for these files anywhere in the repository echo "Searching for swagger.json..." fd -t f "swagger.json" echo -e "\nSearching for redoc.min.js..." fd -t f "redoc.min.js" # Let's also check if these files might be generated or referenced elsewhere echo -e "\nChecking for references to swagger.json..." rg "swagger.json" -l echo -e "\nChecking for references to redoc.min.js..." rg "redoc.min.js" -lLength of output: 1094
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the documentation README for setup instructions echo "Checking documentation README..." cat zmscitizenapi/public/doc/README.md # Check package.json for potential build steps or dependencies echo -e "\nChecking package.json..." cat zmscitizenapi/package.json # Check Makefile for documentation-related targets echo -e "\nChecking Makefile for documentation targets..." cat zmscitizenapi/MakefileLength of output: 3451
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableDaysList.php (1)
13-20: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add input validation, error handling, and method documentation.
The method needs several improvements for robustness and maintainability:
- Missing PHPDoc documentation
- No input validation for query parameters
- No error handling for the service call
- Return type hint would improve type safety
Consider applying these improvements:
+ /** + * Retrieves a list of available days based on query parameters. + * + * @param RequestInterface $request The HTTP request + * @param ResponseInterface $response The HTTP response + * @param array $args Route arguments + * @return ResponseInterface JSON response containing available days + * @throws \InvalidArgumentException When required query parameters are missing + */ - public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) + public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args): ResponseInterface { $queryParams = $request->getQueryParams(); + + // Validate required query parameters + $requiredParams = ['param1', 'param2']; // Add your required parameters + foreach ($requiredParams as $param) { + if (!isset($queryParams[$param])) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException("Missing required parameter: {$param}"); + } + } - $result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getBookableFreeDays($queryParams); + try { + $result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getBookableFreeDays($queryParams); + } catch (\Exception $e) { + return $this->createJsonResponse( + $response, + ['error' => 'Failed to retrieve available days'], + 500 + ); + } return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result, $result['status']); }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsList.php (1)
12-19: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add input validation and error handling.
The current implementation has several areas that could be improved for robustness and maintainability:
- Query parameters are passed directly without validation
- No error handling for the service call
- Implicit assumption that 'status' exists in the result
- Missing method documentation
Consider applying these improvements:
+ /** + * Retrieves available appointments based on query parameters + * + * @param RequestInterface $request The HTTP request + * @param ResponseInterface $response The HTTP response + * @param array $args Route arguments + * @return ResponseInterface JSON response with available appointments + * @throws \InvalidArgumentException When required parameters are missing + */ public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) { $queryParams = $request->getQueryParams(); + + // Validate required parameters + $requiredParams = ['param1', 'param2']; // Add your required parameters + foreach ($requiredParams as $param) { + if (!isset($queryParams[$param])) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException("Missing required parameter: {$param}"); + } + } - $result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getAvailableAppointments($queryParams); + try { + $result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getAvailableAppointments($queryParams); + } catch (\Exception $e) { + return $this->createJsonResponse( + $response, + ['error' => $e->getMessage()], + statusCode: 500 + ); + } - return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result, statusCode: $result['status']); + $statusCode = $result['status'] ?? 200; + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result, statusCode: $statusCode); }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/package.json (3)
17-19: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Move swagger-cli to devDependencies
The
@apidevtools/swagger-clipackage is used for documentation generation and should be in devDependencies since it's not required for production runtime."dependencies": { - "@apidevtools/swagger-cli": "^4.0.4" }, "devDependencies": { + "@apidevtools/swagger-cli": "^4.0.4", "swagger-jsdoc": "^6.1.0",📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements."dependencies": { },
9-10: 💡 Codebase verification
Add generated Swagger documentation to .gitignore
The verification revealed:
- The build script exists at
zmscitizenapi/bin/build_swagger.js- The output directory exists at
zmscitizenapi/public/doc/- The generated
swagger.jsonis not listed in.gitignorePlease add the following to
.gitignore:
zmscitizenapi/public/doc/swagger.jsonThis will prevent the generated documentation from being tracked in version control.
🔗 Analysis chain
Verify build script dependencies and output paths
Please ensure:
- The build script path
./bin/build_swagger.jsexists- The swagger documentation output directory
public/doc/exists- The swagger.json output is added to .gitignore if it's generated
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if build script exists fd --type f --full-path "zmscitizenapi/bin/build_swagger.js" # Check if public/doc directory exists fd --type d --full-path "zmscitizenapi/public/doc" # Check if swagger.json is in .gitignore rg "public/doc/swagger.json" .gitignoreLength of output: 280
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if swagger.json exists in the repository fd swagger.json # Check content of .gitignore to see if there are any swagger-related patterns cat .gitignore # Check if there are any other swagger files that might be used as source fd swagger.yamlLength of output: 192
2-6: 💡 Codebase verification
index.jsis missing but specified as main entry pointThe verification revealed that:
index.jsis missing from the project directory- The only JavaScript file present is
bin/build_swagger.js- The package.json defines build and documentation scripts but no start script
- The project appears to be focused on Swagger/OpenAPI documentation generation
This suggests that either:
- The main entry point file is missing and needs to be created
- The wrong main entry point is specified in package.json
Please create the missing
index.jsfile or update themainfield in package.json to point to the correct entry point.🔗 Analysis chain
Consider starting with version 0.1.0 for new projects
Following semantic versioning best practices, new projects typically start with version 0.x.x until they reach a stable API. Additionally, verify that
index.jsexists as it's specified as the main entry point.🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if index.js exists in the project root fd --type f --full-path "zmscitizenapi/index.js"Length of output: 48
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's try to find any JavaScript files in the zmscitizenapi directory fd -e js --type f --full-path "zmscitizenapi/" # Also check if there are any TypeScript files as an alternative fd -e ts --type f --full-path "zmscitizenapi/" # Let's also check the package.json to see if there are any start/main scripts defined cat zmscitizenapi/package.jsonLength of output: 889
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesByOfficeList.php (1)
13-24:
⚠️ Potential issueAdd input validation and improve error handling.
The method needs several improvements for robustness and maintainability:
- Validate office IDs before processing
- Add proper error handling for the service call
- Add type hints and documentation
Here's the suggested implementation:
+ /** + * Retrieve services for given office IDs. + * + * @param RequestInterface $request The HTTP request + * @param ResponseInterface $response The HTTP response + * @param array $args Route arguments + * @return ResponseInterface JSON response with services or error + */ public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) { - $officeIds = explode(',', $request->getQueryParams()['officeId'] ?? ''); + $officeId = $request->getQueryParams()['officeId'] ?? ''; + if (empty($officeId)) { + return $this->createJsonResponse( + $response, + ['errors' => ['officeId parameter is required']], + 400 + ); + } + + $officeIds = array_filter(explode(',', $officeId)); + if (empty($officeIds)) { + return $this->createJsonResponse( + $response, + ['errors' => ['Invalid office IDs provided']], + 400 + ); + } - $result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getServicesByOfficeIds($officeIds); + try { + $result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getServicesByOfficeIds($officeIds); + } catch (\Exception $e) { + return $this->createJsonResponse( + $response, + ['errors' => ['Failed to retrieve services: ' . $e->getMessage()]], + 500 + ); + } - if (isset($result['errors'])) { + if (!is_array($result) || isset($result['errors'])) { return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result, $result['status']); } + if (!isset($result['services']) || !isset($result['status'])) { + return $this->createJsonResponse( + $response, + ['errors' => ['Invalid response format from service']], + 500 + ); + } return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result['services'], $result['status']); }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements./** * Retrieve services for given office IDs. * * @param RequestInterface $request The HTTP request * @param ResponseInterface $response The HTTP response * @param array $args Route arguments * @return ResponseInterface JSON response with services or error */ public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) { $officeId = $request->getQueryParams()['officeId'] ?? ''; if (empty($officeId)) { return $this->createJsonResponse( $response, ['errors' => ['officeId parameter is required']], 400 ); } $officeIds = array_filter(explode(',', $officeId)); if (empty($officeIds)) { return $this->createJsonResponse( $response, ['errors' => ['Invalid office IDs provided']], 400 ); } try { $result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getServicesByOfficeIds($officeIds); } catch (\Exception $e) { return $this->createJsonResponse( $response, ['errors' => ['Failed to retrieve services: ' . $e->getMessage()]], 500 ); } if (!is_array($result) || isset($result['errors'])) { return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result, $result['status']); } if (!isset($result['services']) || !isset($result['status'])) { return $this->createJsonResponse( $response, ['errors' => ['Invalid response format from service']], 500 ); } return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result['services'], $result['status']); }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Middleware/MaintenanceMiddleware.php (2)
14-27:
⚠️ Potential issueCritical: Fix PSR-15 compliance issues
Several critical issues need to be addressed:
- The middleware should use
process()method instead of__invoke()as per PSR-15- The method must return a
ResponseInterfaceinstance, not an array- The maintenance mode check should be more robust
Apply these changes:
- public function __invoke(ServerRequestInterface $request, RequestHandlerInterface $next) + public function process(ServerRequestInterface $request, RequestHandlerInterface $handler): ResponseInterface { - if (\App::MAINTENANCE_MODE_ENABLED) + if ($this->isMaintenanceMode()) { - $errors[] = [ - 'errorCode' => self::ERROR_UNAVAILABLE, - 'errorMessage' => 'Service Unavailable: The application is under maintenance.', - 'status' => self::HTTP_UNAVAILABLE, - ]; - - return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => self::HTTP_UNAVAILABLE]; + return new JsonResponse( + [ + 'errors' => [ + [ + 'errorCode' => self::ERROR_UNAVAILABLE, + 'errorMessage' => 'Service Unavailable: The application is under maintenance.', + 'status' => self::HTTP_UNAVAILABLE, + ] + ] + ], + self::HTTP_UNAVAILABLE + ); } - return $next->handle($request); + return $handler->handle($request); } + + private function isMaintenanceMode(): bool + { + return defined('\\App::MAINTENANCE_MODE_ENABLED') && \App::MAINTENANCE_MODE_ENABLED === true; + }Don't forget to add the necessary import:
use Psr\Http\Message\ResponseInterface; use BO\Zmscitizenapi\Http\JsonResponse;
8-13:
⚠️ Potential issueImplement PSR-15 MiddlewareInterface
The class should implement
Psr\Http\Server\MiddlewareInterfaceto ensure compatibility with PSR-15 middleware handlers.Apply this diff:
-class MaintenanceMiddleware +use Psr\Http\Server\MiddlewareInterface; + +class MaintenanceMiddleware implements MiddlewareInterfaceAlso, consider making the error code more specific to maintenance mode:
- private const ERROR_UNAVAILABLE = 'serviceUnavailable'; + private const ERROR_UNAVAILABLE = 'maintenanceModeActive';📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.use Psr\Http\Server\MiddlewareInterface; class MaintenanceMiddleware implements MiddlewareInterface { private const HTTP_UNAVAILABLE = 503; private const ERROR_UNAVAILABLE = 'maintenanceModeActive';zmscitizenapi/phpunit.xml (2)
22-26: 💡 Codebase verification
Source directory is missing for code coverage configuration
The coverage configuration in
phpunit.xmlreferences a non-existent./srcdirectory. This will prevent PHPUnit from properly collecting code coverage data.
- The
<directory suffix=".php">./src</directory>path needs to be updated to match the actual source code location in the project.🔗 Analysis chain
Verify source directory for coverage analysis
The coverage configuration includes PHP files from the ./src directory. Let's verify its existence and structure.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check source directory structure if [ -d "src" ]; then echo "Source directory exists" # List PHP files that would be included in coverage find src -name "*.php" -type f else echo "Source directory not found" fiLength of output: 79
7-7: 💡 Codebase verification
Bootstrap file path in phpunit.xml needs correction
The bootstrap file path in phpunit.xml is incorrect. The file exists at
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php, but the configuration points totests/Zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php. The path should be relative to the phpunit.xml location.🔗 Analysis chain
Verify bootstrap file existence
Ensure that the bootstrap file exists at the specified path.
Let me verify if the bootstrap file exists in a different location by searching for it.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if the bootstrap file exists if [ -f "tests/Zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php" ]; then echo "Bootstrap file exists" else echo "Bootstrap file not found" fiLength of output: 105
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for bootstrap.php files in the repository fd bootstrap.phpLength of output: 784
zmscitizenapi/public/doc/partials/info.yaml (1)
15-17:
⚠️ Potential issueUpdate placeholder contact information
The contact information appears to use placeholder values:
- Empty contact name
- Example email address (
[email protected])Please update these with the appropriate contact details for the ZMSCitizenAPI team.
zmscitizenapi/bin/configure (5)
3-6: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve path resolution robustness
The path resolution logic needs better error handling and protection against paths with spaces.
Apply this diff to improve the code:
-REALPATH=$(which realpath || which readlink) -REALPATH=$([[ "$REALPATH" =~ 'readlink' ]] && echo "$REALPATH -e" || echo "$REALPATH") -DIR=$(dirname $($REALPATH ${BASH_SOURCE[0]})) -ROOT=$($REALPATH $DIR/..) +if ! REALPATH=$(which realpath 2>/dev/null || which readlink 2>/dev/null); then + echo "Error: Neither 'realpath' nor 'readlink' found in PATH" >&2 + exit 1 +fi +REALPATH_CMD=$([[ "$REALPATH" =~ readlink$ ]] && echo "$REALPATH -e" || echo "$REALPATH") +DIR=$(dirname "$($REALPATH_CMD "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")") +ROOT=$($REALPATH_CMD "$DIR/..")📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.if ! REALPATH=$(which realpath 2>/dev/null || which readlink 2>/dev/null); then echo "Error: Neither 'realpath' nor 'readlink' found in PATH" >&2 exit 1 fi REALPATH_CMD=$([[ "$REALPATH" =~ readlink$ ]] && echo "$REALPATH -e" || echo "$REALPATH") DIR=$(dirname "$($REALPATH_CMD "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")") ROOT=$($REALPATH_CMD "$DIR/..")
11-16: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance Git hooks setup reliability
The Git hooks setup needs better error handling and permission checks.
Apply this diff to improve the code:
-echo -n "Configuring application" -mkdir -p $ROOT/.git/hooks -ln -sf $ROOT/bin/test $ROOT/.git/hooks/pre-commit -ln -sf $ROOT/bin/configure $ROOT/.git/hooks/post-checkout -ln -sf $ROOT/bin/configure $ROOT/.git/hooks/post-commit -ln -sf $ROOT/bin/configure $ROOT/.git/hooks/post-merge +echo -n "Configuring application..." + +# Ensure hooks directory exists +if ! mkdir -p "$ROOT/.git/hooks"; then + echo "Error: Failed to create hooks directory" >&2 + exit 1 +fi + +# Verify test script exists +if [ ! -f "$ROOT/bin/test" ]; then + echo "Error: pre-commit hook script not found: $ROOT/bin/test" >&2 + exit 1 +fi + +# Setup hooks with error checking +for hook in "pre-commit:test" "post-checkout:configure" "post-commit:configure" "post-merge:configure"; do + name="${hook%:*}" + script="${hook#*:}" + if ! ln -sf "$ROOT/bin/$script" "$ROOT/.git/hooks/$name"; then + echo "Error: Failed to create $name hook" >&2 + exit 1 + fi + chmod +x "$ROOT/.git/hooks/$name" 2>/dev/null || echo "Warning: Failed to set execute permission on $name hook" +done📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.echo -n "Configuring application..." # Ensure hooks directory exists if ! mkdir -p "$ROOT/.git/hooks"; then echo "Error: Failed to create hooks directory" >&2 exit 1 fi # Verify test script exists if [ ! -f "$ROOT/bin/test" ]; then echo "Error: pre-commit hook script not found: $ROOT/bin/test" >&2 exit 1 fi # Setup hooks with error checking for hook in "pre-commit:test" "post-checkout:configure" "post-commit:configure" "post-merge:configure"; do name="${hook%:*}" script="${hook#*:}" if ! ln -sf "$ROOT/bin/$script" "$ROOT/.git/hooks/$name"; then echo "Error: Failed to create $name hook" >&2 exit 1 fi chmod +x "$ROOT/.git/hooks/$name" 2>/dev/null || echo "Warning: Failed to set execute permission on $name hook" done
18-22:
⚠️ Potential issueImprove configuration management security and reliability
The configuration setup has security and reliability concerns:
- The cache directory permissions are too permissive
- Error handling needs improvement
- No validation of the example config file
Apply this diff to improve the code:
-if [ ! -e $ROOT/config.php ] -then - cp $ROOT/config.example.php $ROOT/config.php -fi -test -d $ROOT/cache && chmod -fR a+rwX $ROOT/cache || echo "Could not chmod cache files" +# Check and copy config file +if [ ! -f "$ROOT/config.php" ]; then + if [ ! -f "$ROOT/config.example.php" ]; then + echo "Error: Example configuration file not found" >&2 + exit 1 + fi + if ! cp "$ROOT/config.example.php" "$ROOT/config.php"; then + echo "Error: Failed to create config.php" >&2 + exit 1 + fi + echo "Created config.php from example" +fi + +# Set restrictive cache permissions +if [ -d "$ROOT/cache" ]; then + # Use more restrictive permissions (group writable only) + if ! chmod -R 775 "$ROOT/cache" 2>/dev/null; then + echo "Error: Failed to set cache directory permissions" >&2 + exit 1 + fi +else + echo "Warning: Cache directory not found" >&2 +fi📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.# Check and copy config file if [ ! -f "$ROOT/config.php" ]; then if [ ! -f "$ROOT/config.example.php" ]; then echo "Error: Example configuration file not found" >&2 exit 1 fi if ! cp "$ROOT/config.example.php" "$ROOT/config.php"; then echo "Error: Failed to create config.php" >&2 exit 1 fi echo "Created config.php from example" fi # Set restrictive cache permissions if [ -d "$ROOT/cache" ]; then # Use more restrictive permissions (group writable only) if ! chmod -R 775 "$ROOT/cache" 2>/dev/null; then echo "Error: Failed to set cache directory permissions" >&2 exit 1 fi else echo "Warning: Cache directory not found" >&2 fi
25-28: 💡 Codebase verification
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Version management needs consistent error handling across all services
The verification reveals that the same version management pattern is used across multiple services (zmscitizenapi, zmsstatistic, zmsapi, zmsadmin), and the VERSION file is a critical component used by the documentation build process. The suggested improvements should be applied consistently across all services.
zmscitizenapi/bin/configurezmsstatistic/bin/configurezmsapi/bin/configurezmsadmin/bin/configureAll these files use the same version extraction approach without error handling, and the VERSION file they generate is required for the documentation process as confirmed by the README files.
🔗 Analysis chain
Enhance version management reliability
The version management needs better error handling and should document the versioning strategy choice.
Apply this diff to improve the code:
-#VERSION=`git symbolic-ref -q --short HEAD || git describe --tags --exact-match` -VERSION=`git describe --tags --always` -echo $VERSION > $ROOT/VERSION -echo " $VERSION" +# Ensure we're in a git repository +if ! git rev-parse --git-dir > /dev/null 2>&1; then + echo "Error: Not in a git repository" >&2 + exit 1 +fi + +# Get version information +if ! VERSION=$(git describe --tags --always 2>/dev/null); then + echo "Error: Failed to determine version" >&2 + exit 1 +fi + +# Write version file +if ! echo "$VERSION" > "$ROOT/VERSION"; then + echo "Error: Failed to write VERSION file" >&2 + exit 1 +fi + +echo " $VERSION"Note: The commented version strategy using
git symbolic-refwas likely removed in favor of a simpler tag-based approach. Consider documenting this decision in a comment if it's significant for the project's versioning strategy.Let's check the current versioning approach across the project:
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for version-related patterns echo "Checking version handling in other files..." rg -l "git describe|VERSION file"Length of output: 294
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check the content of configure scripts and READMEs to understand version handling echo "=== Content of configure scripts ===" for file in zmscitizenapi/bin/configure zmsstatistic/bin/configure zmsapi/bin/configure zmsadmin/bin/configure; do echo "=== $file ===" cat "$file" | grep -A 5 -B 5 "VERSION" done echo -e "\n=== Content of README files ===" for file in zmscitizenapi/public/doc/README.md zmsapi/public/doc/README.md; do echo "=== $file ===" cat "$file" | grep -A 5 -B 5 "VERSION" doneLength of output: 4847
8-9: 💡 Codebase verification
Remove commented DLDB export code
The DLDB export functionality is commented out in both
zmscitizenapi/bin/configureandzmsapi/bin/configurefiles, and the actual script exists atzmsapi/bin/getDldbExport. Since this functionality has been intentionally disabled in both configuration files and there are no active references to it in the codebase (outside of test fixtures and templates), the commented code should be removed to maintain clean and unambiguous configuration files.🔗 Analysis chain
Remove or document commented code
The commented DLDB export code lacks context and explanation. If this functionality is needed, it should be uncommented and documented. If not, it should be removed.
Let's check if this DLDB export functionality is used elsewhere:
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for getDldbExport references rg -l "getDldbExport"Length of output: 70
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check if getDldbExport script exists and its content fd getDldbExport # Also check for any DLDB related functionality rg -i "dldb" -A 3Length of output: 130663
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check if getDldbExport script exists and its content cat zmsapi/bin/getDldbExport # Also check if there are any active references to DLDB exports in the codebase rg -i "getDldbExport" -A 3 -g '!{*.json,*.yaml,*.twig}'Length of output: 744
zmscitizenapi/Makefile (3)
31-32: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Review parallel test process count and add error handling.
The current implementation has several concerns:
- 20 parallel processes might be excessive and could overwhelm the system
- No error handling
- No cleanup of previous coverage reports
paratest: # init parallel unit testing with 5 processes - vendor/bin/paratest -p20 --coverage-html public/_tests/coverage/ + rm -rf public/_tests/coverage/ + vendor/bin/paratest -p8 --coverage-html public/_tests/coverage/ || exit 1Consider reducing the process count to a more reasonable number (e.g., 8) to prevent system resource exhaustion.
📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.paratest: # init parallel unit testing with 5 processes rm -rf public/_tests/coverage/ vendor/bin/paratest -p8 --coverage-html public/_tests/coverage/ || exit 1
13-20: 💡 Codebase verification
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Fix missing Swagger file and update error handling in live target
Based on the verification results:
- The
bin/configurescript exists and is executable ✓swagger-cliis available as a dependency (@apidevtools/swagger-cli) ✓- The
swagger.yamlfile is missing, but it's generated by thebuildscript ✓The live target needs to be updated to:
live: # init live system, delete unnecessary libs - composer install --no-dev --prefer-dist - bin/configure - npm install - npm run build - npm run doc - npx swagger-cli bundle -o public/doc/swagger.json public/doc/swagger.yaml + composer install --no-dev --prefer-dist || exit 1 + ./bin/configure || exit 1 + npm ci || exit 1 # Using ci for reproducible builds + npm run build || exit 1 # This generates swagger.yaml + npm run doc || exit 1 # This bundles swagger.json from the generated yaml🔗 Analysis chain
Verify dependencies and add error handling for live target.
The live target has several potential issues to address:
- Verify the existence of bin/configure
- Ensure swagger-cli is available
- Add error handling for each step
Consider this enhanced implementation:
live: # init live system, delete unnecessary libs - composer install --no-dev --prefer-dist - bin/configure - npm install - npm run build - npm run doc - npx swagger-cli bundle -o public/doc/swagger.json public/doc/swagger.yaml + composer install --no-dev --prefer-dist || exit 1 + [ -f bin/configure ] && ./bin/configure || exit 1 + npm ci || exit 1 # Using ci instead of install for reproducible builds + npm run build || exit 1 + npm run doc || exit 1 + command -v npx >/dev/null 2>&1 || { echo "npx is required but not installed"; exit 1; } + npx swagger-cli bundle -o public/doc/swagger.json public/doc/swagger.yaml || exit 1🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if required files and tools exist if [ ! -f "bin/configure" ]; then echo "Error: bin/configure script not found" exit 1 fi # Check if package.json includes swagger-cli if [ -f "package.json" ]; then jq '.dependencies["swagger-cli"] // .devDependencies["swagger-cli"]' package.json fiLength of output: 124
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's verify if configure script exists in other locations and check package.json content fd configure test -f package.json && cat package.json # Also check if there's any documentation about the configure script fd README -t f -E node_modulesLength of output: 709
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if the configure script exists in the correct location and is executable test -f zmscitizenapi/bin/configure && echo "Configure script exists" || echo "Configure script missing" test -x zmscitizenapi/bin/configure && echo "Configure script is executable" || echo "Configure script not executable" # Check package.json in the correct directory test -f zmscitizenapi/package.json && cat zmscitizenapi/package.json # Check if swagger.yaml exists test -f zmscitizenapi/public/doc/swagger.yaml && echo "Swagger file exists" || echo "Swagger file missing"Length of output: 1100
25-27: 💡 Codebase verification
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
The
bin/docscript should be replaced with npm run docThe Makefile's openapi target is incorrectly using a non-existent
bin/docscript, while the actual documentation generation is defined in package.json'sdocnpm script. This script properly handles the Swagger documentation generation through build_swagger.js and swagger-cli bundle.openapi: # Swagger docs on changes - ./bin/doc + npm run doc🔗 Analysis chain
Verify bin/doc script and add error handling.
The openapi target needs verification of the doc script's existence and proper error handling.
openapi: # Swagger docs on changes - ./bin/doc + [ -x bin/doc ] && ./bin/doc || exit 1🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if doc script exists and is executable if [ ! -x "bin/doc" ]; then echo "Error: bin/doc script not found or not executable" exit 1 fiLength of output: 142
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check if the script exists in a different location or with a different name fd doc --type f --type x # Also check for any references to this script in the codebase rg -l "bin/doc" --type makeLength of output: 93
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check the content of both Makefiles to understand the context better echo "=== Content of zmscitizenapi/Makefile ===" cat zmscitizenapi/Makefile echo -e "\n=== Content of zmsapi/Makefile ===" cat zmsapi/Makefile # Also search for any swagger/openapi related files that might indicate the correct location fd -e yaml -e json -e yml . | grep -i "swagger\|openapi"Length of output: 1925
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check for the existence of npm scripts related to doc generation # since we see npm commands in the Makefile echo "=== package.json in zmscitizenapi ===" cat zmscitizenapi/package.json 2>/dev/null | grep -A 5 -B 5 '"doc":' echo -e "\n=== Looking for doc generation scripts ===" fd -t f -e js -e sh doc bin/Length of output: 680
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/Base.php (1)
18-28: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance error handling for JSON decoding.
The method could benefit from better error handling and type safety:
Consider applying these changes:
public function renderJson( array $arguments = [], array $parameters = [], ?array $sessionData = null, string $method = 'GET', array $assertStatusCodes = [ 200 ], ): array { $response = $this->render($arguments, $parameters, $sessionData, $method); $this->assertContains($response->getStatusCode(), $assertStatusCodes); - return json_decode($response->getBody(), true); + $data = json_decode($response->getBody(), true); + if (json_last_error() !== JSON_ERROR_NONE) { + throw new \RuntimeException(sprintf( + 'Failed to decode JSON response: %s', + json_last_error_msg() + )); + } + if (!is_array($data)) { + throw new \UnexpectedValueException( + 'JSON response could not be decoded to array' + ); + } + return $data; }These changes:
- Add explicit error handling for JSON decode failures
- Ensure the decoded result is actually an array
- Provide more descriptive error messages
📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.public function renderJson( array $arguments = [], array $parameters = [], ?array $sessionData = null, string $method = 'GET', array $assertStatusCodes = [ 200 ], ): array { $response = $this->render($arguments, $parameters, $sessionData, $method); $this->assertContains($response->getStatusCode(), $assertStatusCodes); $data = json_decode($response->getBody(), true); if (json_last_error() !== JSON_ERROR_NONE) { throw new \RuntimeException(sprintf( 'Failed to decode JSON response: %s', json_last_error_msg() )); } if (!is_array($data)) { throw new \UnexpectedValueException( 'JSON response could not be decoded to array' ); } return $data; }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGet.php (2)
26-32:
⚠️ Potential issueAdd try-catch block and logging for API calls
The API interaction lacks exception handling and logging, which could make debugging issues difficult in production.
Consider adding error handling:
+try { $result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getScopeByIds($scopeIdParam); +} catch (\Exception $e) { + $this->logger->error('Failed to fetch scopes', [ + 'scopeIds' => $scopeIdParam, + 'error' => $e->getMessage() + ]); + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, [ + 'errors' => ['Internal server error while fetching scopes'] + ], 500); +}Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
13-34: 💡 Codebase verification
Add input validation and rate limiting controls
Based on the code analysis, the endpoint lacks both array size restrictions and rate limiting controls. The
validateScopeIdParammethod only validates that the IDs are numeric but doesn't limit the number of IDs that can be requested.Required security controls:
- Add a maximum limit on the number of scope IDs that can be requested in a single call
- Implement rate limiting middleware to prevent DoS attacks
Example implementation for ValidationService:
public static function validateScopeIdParam(array $serviceIds): array { $errors = []; if (count($serviceIds) > 100) { // Set appropriate limit $errors[] = [ 'scopes' => [], 'errorMessage' => 'Too many scope IDs requested. Maximum allowed is 100.', 'status' => 400, ]; return $errors; } foreach ($serviceIds as $id) { if (!is_numeric($id)) { $errors[] = [ 'scopes' => [], 'errorMessage' => "Invalid scope ID: $id. Must be a number.", 'status' => 400, ]; } } return empty($errors) ? [] : $errors; }🔗 Analysis chain
Verify rate limiting and input size restrictions
The endpoint could be vulnerable to DoS attacks if too many scope IDs are requested in a single call.
Run the following to check for rate limiting middleware:
Consider adding:
- Rate limiting middleware
- Maximum limit on the number of scope IDs that can be requested
- Request size validation
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check for rate limiting implementation rg -A 5 "rate.*limit|throttle" --type php # Check for array size restrictions in the validation service ast-grep --pattern 'class ValidationService { $$$ validateScopeIdParam($$$) { $$$ } $$$ }'Length of output: 148
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's try a broader search for ValidationService class and any input validation rg -l "class ValidationService" --type php | xargs cat # Also check for any middleware classes that might handle request validation fd -e php middleware -X cat # Look for any array size or input validation patterns rg -i "count|sizeof|array_size|max.*length|limit" --type php -A 3Length of output: 153452
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check for any request size validation in the ValidationService class ast-grep --pattern 'validateScopeIdParam($$$) { $$$ }' # Check for any middleware that might handle rate limiting fd -e php -e yaml -e json -X grep -l "middleware\|rate.*limit\|throttle" # Look for any array size restrictions in the code rg "array.*size|max.*length|count.*limit" --type phpLength of output: 1504
zmscitizenapi/public/doc/partials/definitions.yaml (2)
2-13: 💡 Codebase verification
Schema references need to be updated to point to zmsentities
The schema files exist but are located in the
zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/directory instead ofschema/citizenapi/. The references in the YAML file need to be updated to point to the correct location.
- Update all schema references to use the path
zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/instead ofschema/citizenapi/- Example:
$ref: "zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/appointment.json"🔗 Analysis chain
Verify schema files for appointment operations
The schema references follow a consistent naming pattern, but we should verify that all referenced schema files exist.
Let me try to locate these schema files in the repository first, as they might be in a different location.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if all appointment-related schema files exist for schema in appointment appointmentCancel appointmentConfirm appointmentPreconfirm appointmentReserve appointmentUpdate; do if ! fd "^${schema}.json$" "schema/citizenapi/"; then echo "Missing schema file: ${schema}.json" fi doneLength of output: 2267
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for schema files anywhere in the repository for schema in appointment appointmentCancel appointmentConfirm appointmentPreconfirm appointmentReserve appointmentUpdate; do echo "Searching for ${schema}.json:" fd "${schema}.json$" doneLength of output: 2169
30-33: 💡 Codebase verification
Schema files reference incorrect path
The schema files exist but are located at
zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/instead ofschema/citizenapi/. The current references indefinitions.yamlneed to be updated to point to the correct location.
- Update the schema references in
zmscitizenapi/public/doc/partials/definitions.yaml:services: $ref: "../../../zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/services.json" servicesByOffice: $ref: "../../../zmsentities/schema/citizenapi/servicesByOffice.json"🔗 Analysis chain
Verify service discovery schema files
The service discovery endpoints are essential for the API's functionality. Let's verify the schema files exist and have been properly updated for zmscitizenapi.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check if service discovery schema files exist and are properly updated for schema in services servicesByOffice; do if ! fd "^${schema}.json$" "schema/citizenapi/"; then echo "Missing schema file: ${schema}.json" else # Check if any references to zmsapi remain rg "zmsapi" "schema/citizenapi/${schema}.json" && echo "Found old zmsapi reference in ${schema}.json" fi doneLength of output: 561
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's first check if the schema directory exists and its location fd -t d "schema" # Also check for any json files that might contain these schemas fd -e json "services|servicesByOffice" # Let's also check the root directory structure to understand the context ls -laLength of output: 2427
🧰 Tools
🪛 yamllint (1.35.1)
[error] 33-33: no new line character at the end of file
(new-line-at-end-of-file)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceList.php (1)
28-34: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Standardize the response structure for consistency.
The response structure differs between success and error cases:
- Error case: Returns the entire result object
- Success case: Splits the result into offices and status
This inconsistency could confuse API consumers.
Consider standardizing the response:
- if (isset($result['errors'])) { - return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result, $result['status']); - } - - return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $result['offices'], $result['status']); + $responseBody = isset($result['errors']) + ? ['status' => $result['status'], 'errors' => $result['errors']] + : ['status' => $result['status'], 'data' => $result['offices']]; + + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $responseBody, $result['status']);📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.$result = ZmsApiFacadeService::getOfficesByServiceIds($serviceIdParam); $responseBody = isset($result['errors']) ? ['status' => $result['status'], 'errors' => $result['errors']] : ['status' => $result['status'], 'data' => $result['offices']]; return $this->createJsonResponse($response, $responseBody, $result['status']);zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesListTest.php (1)
10-42: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add test cases for error scenarios
The current test only covers the happy path. Consider adding tests for:
- Invalid source responses
- Error status codes
- Malformed data scenarios
Example test method to add:
/** * Tests that the ServicesList handles invalid responses appropriately * * @return void */ public function testRenderingWithInvalidSource() { $this->setApiCalls([ [ 'function' => 'readGetResult', 'url' => '/source/unittest/', 'parameters' => [ 'resolveReferences' => 2, ], 'response' => ['error' => 'Invalid source'], 'status' => 404 ] ]); $response = $this->render(); $this->assertEquals(404, $response->getStatusCode()); }zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php (3)
38-39: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add error handling for routing file
Similar to the config file, the routing file is loaded without checking its existence.
Consider this safer approach:
-\BO\Slim\Bootstrap::loadRouting(\App::APP_PATH . '/routing.php'); +$routingFile = \App::APP_PATH . '/routing.php'; +if (!file_exists($routingFile)) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Routing file not found: ' . $routingFile); +} +\BO\Slim\Bootstrap::loadRouting($routingFile);📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.// load routing $routingFile = \App::APP_PATH . '/routing.php'; if (!file_exists($routingFile)) { throw new \RuntimeException('Routing file not found: ' . $routingFile); } \BO\Slim\Bootstrap::loadRouting($routingFile);
24-28: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add error handling for config file inclusion
The config file is required without checking its existence first. This could lead to unclear errors if the file is missing.
Consider this safer approach:
-require(APP_PATH . '/config.php'); +$configFile = APP_PATH . '/config.php'; +if (!file_exists($configFile)) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Configuration file not found: ' . $configFile); +} +require($configFile);📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.// initialize the static \App singleton $configFile = APP_PATH . '/config.php'; if (!file_exists($configFile)) { throw new \RuntimeException('Configuration file not found: ' . $configFile); } require($configFile); // Set option for environment, routing, logging and templating \BO\Slim\Bootstrap::init();
30-33: 💡 Codebase verification
Uncomment and configure curl options for consistent HTTP client behavior
The curl configuration line should be uncommented as it's consistently used across other components (zmsticketprinter, zmsstatistic, zmsmessaging, etc.) and provides important defaults like SSL and timeout settings. The ZMS_API_URL is properly configured in config.example.php with a fallback mechanism.
- Uncomment line 33:
\BO\Zmsclient\Psr7\Client::$curlopt = \App::$http_curl_config;- Ensure
$http_curl_configin your configuration includes at least these standard options:public static $http_curl_config = [ CURLOPT_SSL_VERIFYPEER => false, CURLOPT_TIMEOUT => 15 ];🔗 Analysis chain
Validate ZMS_API_URL and consider curl configuration
The HTTP client is initialized without validating ZMS_API_URL. Additionally, there's a commented curl configuration that might be necessary.
Run this script to check the API URL configuration:
Let me gather more information about the ZMS_API_URL validation and configuration.
Let me check the HTTP client implementation to understand how the URL and curl configuration are handled.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for ZMS_API_URL configuration and usage # Search for ZMS_API_URL definitions rg -l "ZMS_API_URL" # Check for curl configuration usage rg "http_curl_config"Length of output: 1794
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check ZMS_API_URL configuration and validation # Look for ZMS_API_URL definition in config files rg -A 5 "ZMS_API_URL" "zmscitizenapi/config.example.php" # Check if there's any validation of ZMS_API_URL in the Application class rg -A 5 "ZMS_API_URL" "zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Application.php" # Look for any URL validation in the HTTP client class ast-grep --pattern 'class Http { $$$ }'Length of output: 622
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check HTTP client implementation # Look for Http class implementation in zmsclient fd -e php Http --exec rg -A 10 "class Http" # Check for URL validation in constructor or methods rg -A 10 "__construct.*Http" # Look for curl configuration usage in the client rg -A 5 "curlopt" "zmsclient"Length of output: 5693
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/FriendlyCaptchaService.php (2)
11-20:
⚠️ Potential issueAdd validation for configuration constants.
The method returns configuration without validating if the required Application constants are defined. This could lead to undefined constant errors in production.
Consider adding validation:
public static function getCaptchaDetails(): array { + if (!defined('BO\Zmscitizenapi\Application::$CAPTCHA_SITEKEY') || + !defined('BO\Zmscitizenapi\Application::$CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT') || + !defined('BO\Zmscitizenapi\Application::$CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT_PUZZLE') || + !defined('BO\Zmscitizenapi\Application::$CAPTCHA_ENABLED')) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Required CAPTCHA configuration constants are not defined'); + } return [ 'siteKey' => Application::$CAPTCHA_SITEKEY, 'captchaEndpoint' => Application::$CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT, 'puzzle' => Application::$CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT_PUZZLE, 'captchaEnabled' => Application::$CAPTCHA_ENABLED, 'status' => 200 ]; }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
22-39:
⚠️ Potential issueMultiple improvements needed for security and robustness.
Several issues need to be addressed:
- Missing input validation for the solution parameter
- Unsafe secret key handling
- Hard-to-test global dependency
- Unsafe JSON decoding
- Generic exception usage
Consider applying these improvements:
- public static function verifyCaptcha(string $solution) + public static function verifyCaptcha(string $solution): array { + if (empty($solution) || strlen($solution) > 2000) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Invalid CAPTCHA solution provided'); + } + try { - $response = \App::$http->post(Application::$CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT, [ + $client = self::getHttpClient(); + $response = $client->post(Application::$CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT, [ 'form_params' => [ 'secret' => Application::$CAPTCHA_SECRET, 'solution' => $solution ] ]); - $responseBody = json_decode($response->getBody(), true); + $responseBody = json_decode($response->getBody(), true); + if (!is_array($responseBody)) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Invalid response format from CAPTCHA service'); + } return $responseBody; } catch (RequestException $e) { $errorMessage = $e->hasResponse() ? $e->getResponse()->getBody()->getContents() : $e->getMessage(); - throw new Exception('Captcha verification failed: ' . $errorMessage); + throw new \BO\Zmscitizenapi\Exception\CaptchaVerificationException('Captcha verification failed: ' . $errorMessage); } } + + private static function getHttpClient(): \GuzzleHttp\ClientInterface + { + return \App::$http ?? new \GuzzleHttp\Client(); + }Consider these additional architectural improvements:
- Move HTTP client dependency to constructor injection for better testability
- Store sensitive data like CAPTCHA_SECRET in a secure vault or environment variables
- Create a dedicated exception class for CAPTCHA verification failures
- Add proper PHPDoc blocks for better documentation
Would you like me to provide examples for any of these improvements?
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmsapi/public/doc/README.md (1)
15-17: 💡 Codebase verification
Documentation URLs need attention - accessibility issues detected
The URL verification results show:
https://zms.ddev.site/...: Connection failed (not accessible)https://it-at-m.github.io/...: Returns HTTP 404 (not found)https://eappointment.gitlab.io/...: Returns HTTP 404 (not found)Please update the documentation with currently accessible URLs or remove/replace the non-functioning ones. The local development URL (
http://[::]:8001/public/doc/) can be retained as it's meant for local setup.🔗 Analysis chain
Verify the accessibility of documentation URLs.
Please ensure that all listed URLs are accessible and correctly configured.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check if the documentation URLs are accessible # Note: Local URL (http://[::]:8001/public/doc/) is excluded as it requires local setup # Check DDEV URL curl -I https://zms.ddev.site/terminvereinbarung/api/2/doc/index.html # Check GitHub Pages URL curl -I https://it-at-m.github.io/eappointment/zmsapi/public/doc/index.html # Check GitLab Pages URL curl -I https://eappointment.gitlab.io/zmsapi/Length of output: 2153
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php (1)
31-37: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance JSON response handling
The JSON response helper could be improved with better error handling and HTTP compliance:
Consider applying these improvements:
protected function createJsonResponse(ResponseInterface $response, array $content, int $statusCode): ResponseInterface { + $jsonContent = json_encode($content, JSON_THROW_ON_ERROR | JSON_UNESCAPED_UNICODE); + $contentLength = strlen($jsonContent); + $response = $response->withStatus($statusCode) - ->withHeader('Content-Type', 'application/json'); - $response->getBody()->write(json_encode($content)); + ->withHeader('Content-Type', 'application/json; charset=utf-8') + ->withHeader('Content-Length', (string) $contentLength); + $response->getBody()->write($jsonContent); return $response; }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.protected function createJsonResponse(ResponseInterface $response, array $content, int $statusCode): ResponseInterface { $jsonContent = json_encode($content, JSON_THROW_ON_ERROR | JSON_UNESCAPED_UNICODE); $contentLength = strlen($jsonContent); $response = $response->withStatus($statusCode) ->withHeader('Content-Type', 'application/json; charset=utf-8') ->withHeader('Content-Length', (string) $contentLength); $response->getBody()->write($jsonContent); return $response; }zmscitizenapi/public/doc/README.md (1)
21-29:
⚠️ Potential issueFix formatting issues and update GitLab URL reference
There are several issues to address:
- Missing comma in the sentence
- Bare URL usage
- Reference to GitLab while the project is on GitHub
Here's a suggested improvement:
-* Under /public/doc are the schema from zmsentities. A symbolic link points to the corresponding folder under vendor/eappointment/zmsentities/schema. +* Under `/public/doc` are the schema from zmsentities. A symbolic link points to the corresponding folder under `vendor/eappointment/zmsentities/schema`. -* Under /bin there is a build_swagger.js file. This is executed via ``npm run doc`` and validates the existing swagger.yaml file. If valid, the open api annotations are read from routing.php and the remaining information such as info, definitions, version and tags are compiled from the yaml files under ./partials into a complete swagger.yaml. +* Under `/bin`, there is a `build_swagger.js` file. This is executed via `npm run doc` and validates the existing `swagger.yaml` file. If valid, the open api annotations are read from `routing.php`, and the remaining information such as info, definitions, version, and tags are compiled from the yaml files under `./partials` into a complete `swagger.yaml`. -* a bin/configure must be executed before a bin/doc so that the latest API version is in the ./VERSION file. +* A `bin/configure` must be executed before `bin/doc` so that the latest API version is in the `./VERSION` file. -* To access all paths resolved via redoc or the open api documentation, a resolved swagger.json must be created from the swagger.yaml. This is done via the swagger cli with a call to ``bin/doc``. This call executes the above npm command ``npm run doc`` and subsequently creates a full swagger.json. +* To access all paths resolved via redoc or the open api documentation, a resolved `swagger.json` must be created from the `swagger.yaml`. This is done via the swagger cli with a call to `bin/doc`. This call executes the above npm command `npm run doc` and subsequently creates a full `swagger.json`. -To render the open-api doc by redoc and swagger, appropriate files such as swagger-ui files are fetched in the CI process and stored at https://eappointment.gitlab.io/zmsapi/. +To render the open-api doc by redoc and swagger, appropriate files such as swagger-ui files are fetched in the CI process and stored at [GitHub Pages](https://it-at-m.github.io/eappointment/).Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
🧰 Tools
🪛 LanguageTool
[uncategorized] ~23-~23: Possible missing comma found.
Context: ...pointment/zmsentities/schema. * Under /bin there is a build_swagger.js file. This ...(AI_HYDRA_LEO_MISSING_COMMA)
🪛 Markdownlint (0.35.0)
29-29: null
Bare URL used(MD034, no-bare-urls)
zmscitizenapi/composer.json (4)
36-44:
⚠️ Potential issueDefine the missing @wget-files script.
The post-install and post-update commands reference
@wget-files, but this script is not defined in thescriptssection.Either define the script or remove the references:
"scripts": { "clean": "rm -f public/doc/assets/*.* && rm -f public/_test/assets/*.*", "command": "bin/configure", + "wget-files": "your-wget-command-here", "post-install-cmd": [ "@wget-files" ], "post-update-cmd": [ "@wget-files" ] },Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
25-25:
⚠️ Potential issueSpecify a version constraint for php_codesniffer.
Using
*as a version constraint could lead to unexpected breaks when new versions are released.- "squizlabs/php_codesniffer": "*", + "squizlabs/php_codesniffer": "^3.7.2",📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements."squizlabs/php_codesniffer": "^3.7.2",
31-34:
⚠️ Potential issueAvoid using @dev constraint for production dependencies.
Using
@devfor all core dependencies could lead to instability in production. Consider using stable version constraints or at least dev-master if you need the latest development version.- "eappointment/mellon": "@dev", - "eappointment/zmsslim": "@dev", - "eappointment/zmsclient": "@dev", - "eappointment/zmsentities": "@dev" + "eappointment/mellon": "^1.0", + "eappointment/zmsslim": "^1.0", + "eappointment/zmsclient": "^1.0", + "eappointment/zmsentities": "^1.0"Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
15-22:
⚠️ Potential issueConsider updating to a newer PHP version.
PHP 8.0 reached its end of life on November 26, 2023. Consider upgrading to PHP 8.2 or 8.3 for security updates and performance improvements.
"config": { "platform": { - "php": "8.0" + "php": "8.2" },📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements."config": { "platform": { "php": "8.2" }, "allow-plugins": { "php-http/discovery": true } },zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ExceptionService.php (4)
27-37: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Reduce code duplication and improve type safety.
The error response structure is duplicated across methods. Consider extracting the common logic into a private helper method.
+ /** + * @param string $errorCode + * @param string $message + * @param int $status + * @return array + */ + private static function createErrorResponse(string $errorCode, string $message, int $status): array + { + return [ + 'errors' => [ + [ + 'errorCode' => $errorCode, + 'errorMessage' => $message, + 'status' => $status, + ] + ], + 'status' => $status + ]; + } + - public static function appointmentNotFound(){ + public static function appointmentNotFound(): array + { + return self::createErrorResponse( + self::ERROR_APPOINTMENT_NOT_FOUND, + _('Appointment not found.'), + self::HTTP_NOT_FOUND + ); - $errors[] = [ - 'errorCode' => self::ERROR_APPOINTMENT_NOT_FOUND, - 'errorMessage' => 'Termin wurde nicht gefunden.', - 'status' => self::HTTP_NOT_FOUND, - ]; - - return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => self::HTTP_NOT_FOUND]; }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
39-48: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Fix inconsistent spacing and apply previous improvements.
The method has inconsistent spacing and should use the suggested helper method from the previous comment.
- public static function tooManyAppointmentsWithSameMail(){ - $errors[] = [ - 'errorCode' => self::ERROR_TOO_MANY_APPOINTMENTS, - 'errorMessage' => 'Zu viele Termine mit gleicher E-Mail- Adresse.', - 'status' => self::HTTP_NOT_ACCEPTABLE, - ]; - - return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => self::HTTP_NOT_ACCEPTABLE]; + public static function tooManyAppointmentsWithSameMail(): array + { + return self::createErrorResponse( + self::ERROR_TOO_MANY_APPOINTMENTS, + _('Too many appointments with the same email address.'), + self::HTTP_NOT_ACCEPTABLE + ); }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
15-25: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve type safety and internationalization support.
Several improvements can be made to enhance maintainability and flexibility:
- Add return type declaration
- Externalize the error message for internationalization
- Simplify array initialization
- public static function noAppointmentsAtLocation(){ + public static function noAppointmentsAtLocation(): array + { + $errors = [ + [ + 'errorCode' => self::ERROR_NO_APPOINTMENTS, - 'errorMessage' => 'An diesem Standort gibt es aktuell leider keine freien Termine.', + 'errorMessage' => _('No appointments currently available at this location.'), + 'status' => self::HTTP_NOT_FOUND, + ] + ]; return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => self::HTTP_NOT_FOUND]; }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.public static function noAppointmentsAtLocation(): array { $errors = [ [ 'errorCode' => self::ERROR_NO_APPOINTMENTS, 'errorMessage' => _('No appointments currently available at this location.'), 'status' => self::HTTP_NOT_FOUND, ] ]; return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => self::HTTP_NOT_FOUND]; }
1-50: 💡 Codebase verification
Consider refactoring the exception handling for better separation of concerns
Based on the codebase analysis:
- The ExceptionService is tightly coupled with HTTP concerns and is used directly in ZmsApiFacadeService for error responses
- The service follows a static approach which makes it harder to test and modify
- While other services (like CaptchaService) have interfaces, ExceptionService lacks one
- No dedicated test files were found in the immediate directories
Recommendations:
- Extract HTTP status codes and response formatting into a separate ResponseFormatter service
- Convert static methods to instance methods for better testability
- Create an ExceptionServiceInterface following the pattern seen with CaptchaServiceInterface
- Add unit tests for each error scenario
🔗 Analysis chain
Consider architectural improvements for better maintainability.
- Consider separating the HTTP response handling into a separate service to better follow Single Responsibility Principle.
- Define an interface for this service to improve testability and dependency management.
- Ensure comprehensive unit test coverage for all error scenarios.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check for existing tests fd -e php -p "ExceptionService.*Test\.php$" # Check for interface definitions fd -e php -p "ExceptionService.*Interface\.php$"Length of output: 96
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check for any test files in the test directory fd -e php "Test" tests/ # Let's check for any interface files fd -e php "Interface" # Let's check how this service is being used rg "ExceptionService" -lLength of output: 678
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check how ExceptionService is being used in the files that reference it rg "ExceptionService" -A 3 zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php rg "ExceptionService" -A 3 zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php # Let's check if there's a test directory in a different location fd -e php "test" -d 1Length of output: 863
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/CaptchaGetTest.php (1)
33-50: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance test coverage and add type safety.
The test method could be improved in several ways:
- Add negative test cases (e.g., when CAPTCHA is disabled)
- Add response format validation
- Use constants for status codes
- Add return type hints
- public function testCaptchaDetails() + public function testCaptchaDetails(): void { + // Test when CAPTCHA is enabled $captchaEnabled = filter_var(getenv('CAPTCHA_ENABLED'), FILTER_VALIDATE_BOOLEAN); $parameters = []; $response = $this->render([], $parameters, []); + + // Validate response format + $this->assertJson((string)$response->getBody(), 'Response is not valid JSON'); $responseBody = json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true); + $this->assertIsArray($responseBody, 'Response body should be an array'); + // Define expected status code + private const HTTP_OK = 200; $expectedResponse = [ 'siteKey' => 'FAKE_SITE_KEY', 'captchaEndpoint' => 'https://api.friendlycaptcha.com/api/v1/siteverify', 'puzzle' => 'https://api.friendlycaptcha.com/api/v1/puzzle', 'captchaEnabled' => true, - 'status' => 200 + 'status' => self::HTTP_OK ]; - $this->assertEquals(200, $response->getStatusCode()); + $this->assertEquals(self::HTTP_OK, $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, $responseBody); } + + /** + * @test + */ + public function testCaptchaDetailsWhenDisabled(): void + { + // Test when CAPTCHA is disabled + putenv('CAPTCHA_ENABLED=0'); + Application::initialize(); + + $response = $this->render([], [], []); + $responseBody = json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true); + + $expectedResponse = [ + 'siteKey' => 'FAKE_SITE_KEY', + 'captchaEndpoint' => 'https://api.friendlycaptcha.com/api/v1/siteverify', + 'puzzle' => 'https://api.friendlycaptcha.com/api/v1/puzzle', + 'captchaEnabled' => false, + 'status' => self::HTTP_OK + ]; + + $this->assertEquals(self::HTTP_OK, $response->getStatusCode()); + $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, $responseBody); + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Application.php (2)
28-40: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add validation for required CAPTCHA settings when enabled
When CAPTCHA is enabled, the secret and sitekey should not be empty. Consider adding validation to prevent runtime issues.
public static function initialize() { self::$CAPTCHA_ENABLED = filter_var(getenv('CAPTCHA_ENABLED'), FILTER_VALIDATE_BOOLEAN); + if (self::$CAPTCHA_ENABLED) { + $secret = getenv('CAPTCHA_SECRET'); + $sitekey = getenv('CAPTCHA_SITEKEY'); + if (empty($secret) || empty($sitekey)) { + throw new \RuntimeException('CAPTCHA_SECRET and CAPTCHA_SITEKEY are required when CAPTCHA is enabled'); + } + self::$CAPTCHA_SECRET = $secret; + self::$CAPTCHA_SITEKEY = $sitekey; + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
36-40:
⚠️ Potential issueConsider protecting sensitive configuration
The CAPTCHA credentials are stored in public static properties, making them mutable from anywhere in the application. Consider making them private or readonly.
- public static string $CAPTCHA_SECRET; - public static string $CAPTCHA_SITEKEY; + private static string $CAPTCHA_SECRET; + private static string $CAPTCHA_SITEKEY; + + public static function getCaptchaSitekey(): string + { + return self::$CAPTCHA_SITEKEY; + }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.private static bool $CAPTCHA_ENABLED; private static string $CAPTCHA_SECRET; private static string $CAPTCHA_SITEKEY; private static string $CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT; private static string $CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT_PUZZLE; public static function getCaptchaEnabled(): bool { return self::$CAPTCHA_ENABLED; } public static function getCaptchaSecret(): string { return self::$CAPTCHA_SECRET; } public static function getCaptchaSitekey(): string { return self::$CAPTCHA_SITEKEY; } public static function getCaptchaEndpoint(): string { return self::$CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT; } public static function getCaptchaEndpointPuzzle(): string { return self::$CAPTCHA_ENDPOINT_PUZZLE; }zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ScopesListTest.php (1)
1-66: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider adding error scenario test cases
The current test covers the happy path well, but consider adding tests for:
- Invalid source parameter
- Missing or malformed provider data
- Error responses (4xx, 5xx status codes)
- Empty scopes list
- Maximum number of scopes
Example error test:
public function testInvalidSource() { $this->setApiCalls([ [ 'function' => 'readGetResult', 'url' => '/source/invalid/', 'parameters' => [ 'resolveReferences' => 2, ], 'response' => ['status' => 404] ] ]); $response = $this->render(); $this->assertEquals(404, $response->getStatusCode()); }zmscitizenapi/bin/build_swagger.js (4)
79-87:
⚠️ Potential issueFix broken version reading implementation
The
readApiVersionfunction has a critical issue - it's using asynchronousfs.readFilebut attempting to return synchronously, which will always result inundefined. Additionally, there's no proper error handling for missing VERSION file.Replace with this corrected implementation:
function readApiVersion() { - fs.readFile('./VERSION', 'utf8' , (err, data) => { - if (err) { - console.error(err) - return - } - return data; - }) + try { + return fs.readFileSync('./VERSION', 'utf8').trim(); + } catch (err) { + console.error('Failed to read VERSION file:', err); + return 'unknown'; + } }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.function readApiVersion() { try { return fs.readFileSync('./VERSION', 'utf8').trim(); } catch (err) { console.error('Failed to read VERSION file:', err); return 'unknown'; } }
1-15: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider upgrading OpenAPI specification version and improving configuration robustness
The configuration has several areas for improvement:
- OpenAPI 2.0.0 is outdated. Consider upgrading to OpenAPI 3.x for better feature support and compatibility.
- The hard-coded path
./routing.phpmight cause issues in different environments.Consider applying these improvements:
const options = { definition: { - openapi: '2.0.0', + openapi: '3.0.3', info: { version: readApiVersion(), title: "ZMS API" }, }, - apis: ['./routing.php'] + apis: [process.env.API_ROUTES_PATH || './routing.php'] };📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.var fs = require('fs'); const swaggerParser = require('swagger-parser'); const swaggerJsdoc = require('swagger-jsdoc'); const yaml = require('js-yaml'); const options = { definition: { openapi: '3.0.3', info: { version: readApiVersion(), title: "ZMS API" }, }, apis: [process.env.API_ROUTES_PATH || './routing.php'] };
22-41: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve swagger validation implementation
The current implementation has several issues:
- Unnecessary file size check before validation
- Nested callbacks making error handling difficult
- Inconsistent error handling approaches
Consider refactoring to use async/await for better readability and error handling:
-function validateSwagger() { +async function validateSwagger() { try { - fs.stat('public/doc/swagger.yaml', function(error, stats) { - var routessize = stats.size; - if (error) { - console.log(error); - } else { - console.log("Found public/doc/swagger.yaml with " + routessize + " bytes"); - } - - swaggerParser.validate('public/doc/swagger.yaml', (err, api) => { - if (err) { - console.error(err); - } - else { - console.log("Validated API %s, Version: %s", api.info.title, api.info.version); - } - }) - }); + const api = await swaggerParser.validate('public/doc/swagger.yaml'); + console.log("Validated API %s, Version: %s", api.info.title, api.info.version); + } catch (error) { + console.error('Swagger validation failed:', error); + process.exit(1); } }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.async function validateSwagger() { try { const api = await swaggerParser.validate('public/doc/swagger.yaml'); console.log("Validated API %s, Version: %s", api.info.title, api.info.version); } catch (error) { console.error('Swagger validation failed:', error); process.exit(1); } }
43-68: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve swagger build process reliability
The current implementation has potential reliability issues:
- Direct string concatenation of YAML content is risky
- No validation of partial files' existence
- No YAML syntax validation for partial files
Consider this safer implementation:
-function buildSwagger() { +async function buildSwagger() { + const required_files = [ + 'public/doc/partials/version.yaml', + 'public/doc/partials/info.yaml', + 'public/doc/partials/basic.yaml', + 'public/doc/partials/tags.yaml', + 'public/doc/partials/definitions.yaml', + './VERSION' + ]; + + try { + // Verify all required files exist + await Promise.all(required_files.map(file => fs.promises.access(file))); + + // Parse each YAML file properly + const version = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/version.yaml', 'utf8')); + const info = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/info.yaml', 'utf8')); + const basic = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/basic.yaml', 'utf8')); + const tags = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/tags.yaml', 'utf8')); + const definitions = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/definitions.yaml', 'utf8')); + + // Merge objects properly + const apiVersion = (await fs.promises.readFile('./VERSION', 'utf8')).trim(); + const merged = { + ...version, + info: { ...info, version: apiVersion }, + ...basic, + ...tags, + paths: openapiSpecification.paths, + ...definitions + }; + + // Write the properly merged YAML + await fs.promises.writeFile('public/doc/swagger.yaml', yaml.dump(merged), 'utf8'); + console.log("Built new swagger file successfully!"); + } catch (error) { + console.error('Failed to build swagger:', error); + process.exit(1); + } }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.async function buildSwagger() { const required_files = [ 'public/doc/partials/version.yaml', 'public/doc/partials/info.yaml', 'public/doc/partials/basic.yaml', 'public/doc/partials/tags.yaml', 'public/doc/partials/definitions.yaml', './VERSION' ]; try { // Verify all required files exist await Promise.all(required_files.map(file => fs.promises.access(file))); // Parse each YAML file properly const version = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/version.yaml', 'utf8')); const info = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/info.yaml', 'utf8')); const basic = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/basic.yaml', 'utf8')); const tags = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/tags.yaml', 'utf8')); const definitions = yaml.load(await fs.promises.readFile('public/doc/partials/definitions.yaml', 'utf8')); // Merge objects properly const apiVersion = (await fs.promises.readFile('./VERSION', 'utf8')).trim(); const merged = { ...version, info: { ...info, version: apiVersion }, ...basic, ...tags, paths: openapiSpecification.paths, ...definitions }; // Write the properly merged YAML await fs.promises.writeFile('public/doc/swagger.yaml', yaml.dump(merged), 'utf8'); console.log("Built new swagger file successfully!"); } catch (error) { console.error('Failed to build swagger:', error); process.exit(1); } }zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_appointments.json (1)
17-55:
⚠️ Potential issueVerify appointment date and workstation configuration
- The
datevalue "32526616522" appears to be an invalid timestamp (year ~3000).- All workstation counts are set to 0, which might not provide adequate test coverage.
Consider these changes:
- "date": "32526616522", + "date": "1700064941", - "public": 0, - "callcenter": 0, - "intern": 0 + "public": 2, + "callcenter": 1, + "intern": 1📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements."date": "1700064941", "scope": { "id": "58", "source": "dldb" }, "availability": { "id": 0, "weekday": { "sunday": 0, "monday": 0, "tuesday": 0, "wednesday": 0, "thursday": 0, "friday": 0, "saturday": 0 }, "repeat": { "afterWeeks": 1, "weekOfMonth": 0 }, "bookable": { "startInDays": 1, "endInDays": 60 }, "workstationCount": { "public": 2, "callcenter": 1, "intern": 1 }, "lastChange": 0, "multipleSlotsAllowed": true, "slotTimeInMinutes": 10, "startDate": 0, "endDate": 0, "startTime": "0:00", "endTime": "23:59", "type": "appointment" }, "slotCount": "4"zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_appointments_free.json (2)
17-54:
⚠️ Potential issueFix unrealistic test data values
Several values in the appointment data appear unrealistic for testing:
- The
datetimestamp (32526616522) corresponds to approximately year 2999- All workstation counts are set to 0, which might not properly test capacity scenarios
- All weekday availability flags are 0, which suggests no available days
Consider updating the values to be more realistic:
- "date": "32526616522", + "date": "1699939200", // Use a more recent timestamp "workstationCount": { - "public": 0, - "callcenter": 0, - "intern": 0 + "public": 2, + "callcenter": 1, + "intern": 1 }, "weekday": { - "monday": 0, - "tuesday": 0, + "monday": 1, + "tuesday": 1,Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
58-76: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance test data for authentication and queue metrics
The current test data might not provide adequate coverage:
- The
authKeyappears truncated ("fb43")- Empty
createIPwon't test IP tracking functionality- All queue metrics being 0 won't test various waiting scenarios
Consider enhancing the test data:
- "authKey": "fb43", + "authKey": "fb43e791-5c9d-4b5f-8cb4-b7c2f5234321", - "createIP": "", + "createIP": "192.168.1.100", "queue": { - "waitingTimeEstimate": 0, - "waitingTime": 0, + "waitingTimeEstimate": 15, + "waitingTime": 12,📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements."apiclient": { "shortname": "default" }, "authKey": "fb43e791-5c9d-4b5f-8cb4-b7c2f5234321", "createIP": "192.168.1.100", "createTimestamp": 1725635464, "id": 0, "archiveId": 0, "queue": { "$schema": "https:\/\/schema.berlin.de\/queuemanagement\/queue.json", "arrivalTime": 0, "callCount": 0, "callTime": 0, "number": 0, "waitingTimeEstimate": 15, "waitingTimeOptimistic": 0, "waitingTime": 12, "wayTime": 0 },zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesListTest.php (1)
10-73: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add test coverage for error scenarios
The current test only covers the successful response path. Consider adding test cases for:
- Invalid/missing source parameters
- API error responses
- Empty office list
- Malformed response data
Example test method structure:
public function testRenderingWithEmptyOfficeList() { // Mock empty response } public function testRenderingWithInvalidSource() { // Mock error response }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php (3)
8-25: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add input validation and consider using a DTO pattern
The method could benefit from:
- Input validation to ensure required fields
- A dedicated DTO class for the scope structure
- Type declarations for parameters and return type
Example implementation:
- public static function mapScope($scope) + public static function mapScope(array $scope): array { + if (!isset($scope['id'])) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Scope must have an ID'); + }Consider creating a
ScopeDTOclass to represent this data structure more formally.Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
45-79: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Refactor complex method to improve maintainability
The method has several concerns:
- High cyclomatic complexity
- Multiple responsibilities
- Unsafe array access
Consider breaking this into smaller methods:
+ private static function getServiceProviderIds(array $relationList): array + { + $servicesProviderIds = []; + foreach ($relationList as $relation) { + $servicesProviderIds[$relation->request->id][] = $relation->provider->id; + } + return $servicesProviderIds; + } + + private static function mapServiceCombinations(object $service, array $servicesProviderIds): array + { + $combinations = []; + if (!empty($service->getAdditionalData()['combinable'])) { + foreach ($service->getAdditionalData()['combinable'] as $combinationServiceId) { + $combinations[$combinationServiceId] = array_values(array_intersect( + $servicesProviderIds[$service->getId()] ?? [], + $servicesProviderIds[$combinationServiceId] ?? [] + )); + } + } + return $combinations; + }This would make the main method cleaner and more maintainable.
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
27-43:
⚠️ Potential issueAdd error handling and type declarations
The method has several potential issues:
- No error handling for
ZmsApiFacadeService::getScopeForProvider()- Direct property access without checks
- Missing type declarations
Example implementation:
- public static function mapOfficesWithScope($providerList) + public static function mapOfficesWithScope(array $providerList): array { $offices = []; foreach ($providerList as $provider) { + if (!isset($provider->id)) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Provider must have an ID'); + } $officeData = [ "id" => $provider->id, "name" => $provider->displayName ?? $provider->name, ]; - $scope = ZmsApiFacadeService::getScopeForProvider($provider->id); + try { + $scope = ZmsApiFacadeService::getScopeForProvider($provider->id); + } catch (\Exception $e) { + // Log error and continue or handle appropriately + continue; + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/UtilityHelper.php (3)
17-28: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add type declarations and improve error handling.
The method could be improved with stricter type safety and better error messages.
Consider applying these improvements:
- public static function getInternalDateFromISO($dateString) + public static function getInternalDateFromISO(string $dateString): array { try { - if (!is_string($dateString)) { - throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Date string must be a string'); - } $date = new \DateTime($dateString); return self::formatDateArray($date); } catch (\Exception $e) { - throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Invalid ISO date format: ' . $e->getMessage()); + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Invalid ISO date format. Expected format: YYYY-MM-DD or ISO 8601'); } }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.public static function getInternalDateFromISO(string $dateString): array { try { $date = new \DateTime($dateString); return self::formatDateArray($date); } catch (\Exception $e) { throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Invalid ISO date format. Expected format: YYYY-MM-DD or ISO 8601'); } }
30-38: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add return type and improve timestamp validation.
The method should have a return type declaration and validate the timestamp range.
Consider applying these improvements:
- public static function getInternalDateFromTimestamp(int $timestamp) + public static function getInternalDateFromTimestamp(int $timestamp): array { try { + if ($timestamp < 0) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Timestamp must be a positive integer'); + } $date = (new \DateTime())->setTimestamp($timestamp); return self::formatDateArray($date); } catch (\Exception $e) { throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Invalid timestamp: ' . $e->getMessage()); } }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.public static function getInternalDateFromTimestamp(int $timestamp): array { try { if ($timestamp < 0) { throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Timestamp must be a positive integer'); } $date = (new \DateTime())->setTimestamp($timestamp); return self::formatDateArray($date); } catch (\Exception $e) { throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Invalid timestamp: ' . $e->getMessage()); } }
40-43: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve type safety and documentation.
The method needs type declarations and PHPDoc to explain its usage as an array filter callback.
Consider applying these improvements:
+ /** + * Callback for array_filter to keep only unique elements based on their first occurrence + * + * @param mixed $value The array element to check + * @param int $index The array key/index of the element + * @param array $self The array being filtered + * @return bool True if the element is the first occurrence + */ - public static function uniqueElementsFilter($value, $index, $self) + public static function isFirstOccurrence(mixed $value, int $index, array $self): bool { return array_search($value, $self) === $index; }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements./** * Callback for array_filter to keep only unique elements based on their first occurrence * * @param mixed $value The array element to check * @param int $index The array key/index of the element * @param array $self The array being filtered * @return bool True if the element is the first occurrence */ public static function isFirstOccurrence(mixed $value, int $index, array $self): bool { return array_search($value, $self) === $index; }zmsadmin/tests/Zmsadmin/fixtures/GET_source_unittest.json (1)
7-7: 💡 Codebase verification
Server field change appears to be inconsistent across fixtures
The search results reveal that the server field value varies across fixture files:
- Most fixtures use "Zmsapi-ENV"
- Some include version information like "Zmsapi-ENV (v2.15.03)"
- Only three files use the simplified "Zmsapi" value:
GET_source_unittest.jsonGET_processList_fake_entry.jsonGET_processList_empty.jsonThis inconsistency suggests the change should either be reverted to match the majority pattern of "Zmsapi-ENV" or all fixtures should be updated to use the simplified "Zmsapi" format for consistency.
🔗 Analysis chain
Verify impact of server field simplification
The server field has been simplified from a versioned format to just "Zmsapi". While this standardization is consistent across fixtures, please ensure:
- The simplified value complies with the referenced schemas
- No test cases depend on the version information that was removed
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for potential test dependencies on server version # Search for test files that might reference the old server version format rg -l "Zmsapi-ENV \(v[0-9]+\.[0-9]+\.[0-9]+-[0-9]+-g[a-f0-9]+\)" --type php # Check if any tests explicitly assert or validate the server version ast-grep --pattern 'assert$_($_, $server)' # Look for schema definitions that might constrain the server field fd -e json -e yaml -e xml . | xargs rg -l '"server".*pattern'Length of output: 186
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's try a different approach to check test dependencies # Look for any test assertions related to the 'server' field rg -A 2 '"server"' --type php zmsadmin/tests/ # Check for any schema validation or test setup involving server field rg -A 2 'server' --type php zmsadmin/tests/ # Look for other fixture files that might have similar server field fd -e json . zmsadmin/tests/ | xargs rg '"server":'Length of output: 10270
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesServicesRelationsTest.php (1)
23-106: 💡 Codebase verification
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider improving test coverage and data organization
The review comment's suggestions are valid based on the verification results:
- The test class only contains a single happy path test case (
testRendering) with no error scenarios- The test data is indeed hardcoded in the test file rather than using a fixture file
- The test file doesn't contain any exception testing
- There are no specific test cases for the combinable services logic
Specific improvements needed:
- Move the large
$expectedResponsearray to a fixture file inzmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/- Add test cases for error scenarios like invalid source, missing parameters
- Add specific test cases to verify the combinable services logic
- Add validation for the schema URL format
🔗 Analysis chain
Consider improving test coverage and data organization.
The test could be enhanced in several ways:
- Move the large expected response array to a separate fixture file for better maintainability
- Add test cases for error scenarios (e.g., invalid source, missing parameters)
- Add validation for specific field formats (e.g., schema URL)
- Add test cases for the combinable services logic
Example improvement for moving the expected response:
- $expectedResponse = [ - "offices" => [ - // ... large array ... - ], - ]; + $expectedResponse = json_decode(file_get_contents(__DIR__ . '/fixtures/expected_offices_services_response.json'), true);Let's verify if there are other test cases for error scenarios:
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for related test files that might contain error scenarios rg -l "class.*Test.*Office.*Service" --type php # Search for specific error handling patterns in the main class ast-grep --pattern 'throw new \Exception($_)'Length of output: 97
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's try a broader search for test files related to offices and services fd "Test.php" | rg -l "Office|Service" # Search for any test methods in the specific test file rg "function test" "zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesServicesRelationsTest.php" # Look for fixture files in the test directory fd . "zmscitizenapi/tests" -t f -e json # Search for error handling in the main implementation file fd . -t f | rg -l "OfficesServicesRelations" | grep -v "Test"Length of output: 964
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's check the content of the test file to understand the test coverage better cat "zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesServicesRelationsTest.php" # Let's also check if there are any other test files with similar patterns rg -l "testRendering|OfficesServicesRelations" --type php # Check if there are any error handling tests in the test class rg "test.*Exception|expectException" "zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesServicesRelationsTest.php"Length of output: 19432
cli (1)
25-25: 💡 Codebase verification
NPM build support is required for zmscitizenapi module
The module has a package.json with build scripts defined:
buildscript that runsbuild_swagger.jsdocscript that depends on the build stepThis module should be added to the
specific_moduleslist in theloopcommand to ensure proper build support.🔗 Analysis chain
Verify if npm build support is needed
Please verify if the zmscitizenapi module requires npm build support. If it does, it should be added to the
specific_moduleslist in theloopcommand and have corresponding build commands defined.🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check if the module has npm-related files that would indicate need for npm build support # Check for package.json, webpack config, or other npm-related files echo "Checking for npm-related files in zmscitizenapi:" fd -t f "^(package\.json|webpack\.config\.js|.*\.js|.*\.ts)$" zmscitizenapi # Check if there are any npm scripts defined if [ -f "zmscitizenapi/package.json" ]; then echo "Found package.json. Checking npm scripts:" cat zmscitizenapi/package.json | jq '.scripts' fiLength of output: 594
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_SourceGet_dldb.json (2)
79-118: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve data type consistency in scopes
- Boolean values are represented as strings ("0", "1")
- Inconsistent handling of optional fields (empty string vs. omitted)
"preferences": { "client": { - "telephoneActivated": "1", - "telephoneRequired": "0", + "telephoneActivated": true, + "telephoneRequired": false, "customTextfieldLabel": "Custom Label" } }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
2-7: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Update schema URL and timestamp in test fixture
- The schema URL should not point to localhost as it makes the tests environment-dependent
- The generated timestamp is from 2019, which might affect test reliability
- "$schema": "https://localhost/terminvereinbarung/api/2/", + "$schema": "https://schema.berlin.de/terminvereinbarung/api/2/", "meta": { "$schema": "https://schema.berlin.de/queuemanagement/metaresult.json", "error": false, - "generated": "2019-02-08T14:45:15+01:00", + "generated": "2024-02-08T14:45:15+01:00", "server": "Zmsapi" },📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements."$schema": "https://schema.berlin.de/terminvereinbarung/api/2/", "meta": { "$schema": "https://schema.berlin.de/queuemanagement/metaresult.json", "error": false, "generated": "2024-02-08T14:45:15+01:00", "server": "Zmsapi"zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesByOfficeListTest.php (2)
38-69: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider reducing test setup duplication.
The API call setup is duplicated across multiple test methods. Consider extracting it to a setUp method or helper function.
Example refactor:
+ private function setupMockApiCall() + { + $this->setApiCalls([ + [ + 'function' => 'readGetResult', + 'url' => '/source/unittest/', + 'parameters' => [ + 'resolveReferences' => 2, + ], + 'response' => $this->readFixture("GET_SourceGet_dldb.json"), + ] + ]); + } public function testRenderingMulti() { - $this->setApiCalls([...]); + $this->setupMockApiCall(); // rest of the test }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
105-122:
⚠️ Potential issueFix inconsistent error response structure.
The error response structure in this test differs from other error responses. The 'services' array in the error object is not present in other error responses and seems out of place.
Suggested fix:
$expectedResponse = [ 'errors' => [ [ - 'services' => [], 'errorMessage' => 'Invalid officeId(s)', + 'errorCode' => 'invalidOfficeId', 'status' => 400 ] ], 'status' => 400 ];📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.public function testNoOfficeIdProvided() { $response = $this->render([], [], []); $expectedResponse = [ 'errors' => [ [ 'errorMessage' => 'Invalid officeId(s)', 'errorCode' => 'invalidOfficeId', 'status' => 400 ] ], 'status' => 400 ]; $this->assertEquals(400, $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true)); }zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_appointments_empty.json (1)
33-38: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Use consistent placeholder values for sensitive information
The contact information contains what appears to be real addresses and locations. Consider using consistent placeholder values for sensitive information.
- "email": "[email protected]", + "email": "[email protected]", - "street": "Heerstr. 12, 14052 Berlin", + "street": "Example Street 123",Also applies to: 112-120
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGetTest.php (3)
235-252: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance invalid scope ID validation and standardize error response.
- Add test cases for more invalid formats:
- Negative numbers
- Floating point numbers
- Special characters
- Standardize error response structure to match other endpoints
+ public function testInvalidScopeIdFormats() + { + $invalidFormats = [ + 'negative' => '-1', + 'float' => '1.5', + 'special' => '@#$' + ]; + + foreach ($invalidFormats as $case => $invalidId) { + $response = $this->render([], [ + 'scopeId' => $invalidId + ], []); + + $expectedResponse = [ + 'errors' => [ + [ + 'errorCode' => 'invalidScopeIdFormat', + 'errorMessage' => "Invalid scope ID: $invalidId. Must be a number.", + 'status' => 400 + ] + ], + 'status' => 400 + ]; + + $this->assertEquals(400, $response->getStatusCode()); + $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true)); + } + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
50-101: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Refactor duplicate test data into shared fixtures.
The expected response structure is largely duplicated between test methods. Consider extracting common test data into shared fixtures or data providers.
+ /** + * @return array + */ + private function getBaseScopeData($id, $providerId) + { + return [ + 'id' => $id, + 'provider' => [ + 'id' => $providerId, + 'source' => 'unittest', + ], + 'shortName' => "Scope $id", + 'telephoneActivated' => '1', + 'telephoneRequired' => '0', + 'customTextfieldActivated' => '1', + 'customTextfieldRequired' => '0', + 'customTextfieldLabel' => 'Custom Label', + 'captchaActivatedRequired' => '1', + 'displayInfo' => null + ]; + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
136-152:
⚠️ Potential issueStandardize error response structure.
The error response structure in this test differs from others (e.g., testScopeNotFound) by:
- Including 'services' instead of 'scopes'
- Missing 'errorCode' field
Consider standardizing the error response structure across all endpoints:
$expectedResponse = [ 'errors' => [ [ - 'services' => [], + 'errorCode' => 'invalidScopeId', 'errorMessage' => 'Invalid scopeId(s).', 'status' => 400 ] ], 'status' => 400 ];Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php (2)
166-320: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Extend parameter validation refactoring to handle multiple missing parameters
The multiple parameter tests can be included in the same data provider pattern, further reducing duplication:
public function missingParameterProvider(): array { + $baseParams = [ + 'date' => '3000-09-21', + 'officeId' => '10546', + 'serviceId' => '1063423', + 'serviceCount' => '1', + ]; + return [ // Single parameter cases... + 'missing_date_and_office_id' => [ + 'parameters' => array_diff_key($baseParams, array_flip(['date', 'officeId'])), + 'errorMessages' => [ + 'date is required and must be a valid date.', + 'officeId should be a 32-bit integer.', + ], + ], // Add other multiple parameter cases... ]; } - public function testMissingParameter(array $parameters, string $errorMessage): void + public function testMissingParameter(array $parameters, array|string $errorMessages): void { + $errorMessages = is_array($errorMessages) ? $errorMessages : [$errorMessages]; $response = $this->render([], $parameters, []); $responseBody = json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true); + $errors = array_map(function($message) { + return [ + 'errorMessage' => $message, + 'status' => 400, + ]; + }, $errorMessages); $expectedResponse = [ - 'errors' => [ - [ - 'errorMessage' => $errorMessage, - 'status' => 400, - ] - ], + 'errors' => $errors, 'status' => 400 ]; $this->assertEquals(400, $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, $responseBody); }This extension:
- Handles both single and multiple parameter cases
- Uses a base parameter set to make test cases clearer
- Reduces the total amount of test code while maintaining coverage
- Makes the test suite more maintainable
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
74-164: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Refactor to reduce code duplication in parameter validation tests
The individual parameter tests follow the same pattern and contain significant duplication. Consider refactoring using a data provider:
+ /** + * @return array[] + */ + public function missingParameterProvider(): array + { + return [ + 'missing_date' => [ + 'parameters' => [ + 'officeId' => '10546', + 'serviceId' => '1063423', + 'serviceCount' => '1', + ], + 'errorMessage' => 'date is required and must be a valid date.', + ], + 'missing_office_id' => [ + 'parameters' => [ + 'date' => '3000-09-21', + 'serviceId' => '1063423', + 'serviceCount' => '1', + ], + 'errorMessage' => 'officeId should be a 32-bit integer.', + ], + // Add other cases... + ]; + } + + /** + * @dataProvider missingParameterProvider + * @test + */ + public function testMissingParameter(array $parameters, string $errorMessage): void + { + $response = $this->render([], $parameters, []); + $responseBody = json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true); + $expectedResponse = [ + 'errors' => [ + [ + 'errorMessage' => $errorMessage, + 'status' => 400, + ] + ], + 'status' => 400 + ]; + $this->assertEquals(400, $response->getStatusCode()); + $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, $responseBody); + }This refactoring would:
- Reduce code duplication
- Make it easier to add new test cases
- Improve test maintenance
- Make the test cases more visible in the data provider
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGetTest.php (1)
182-245: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Reduce test duplication using PHPUnit data providers
Consider refactoring the error test cases using a data provider to reduce code duplication and make it easier to add new test cases.
Example implementation:
/** * @dataProvider provideInvalidParameters */ public function testInvalidParameters(array $parameters, string $expectedError) { $response = $this->render([], $parameters, []); $responseBody = json_decode((string) $response->getBody(), true); $this->assertEquals(400, $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEquals([ 'errors' => [ [ 'status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => $expectedError ] ], 'status' => 400 ], $responseBody); } public function provideInvalidParameters(): array { return [ 'missing_process_id' => [ ['authKey' => 'fb43'], self::ERROR_INVALID_PROCESS_ID ], 'missing_auth_key' => [ ['processId' => '101002'], self::ERROR_INVALID_AUTH_KEY ], 'invalid_process_id' => [ ['processId' => 'invalid', 'authKey' => 'fb43'], self::ERROR_INVALID_PROCESS_ID ], 'invalid_auth_key' => [ ['processId' => '101002', 'authKey' => 12345], self::ERROR_INVALID_AUTH_KEY ] ]; }zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserveTest.php (1)
79-449: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Refactor tests to reduce duplication and improve coverage
The error handling tests are comprehensive but have significant code duplication. Consider these improvements:
- Create a data provider to combine similar test cases
- Extract common assertion logic into helper methods
- Add test for negative serviceCount values
Example refactor using data provider:
+ /** + * @return array<string, array{parameters: array, expectedError: string, expectedStatus: int}> + */ + public function provideInvalidParameters(): array + { + return [ + 'missing_office_id' => [ + 'parameters' => [ + 'serviceId' => ['1063423'], + 'serviceCount' => [0], + 'timestamp' => "32526616522", + ], + 'expectedError' => 'Missing officeId.', + 'expectedStatus' => 400 + ], + // Add other test cases... + ]; + } + + /** + * @test + * @dataProvider provideInvalidParameters + */ + public function testInvalidParameters( + array $parameters, + string $expectedError, + int $expectedStatus + ): void { + $this->setApiCalls([]); + $response = $this->render([], $parameters, [], 'POST'); + $this->assertErrorResponse($response, $expectedError, $expectedStatus); + } + + private function assertErrorResponse( + ResponseInterface $response, + string $expectedError, + int $expectedStatus + ): void { + $responseBody = json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true); + $this->assertEquals($expectedStatus, $response->getStatusCode()); + $this->assertArrayHasKey('errors', $responseBody); + $this->assertContains( + [ + 'status' => $expectedStatus, + 'errorMessage' => $expectedError, + ], + $responseBody['errors'] + ); + }Add test for negative serviceCount:
public function testNegativeServiceCount() { $this->setApiCalls([]); $parameters = [ 'officeId' => '10546', 'serviceId' => ['1063423'], 'serviceCount' => [-1], 'timestamp' => "32526616522", 'captchaSolution' => null ]; $response = $this->render([], $parameters, [], 'POST'); $responseBody = json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true); $expectedResponse = [ 'errors' => [ [ 'status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'Invalid serviceCount format. It should be an array of non-negative numeric values.', ] ], 'status' => 400 ]; $this->assertEquals(400, $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, $responseBody); }zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_calendar.json (4)
2-2: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Standardize schema URL formatting and avoid localhost
The schema URLs are inconsistent (escaped vs. unescaped slashes) and use localhost:
- "$schema": "https://localhost/terminvereinbarung/api/2/", + "$schema": "https://schema.berlin.de/terminvereinbarung/api/2/",Also applies to: 10-10
13-15:
⚠️ Potential issueStandardize date field types
Date fields use inconsistent types:
- firstDay uses numbers (13-15):
"year": 2024- days array uses strings (50-52):
"year": "2024"This could cause comparison issues in the code. Standardize to either numbers or strings.
Also applies to: 50-52
469-473: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Review handling of sensitive information in test fixtures
The fixture contains real-looking contact information. Consider:
- Using clearly fake data in test fixtures
- Documenting PII handling guidelines for test data
Also applies to: 478-485
60-65: 💡 Codebase verification
Test coverage needed for non-zero appointment scenarios
The schema files show that
allAppointmentssupports non-zero values (examples show values likepublic: 3, intern: 10), but all test fixtures inGET_calendar.jsonandGET_calendar_empty_days.jsononly test the "free" scenario with zero appointments. Additional test cases should be added to cover:
- Scenarios with non-zero public appointments
- Scenarios with non-zero intern appointments
- Scenarios with non-zero callcenter appointments
- Mixed scenarios with multiple appointment types
🔗 Analysis chain
Verify allAppointments test coverage
All
allAppointmentssections show zero values. This suggests potential missing test cases for scenarios with existing appointments.Also applies to: 78-83, 96-101
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for test files that might contain non-zero allAppointments scenarios fd -e php -e json . | xargs rg -l "allAppointments.*[1-9]"Length of output: 60
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Let's first check all test files containing allAppointments to understand the test coverage fd -e php -e json . | xargs rg -A 5 '"allAppointments"'Length of output: 23144
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php (3)
18-20:
⚠️ Potential issuePotential null reference when accessing
$request->getParsedBody()If
$requestis not an instance ofServerRequestInterface, it is set tonull, which will cause a fatal error when calling$request->getParsedBody(). It's important to ensure$requestis a validServerRequestInterfacebefore proceeding.Consider updating the code to return an error response if
$requestis not aServerRequestInterfaceinstance:public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args) { - $request = $request instanceof ServerRequestInterface ? $request : null; + if (!($request instanceof ServerRequestInterface)) { + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, ['errors' => 'Invalid request type'], 400); + } $body = $request->getParsedBody(); // ...📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.if (!($request instanceof ServerRequestInterface)) { return $this->createJsonResponse($response, ['errors' => 'Invalid request type'], 400); } $body = $request->getParsedBody();
20-27:
⚠️ Potential issueHandle potential null or invalid
$bodyfrom$request->getParsedBody()The
$bodyvariable may benullor not an array if the parsed body is empty or malformed. Accessing keys on a null or non-array value can cause errors. Ensure that$bodyis a valid array before accessing its elements.Consider adding a check to validate
$body:$body = $request->getParsedBody(); + if (!is_array($body)) { + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, ['errors' => 'Invalid request body'], 400); + } $processId = $body['processId'] ?? null; $authKey = $body['authKey'] ?? null; // ...Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
40-43:
⚠️ Potential issueEnsure 'clients' array is not empty before accessing
Accessing
$reservedProcess['clients'][0]assumes that the 'clients' array contains at least one element. If it is empty or undefined, this will result in an undefined index error. It's important to verify that the 'clients' array exists and is not empty before accessing its elements.Consider adding a check before modifying client data:
+ if (empty($reservedProcess['clients'][0])) { + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, ['errors' => 'No clients found in the process'], 400); + } $reservedProcess['clients'][0]['familyName'] = $familyName; $reservedProcess['clients'][0]['email'] = $email; $reservedProcess['clients'][0]['telephone'] = $telephone;Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/ErrorHandler.php (3)
61-66:
⚠️ Potential issueAvoid exposing sensitive information in error messages
Returning the exception message to the client when
$displayErrorDetailsistruemay expose sensitive information. This can be a security risk.Ensure that
$displayErrorDetailsis set tofalsein production environments to prevent leakage of sensitive data. Alternatively, sanitize the exception messages before sending them to the client.
29-31:
⚠️ Potential issueImport 'HttpException' to prevent runtime errors
The
HttpExceptionclass is referenced but not imported, which will cause aClass not founderror at runtime.Please add the necessary import statement at the top of the file:
+use Slim\Exception\HttpException;Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
48-48:
⚠️ Potential issueImport 'Response' class to instantiate response objects
The
Responseclass is instantiated but not imported, leading to aClass not founderror.Include the required import statement:
+use Slim\Psr7\Response;Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php (2)
81-82:
⚠️ Potential issueAvoid hardcoding email addresses; obtain client email from input
The email address is hardcoded as
'[email protected]', which may not be appropriate for all users. Consider obtaining the client's email address from the input data to personalize the communication and ensure the correct email is used.Apply this diff to address the issue:
$selectedProcess['clients'] = [ [ - 'email' => '[email protected]' + 'email' => $body['email'] ?? '[email protected]' ] ];This change attempts to retrieve the email from the request body, defaulting to
'[email protected]'if not provided. Ensure that you update the validation logic to include the email field if you make this change.Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
78-78:
⚠️ Potential issueHandle cases where no suitable process is found to prevent errors
When filtering
$freeAppointments, if no matching process is found, accessing$selectedProcess[0]will cause an undefined offset error. It's essential to check if$selectedProcessis not empty before proceeding.Apply this diff to add a check:
$selectedProcess = array_values($selectedProcess); +if (empty($selectedProcess)) { + return $this->createJsonResponse($response, [ + 'errorCode' => 'noSuitableProcessFound', + 'errorMessage' => 'No suitable appointment process found for the given timestamp' + ], 404); +} $selectedProcess = $selectedProcess[0];This ensures that if no process is found, a meaningful error response is returned rather than causing a runtime error.
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (4)
11-21: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Refactor duplicated code in static methods for better maintainability
The methods
getOffices(),getScopes(),getServices(), andgetRequestRelationList()contain duplicated code when fetching sources and retrieving lists. Consider refactoring the common logic into a private helper method to improve maintainability and reduce redundancy.Suggested refactor:
+ private static function getSources() + { + return \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [ + 'resolveReferences' => 2, + ])->getEntity(); + } public static function getOffices() { - $sources = \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [ - 'resolveReferences' => 2, - ])->getEntity(); + $sources = self::getSources(); $providerList = $sources->getProviderList() ?? []; return $providerList; } public static function getScopes() { - $sources = \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [ - 'resolveReferences' => 2, - ])->getEntity(); + $sources = self::getSources(); $scopeList = $sources->getScopeList() ?? []; return $scopeList; } public static function getServices() { - $sources = \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [ - 'resolveReferences' => 2, - ])->getEntity(); + $sources = self::getSources(); $requestList = $sources->getRequestList() ?? []; return $requestList; } public static function getRequestRelationList() { - $sources = \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [ - 'resolveReferences' => 2, - ])->getEntity(); + $sources = self::getSources(); $requestRelationList = $sources->getRequestRelationList(); return $requestRelationList; }Also applies to: 23-33, 35-45, 47-57
158-164: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve exception handling by accessing exception properties directly
Using
json_encodeandjson_decodeon an exception object to access its properties is unconventional and may lead to unintended behavior. Consider accessing the exception properties directly.Suggested change:
} catch (\Exception $e) { - $exceptionName = json_decode(json_encode($e), true)['template'] ?? null; + $exceptionName = get_class($e); if ($exceptionName === 'BO\\Zmsapi\\Exception\\Process\\MoreThanAllowedAppointmentsPerMail') { $exception = [ 'exception' => 'tooManyAppointmentsWithSameMail' ]; return $exception; } throw $e; }Ensure that the exception's class or code is used appropriately to identify the specific exception.
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
101-109:
⚠️ Potential issueValidate input arrays to prevent undefined index errors
In the
foreachloop, you're accessing$serviceCounts[$index]without checking if the index exists. If$serviceCountshas missing or extra elements, it could lead to undefined index errors. Consider adding validation to ensure both arrays are properly aligned.Suggested fix:
foreach ($serviceIds as $index => $serviceId) { + if (!isset($serviceCounts[$index])) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException("Service count is missing for service ID at index $index"); + } $count = intval($serviceCounts[$index]); + if ($count <= 0) { + continue; // Skip if count is zero or negative + } for ($i = 0; $i < $count; $i++) { $requests[] = [ 'id' => $serviceId, 'source' => 'dldb' ]; } }This ensures that
$serviceCounts[$index]exists and that the count is a positive integer.📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.foreach ($serviceIds as $index => $serviceId) { if (!isset($serviceCounts[$index])) { throw new \InvalidArgumentException("Service count is missing for service ID at index $index"); } $count = intval($serviceCounts[$index]); if ($count <= 0) { continue; // Skip if count is zero or negative } for ($i = 0; $i < $count; $i++) { $requests[] = [ 'id' => $serviceId, 'source' => 'dldb' ]; } }
154-165:
⚠️ Potential issueEnsure all exceptions are properly handled in submitClientData
In the
catchblock, if the exception is not of typeMoreThanAllowedAppointmentsPerMail, the method does not return anything, which may lead to unexpected behavior. Consider rethrowing the exception or handling it appropriately.Suggested fix:
} catch (\Exception $e) { $exceptionName = json_decode(json_encode($e), true)['template'] ?? null; if ($exceptionName === 'BO\\Zmsapi\\Exception\\Process\\MoreThanAllowedAppointmentsPerMail') { $exception = [ 'exception' => 'tooManyAppointmentsWithSameMail' ]; return $exception; } + throw $e; // Re-throw the exception if it's not the specific one }Alternatively, you may want to return an error response or handle other exceptions as needed.
📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.try { $result = \App::$http->readPostResult($url, $processEntity); return $result->getEntity(); } catch (\Exception $e) { $exceptionName = json_decode(json_encode($e), true)['template'] ?? null; if ($exceptionName === 'BO\\Zmsapi\\Exception\\Process\\MoreThanAllowedAppointmentsPerMail') { $exception = [ 'exception' => 'tooManyAppointmentsWithSameMail' ]; return $exception; } throw $e; // Re-throw the exception if it's not the specific one }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (4)
39-56: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Standardize error response structure and status codes
The methods return error responses with inconsistent structures and status codes, which can lead to confusion when handling responses.
Consider standardizing the error response format. For example:
- When there are no errors, return a success status (e.g.,
200) without anerrorsarray.- When errors are present, return a consistent structure with
status,errorCode, anderrorMessage.Example adjustment:
if (!empty($errors)) { return [ 'status' => 400, 'errors' => $errors, ]; } return [ 'status' => 200, 'message' => 'Validation successful.', ];This ensures that the response format is predictable and easier to handle on the client side.
Also applies to: 81-110, 114-158, 163-172, 177-187, 192-202, 206-217, 221-232, 236-246, 250-260, 264-274, 278-288, 292-302, 306-313, 319-365, 372-385, 389-402
96-101:
⚠️ Potential issueImprove validation of service IDs and counts
The current validation of
$serviceIdsand$serviceCountsmay not correctly handle empty arrays or non-numeric values.Apply this diff to enhance validation:
-if (empty($serviceIds[0]) || !preg_match('/^\d+(,\d+)*$/', implode(',', $serviceIds))) { +if (empty($serviceIds) || array_filter($serviceIds, fn($id) => !is_numeric($id))) { $errors[] = [ 'status' => 400, - 'errorMessage' => 'serviceId should be a comma-separated string of integers.', + 'errorMessage' => 'serviceIds should be an array of numeric values.', ]; }Explanation:
- Checks if
$serviceIdsis empty.- Uses
array_filterto identify non-numeric IDs.- Updates error messages for clarity.
Also applies to: 103-110, 127-137, 151-158
349-354: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Allow telephone to be optional and nullable
Currently, if
$telephoneis provided asnull, the validation may incorrectly add an error. If the telephone field is optional, the validation should allow it to benullor a valid string.Apply this diff to adjust the validation:
-if ($telephone !== null && !$telephone || !preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone)) { +if ($telephone !== null && (!preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone))) {Explanation:
- Ensures that if
$telephoneis notnull, it must match the specified pattern.- Allows
$telephoneto benullwithout triggering an error.📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.if ($telephone !== null && (!preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone))) { $errors[] = [ 'status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'telephone should be a numeric string between 7 and 15 digits.', ]; }
349-354:
⚠️ Potential issueFix logical error in telephone validation
The condition for validating the
$telephonevariable contains a logical error, which may lead to incorrect error reporting or acceptance of invalid input.Apply this diff to correct the condition:
-if ($telephone !== null && !$telephone || !preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone)) { +if ($telephone !== null && (!preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone))) {Explanation:
- Removed the
!$telephonecheck because if$telephoneis an empty string or zero,!$telephonewould evaluate totrue, which is not the intended behavior.- Simplified the condition to focus on validating the format of
$telephonewhen it is notnull.📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.if ($telephone !== null && (!preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone))) { $errors[] = [ 'status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'telephone should be a numeric string between 7 and 15 digits.', ]; }zmscitizenapi/routing.php (3)
230-602:
⚠️ Potential issueAdd security definitions to protect API endpoints
The API endpoints currently lack security requirements in the Swagger annotations. If these endpoints require authentication or authorization, it's important to define security schemes to enforce access control and document the expected authentication method.
Add a security definition to your Swagger/OpenAPI specification and apply it to the endpoints:
# Security scheme definition securityDefinitions: BearerAuth: type: apiKey name: Authorization in: header # Global security requirement (applies to all endpoints) security: - BearerAuth: []Or apply the security requirement to specific endpoints:
get: summary: Get the list of available appointments tags: - appointments + security: + - BearerAuth: [] parameters: - name: dateEnsure that your application checks the 'Authorization' header and validates the token or credentials provided.
350-399:
⚠️ Potential issueSpecify HTTP response codes and messages consistently
In the '/reserve-appointment/' endpoint, the 404 response description is "Appointment not found," which may not be appropriate for a reservation action. Typically, a 404 response is used for retrieval endpoints when a resource is not found.
Consider updating or removing the 404 response for this endpoint:
- description: Appointment not found + description: Not applicable for reservation endpointAlternatively, if a 404 response is expected, provide a more suitable description that aligns with the reservation context.
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
277-318: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance input validation for 'processId' and 'authKey' in '/appointment/' endpoint
Currently, 'processId' and 'authKey' have specific formats that are only described in the documentation. Implementing pattern validation can enforce correct input formats at the API level.
Update the parameter definitions to include format validation:
- name: processId description: The unique identifier for the process. Must be an integer starting with 10 or 11. in: query required: true type: integer + pattern: '^(10|11)\d+$' - name: authKey description: The authentication key consisting of 4 to 5 alphanumeric characters. in: query required: true type: string + pattern: '^[a-zA-Z0-9]{4,5}$'This ensures that only valid input reaches your application logic, enhancing security and reliability.
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (1)
151-162:
⚠️ Potential issueFix incorrect access to 'scopes' in 'getScopeByOfficeId' method
In the
getScopeByOfficeIdmethod, you're callingself::getScopes(), which returns an array containing 'scopes' and 'status' keys. However, you are iterating directly over$scopes, which leads to incorrect access of the scope data.Apply this diff to fix the issue:
try { - $scopes = self::getScopes(); + $scopesResponse = self::getScopes(); + $scopes = $scopesResponse['scopes']; foreach ($scopes as $scope) { if (isset($scope['provider']) && $scope['provider']->id == $officeId) { return $scope; } }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableDaysListTest.php (1)
78-101:
⚠️ Potential issueInconsistent error message and status code for invalid date formats
The
testInvalidDateFormatmethod is checking for invalid date formats but expects a 404 status code with an error message indicating no appointments are available at the office. Invalid date formats should result in a 400 Bad Request status with an appropriate error message about the invalid date.Apply the following changes to align the error response with the invalid date format:
$expectedResponse = [ 'errors' => [ [ - 'errorCode' => 'noAppointmentForThisOffice', - 'errorMessage' => 'An diesem Standort gibt es aktuell leider keine freien Termine.', - 'status' => 404, + 'errorMessage' => 'startDate and endDate must be valid dates.', + 'status' => 400, ] ], - 'status' => 404, + 'status' => 400, ]; - $this->assertEquals(404, $response->getStatusCode()); + $this->assertEquals(400, $response->getStatusCode());📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.public function testInvalidDateFormat() { $parameters = [ 'officeId' => '9999998', 'serviceId' => '1', 'serviceCount' => '1', 'startDate' => 'invalid-date', 'endDate' => 'invalid-date', ]; $response = $this->render([], $parameters, []); $responseBody = json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true); $expectedResponse = [ 'errors' => [ [ 'errorMessage' => 'startDate and endDate must be valid dates.', 'status' => 400, ] ], 'status' => 400, ]; $this->assertEquals(400, $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, $responseBody);zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdateTest.php (1)
156-1797: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Refactor repetitive test methods using data providers
The test methods from
testInvalidProcessid_InvalidAuthkey_InvalidFamilyname_InvalidEmail_InvalidTelephone_InvalidCustomtextfield(line 156) onwards are highly repetitive, differing only in the combinations of valid and invalid input parameters. This duplication increases maintenance overhead and reduces readability. Consider refactoring these tests using PHPUnit's data providers to supply different parameter sets, thereby consolidating the tests into fewer methods.Suggestion:
Refactor the repetitive test methods into a single test method that utilizes a data provider. Here's an example of how this can be implemented:
/** * @dataProvider invalidParameterProvider */ public function testInvalidParameters($parameters, $expectedResponse) { $response = $this->render([], $parameters, [], 'POST'); $responseBody = json_decode((string) $response->getBody(), true); $this->assertEquals($expectedResponse['status'], $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, $responseBody); } public function invalidParameterProvider() { return [ 'AllInvalidParameters' => [ 'parameters' => [ 'processId' => null, 'authKey' => '', 'familyName' => '', 'email' => 'invalid-email', 'telephone' => '123', 'customTextfield' => 123, ], 'expectedResponse' => [ 'errors' => [ ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'processId should be a positive 32-bit integer.'], ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'authKey should be a non-empty string.'], ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'familyName should be a non-empty string.'], ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'email should be a valid email address.'], ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'telephone should be a numeric string between 7 and 15 digits.'], ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'customTextfield should be a string.'], ], 'status' => 400, ], ], 'InvalidEmailValidTelephone' => [ 'parameters' => [ 'processId' => '101002', 'authKey' => 'fb43', 'familyName' => 'Smith', 'email' => 'invalid-email', 'telephone' => '123456789', 'customTextfield' => 'Some custom text', ], 'expectedResponse' => [ 'errors' => [ ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'email should be a valid email address.'], ], 'status' => 400, ], ], // Additional test cases... ]; }By utilizing a data provider, you can:
- Reduce code duplication: Eliminate the need for multiple test methods that differ only in their input parameters.
- Improve maintainability: Easily add, modify, or remove test cases without altering the test logic.
- Enhance readability: Provide a clear overview of all test scenarios and expected outcomes in one place.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 15
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (11)
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php (2)
9-36: Consider improving test robustnessWhile the happy path test is functional, consider these improvements:
- Use a dynamic future date instead of hardcoding '3000-09-21'
- Document the meaning of the timestamp 32526616522
- Add assertions for the complete response structure
Example improvement:
public function testRendering() { $this->setApiCalls( [ [ 'function' => 'readPostResult', 'url' => '/process/status/free/', 'response' => $this->readFixture("GET_appointments.json") ] ] ); $parameters = [ - 'date' => '3000-09-21', + 'date' => date('Y-m-d', strtotime('+1 year')), 'officeId' => 10546, 'serviceId' => '1063423', 'serviceCount' => '1', ]; $response = $this->render([], $parameters, []); $responseBody = json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true); $expectedResponse = [ 'appointmentTimestamps' => [32526616522], 'status' => 200, ]; $this->assertEquals(200, $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, $responseBody); + // Validate response structure + $this->assertArrayHasKey('appointmentTimestamps', $responseBody); + $this->assertIsArray($responseBody['appointmentTimestamps']); + $this->assertNotEmpty($responseBody['appointmentTimestamps']); + foreach ($responseBody['appointmentTimestamps'] as $timestamp) { + $this->assertIsInt($timestamp); + } }
39-72: Consider extracting test data setup and using translation keysThe test is well-structured but could benefit from:
- Extracting common parameter setup to reduce duplication
- Using translation keys instead of hardcoded German error messages
Example improvement:
+ private function getDefaultParameters(): array + { + return [ + 'date' => date('Y-m-d', strtotime('+1 year')), + 'officeId' => 10546, + 'serviceId' => '1063423', + 'serviceCount' => '1', + ]; + } public function testEmptyAppointments() { $this->setApiCalls([ [ 'function' => 'readPostResult', 'url' => '/process/status/free/', 'response' => $this->readFixture("GET_appointments_empty.json") ] ]); - $parameters = [ - 'date' => '3000-09-21', - 'officeId' => 10546, - 'serviceId' => '1063423', - 'serviceCount' => '1', - ]; + $parameters = $this->getDefaultParameters(); $response = $this->render([], $parameters, []); $expectedResponse = [ 'errors' => [ [ 'appointmentTimestamps' => [], 'errorCode' => "appointmentNotAvailable", - 'errorMessage' => 'Der von Ihnen gewählte Termin ist leider nicht mehr verfügbar.', + 'errorMessage' => $this->translate('error.appointment.not.available'), 'status' => 404, ] ], 'status' => 404 ]; $this->assertEquals(404, $response->getStatusCode()); $this->assertEqualsCanonicalizing($expectedResponse, json_decode((string)$response->getBody(), true)); }zmscitizenapi/routing.php (2)
25-29: Consider implementing rate limiting for public endpointsThese public endpoints could be vulnerable to abuse. Consider:
- Implementing rate limiting per IP/client
- Adding request throttling for sensitive operations
Also applies to: 49-53, 73-77, 97-101, 129-133
270-323: Consider optimizing appointment workflow implementationThe appointment-related endpoints show a complex workflow with multiple states (reserve, preconfirm, confirm, cancel). Consider:
- Implementing a state machine pattern to manage appointment states
- Extracting common error response schema to a shared definition
- Adding workflow validation to prevent invalid state transitions
Example state machine implementation:
namespace BO\Zmscitizenapi\Appointment; class AppointmentStateMachine { private const STATES = [ 'RESERVED' => ['PRECONFIRMED', 'CANCELLED'], 'PRECONFIRMED' => ['CONFIRMED', 'CANCELLED'], 'CONFIRMED' => ['CANCELLED'], 'CANCELLED' => [] ]; public function canTransition(string $currentState, string $newState): bool { return in_array($newState, self::STATES[$currentState] ?? []); } }Also applies to: 349-398, 400-449, 451-500, 502-551, 553-602
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (3)
1-11: Consider implementing an interface and adding class-level documentation.The class structure is well-organized, but could benefit from:
- Implementing an interface to define the contract for ZMS API interactions
- Adding PHPDoc with
@packageand class description<?php namespace BO\Zmscitizenapi\Services; use BO\Zmscitizenapi\Helper\UtilityHelper; use \BO\Zmsentities\Process; use \BO\Zmsentities\Scope; use \BO\Zmsentities\Collection\ScopeList; +/** + * @package BO\Zmscitizenapi\Services + * Facade service for ZMS API interactions, providing simplified interface for office, + * service, and appointment-related operations. + */ +interface ZmsApiFacadeServiceInterface { + public static function getOffices(): array; + // ... other method signatures +} + -class ZmsApiFacadeService +class ZmsApiFacadeService implements ZmsApiFacadeServiceInterface
609-629: Critical appointment management methods are missing.The following essential methods are marked as TODO:
- preconfirmAppointment
- confirmAppointment
- cancelAppointment
These methods are crucial for complete appointment lifecycle management.
Would you like me to help implement these methods or create GitHub issues to track their implementation?
631-633: Improve code style with modern PHP features.Consider the following improvements:
- Remove extra empty lines at the end of the file
- Add return type declarations to all methods
- Use PHP 7.4+ property type declarations
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php (1)
89-93: Consider allowing client email to be provided by the requesterCurrently, the client email is hardcoded as
'[email protected]', which might not meet the requirements for notifying the client or for records.Consider accepting the client's email from the request body:
+ $clientEmail = $body['email'] ?? '[email protected]';zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (3)
5-5: Consider utilizing\BO\Mellon\Validatorfor input validationSince you've imported
\BO\Mellon\Validator, it would be beneficial to leverage its existing validation methods. This can help maintain consistency across the application and reduce redundant code.
313-313: Add type hints to method parameters invalidateUpdateAppointmentInputsAdding type hints enhances code readability and enforces type safety. This method lacks type hints for its parameters.
Apply this diff to include type hints:
-public static function validateUpdateAppointmentInputs($processId, $authKey, $familyName, $email, $telephone, $customTextfield) +public static function validateUpdateAppointmentInputs(int $processId, string $authKey, string $familyName, string $email, ?string $telephone, ?string $customTextfield): array
15-398: Refactor to eliminate duplicated validation logicSeveral methods perform similar validations, such as checking if IDs are numeric or arrays are not empty.
Consider creating helper functions to handle common validation tasks. For example:
validateNumericId($id, $fieldName)validateNumericArray($array, $fieldName)This approach adheres to the DRY principle and enhances maintainability.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (14)
zmscitizenapi/routing.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGet.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserveTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGetTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_appointments.json(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_appointments_free.json(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_calendar.json(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_calendar_empty_days.json(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_reserve_SourceGet_dldb.json(1 hunks)
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_reserve_SourceGet_dldb.json
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (8)
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGet.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserveTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGetTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_appointments.json
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_appointments_free.json
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_calendar.json
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/fixtures/GET_calendar_empty_days.json
🔇 Additional comments (5)
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php (2)
1-8: LGTM! Class structure follows testing best practices
The class is properly structured with appropriate namespace and inheritance.
1-321: Overall test suite is well-structured and comprehensive
The test suite provides thorough coverage of the appointment list functionality. While there are opportunities for improvement in terms of code organization and maintainability, the core functionality and test cases are solid.
Let's verify the test coverage:
✅ Verification successful
Test coverage is comprehensive and matches implementation
The test suite in AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php provides thorough coverage of the AvailableAppointmentsList endpoint's functionality:
-
The validation rules in
ValidationService::validateGetAvailableAppointments()are fully covered by test cases:- Required date parameter (
testDateMissing) - Valid officeId as 32-bit integer (
testOfficeIdMissing) - Comma-separated serviceId integers (
testServiceIdMissing) - Comma-separated serviceCount integers (
testServiceCountMissing)
- Required date parameter (
-
The test cases also cover combinations of missing parameters:
- Date + OfficeId missing
- Date + ServiceId missing
- Date + ServiceCount missing
- OfficeId + ServiceId missing
- OfficeId + ServiceCount missing
- ServiceId + ServiceCount missing
-
The successful and empty appointment scenarios are verified:
- Success case with timestamp response (
testRendering) - Empty appointments with 404 response (
testEmptyAppointments)
- Success case with timestamp response (
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check if all public methods in AvailableAppointmentsList are covered by tests
# Find the implementation class
ast-grep --pattern 'class AvailableAppointmentsList {
$$$
public function $method($_) {
$$$
}
$$$
}'
# Find corresponding test methods
ast-grep --pattern 'function test$_() {
$$$
}'
Length of output: 165
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's try a different approach to find the implementation class and its methods
# First, let's find the implementation file
fd "AvailableAppointmentsList.php" --exclude "*Test.php"
# Then let's examine its content if found
rg "class AvailableAppointmentsList" -A 20
# Also check the base class it might be extending from
rg "extends.*Controller" --type php
Length of output: 33490
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's examine the implementation file content
cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsList.php
# Also check the base class to understand the inherited functionality
cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php
Length of output: 2156
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's examine the ZmsApiFacadeService to understand the validation logic
cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php
# Also check if there are any interface/contract definitions
fd "ZmsApiFacadeService" --type f --exclude "*Test.php"
Length of output: 21774
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's examine the validation service to understand the validation rules
cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php
# Also check the utility helper for date validation
cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/UtilityHelper.php
Length of output: 16660
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php (3)
65-70: Handle potential empty 'appointments' array in $process
In the anonymous function used with array_filter, if 'appointments' is not set or not an array, the function returns false. However, if 'appointments' exists but is empty, array_column will return an empty array, and in_array will always return false. This might exclude valid processes.
Consider checking if 'appointments' is not empty:
Alternatively, ensure that processes with empty 'appointments' are handled appropriately.
112-115:
Avoid exposing exception messages to the client
Returning the raw exception message in the API response may reveal sensitive information. It's better to log the exception internally and return a generic error message to the client.
As previously mentioned, consider using the ErrorHandler for consistent error handling as shown in:
Apply this diff to modify the error response:
81-81: Method withUpdatedData may not update $selectedProcess as intended
The method withUpdatedData is called but does not appear to modify $selectedProcess unless it returns $this. If it doesn't, the updated data might not persist.
Please ensure that withUpdatedData updates $selectedProcess as intended. If the method doesn't return the modified object, you might need to assign the result back:
Run the following script to verify the behavior:
✅ Verification successful
Method withUpdatedData correctly returns $this and updates the object
The implementation in Process.php shows that the method correctly updates the object's properties and returns $this at the end, making the method call in AppointmentReserve.php work as intended. The current implementation is correct and no changes are needed.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Check if the withUpdatedData method returns the updated object.
# Test: Search for the withUpdatedData method definition
rg -A 5 'function withUpdatedData' src/
# Expected: The method should return $this at the end.
Length of output: 86
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's try searching in the correct directory structure
fd -t f withUpdatedData --exec rg -A 5 'function withUpdatedData' {}
Length of output: 72
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's try a broader search for the method implementation
rg -l "withUpdatedData" --type php
# Then search for the actual implementation
ast-grep --pattern 'function withUpdatedData($_) {
$$$
}'
Length of output: 395
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's examine the implementation in Process.php since it's likely the base class
rg -A 10 "function withUpdatedData" zmsentities/src/Zmsentities/Process.php
Length of output: 671
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 9
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (12)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGet.php (1)
12-21: Add PHPDoc block with parameter and return type documentationThe method should include comprehensive documentation describing expected parameters, return type, and possible exceptions.
+ /** + * Retrieves an appointment process by ID + * + * @param RequestInterface $request The incoming HTTP request + * @param ResponseInterface $response The response object + * @param array $args Route arguments + * @return ResponseInterface JSON response containing process data + * @throws \InvalidArgumentException When required parameters are missing or invalid + */ public function readResponse(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args): ResponseInterfacezmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirm.php (1)
10-11: Add class-level documentationSince this is a public API endpoint for appointment confirmation, please add a PHPDoc block describing the class purpose, responsibilities, and expected usage.
Example:
+/** + * Handles appointment confirmation requests. + * + * This endpoint is responsible for confirming appointments in the system. + * Endpoint: POST /confirm-appointment/ + */ class AppointmentConfirm extends BaseControllerzmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php (2)
10-15: Consider injecting time dependency.Using
time()directly makes the code harder to test. Consider injecting a time provider or using a wrapper service for better testability.- $noCacheResponse = \BO\Slim\Render::withLastModified($response, time(), '0'); + $noCacheResponse = \BO\Slim\Render::withLastModified($response, $this->getTimeProvider()->getCurrentTime(), '0');You'll need to add a time provider interface and implementation:
interface TimeProviderInterface { public function getCurrentTime(): int; } class SystemTimeProvider implements TimeProviderInterface { public function getCurrentTime(): int { return time(); } }
1-40: Consider enhancing base functionality.As this is a base controller for the zmscitizenapi module, consider adding:
- Common error handling methods
- Request validation utilities
- Response formatting consistency
- Logging infrastructure
This would ensure consistent behavior across all derived controllers.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php (1)
55-57: Redundant catch block without handlingThe
catchblock rethrows the caught exception without any additional handling or logging. This is redundant and can be removed to simplify the code.You can safely remove the
try-catchblock if no specific exception handling is required:...After removal:
... // Code inside try block remains unchangedzmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (2)
98-103: Simplify validation logic for$serviceIdsIn the
validateGetAvailableAppointmentsmethod, the validation for$serviceIdscan be simplified and made more robust.Consider using
array_filterwithis_numericdirectly:+ if (empty($serviceIds) || !is_array($serviceIds) || count(array_filter($serviceIds, 'is_numeric')) !== count($serviceIds)) {This ensures all elements in
$serviceIdsare numeric.
364-378: Improve parameter validation messages invalidateServiceIdParamThe method
validateServiceIdParamreturns error messages within an array for each invalid ID but doesn't provide a consolidated response.Consider aggregating errors and returning a structured response:
+ // Suggestion: Return a single error message with all invalid IDs + if (!empty($errors)) { + return [ + 'status' => 400, + 'errorMessage' => 'Invalid service IDs provided.', + 'invalidServiceIds' => array_column($errors, 'errorMessage') + ]; + }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php (1)
67-72: Simplify filtering of processesThe filtering logic for
$filteredProcessescan be optimized for readability and efficiency.Consider simplifying the filter function:
+ $filteredProcesses = array_filter($processArray, fn($process) => + isset($process['appointments']) && + is_array($process['appointments']) && + in_array($timestamp, array_column($process['appointments'], 'date')) + );This makes the code more concise and easier to read.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php (1)
33-52: Optimize scope retrieval to enhance performanceIn the
mapOfficesWithScopemethod, you are fetching scopes within the method usingZmsApiClientService::getScopes(). If this method is called multiple times, it could lead to redundant API calls and impact performance. Consider passing theScopeListas a parameter to avoid unnecessary data fetching.zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (2)
98-100: Use a custom exception for invalid API responsesIn the
getFreeTimeslotsmethod, throwing a generic\Exceptionmakes error handling less precise. Implement a custom exception to provide clearer context.Apply this diff:
- throw new \Exception('Invalid response from API'); + throw new InvalidApiResponseException('Invalid response from API in getFreeTimeslots');Make sure to define the
InvalidApiResponseExceptionclass appropriately.
127-128: Handle client IP address retrieval securelyDirectly accessing
$_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR']may not always provide the correct client IP, especially in environments with proxy servers. Consider using a method that accounts for proxy headers.zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (1)
382-382: Ensure consistent response structure ingetServicesProvidedAtOfficeThe method returns raw data without wrapping it in a standardized response format. For consistency and better error handling, consider returning data within a structured response.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (24)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentCancel.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirm.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGet.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentPreconfirm.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableDaysList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/CaptchaGet.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/UtilityHelper.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesServicesRelations.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGet.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopesList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ExceptionService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/FriendlyCaptchaService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesByOfficeList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesList.php(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (15)
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableDaysList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentPreconfirm.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopesList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesServicesRelations.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentCancel.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/CaptchaGet.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGet.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/FriendlyCaptchaService.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesByOfficeList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ExceptionService.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/UtilityHelper.php
🔇 Additional comments (13)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGet.php (2)
1-11: LGTM: Class structure and imports are well-organized
The class follows PSR-4 standards with proper namespace and import declarations.
1-23: Verify integration with error handling middleware
Ensure that the exception handling in this controller integrates properly with any global error handling middleware.
✅ Verification successful
Let me gather more specific information about the error handling setup in the zmscitizenapi module.
Let me check the ExceptionService implementation and the bootstrap file to understand the error handling setup better.
Let me check the custom ErrorHandler implementation to complete the verification.
Error handling is properly integrated with global middleware
The AppointmentGet controller is well-integrated with the application's error handling system. The codebase has:
- A global error handling middleware configured in bootstrap.php
- A custom ErrorHandler that implements Slim's ErrorHandlerInterface
- Standardized error response formatting with proper status codes and JSON output
- Environment-aware error detail display
- Error logging capabilities
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for error handling middleware and exception handlers
rg -t php "class.*Exception|handleException|error.*middleware" --type php
Length of output: 18815
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check for error handling setup in zmscitizenapi
rg -t php "class.*Exception|handleException|error.*middleware" --type php zmscitizenapi/
Length of output: 175
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check ExceptionService implementation and bootstrap file
echo "=== ExceptionService implementation ==="
cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ExceptionService.php
echo -e "\n=== Bootstrap file ==="
cat zmscitizenapi/bootstrap.php
Length of output: 3011
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check custom ErrorHandler implementation
cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/ErrorHandler.php
Length of output: 2445
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirm.php (2)
1-9: LGTM: Namespace and imports are well-structured
The namespace follows PSR-4 autoloading standard and imports are properly organized.
1-16: Consider architectural consistency and validation reuse
As discussed in the PR comments, consider:
- Evaluating potential validation reuse from
\BO\Mellonnamespace - If no suitable validations exist, consider creating a shared validation service that both modules can use
- Ensure the response structure aligns with other endpoints in the zmscitizenapi module
Let's check the response structure of other endpoints:
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php (2)
1-7: LGTM! Clean namespace and imports.
The namespace follows PSR-4 standard and imports are properly defined.
8-9: Verify parent class contract.
The class extends \BO\Slim\Controller. Let's ensure we're properly implementing its contract.
✅ Verification successful
Parent class contract is properly implemented
The verification shows that BaseController correctly extends \BO\Slim\Controller and properly implements its contract:
- The parent class
\BO\Slim\Controlleris abstract and defines core functionality for handling HTTP requests BaseControlleroverrides__invoke()with proper type hints and adds caching control- It provides a hook method
readResponse()for child controllers - No abstract methods in the parent class need implementation
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify parent class existence and its abstract methods
# Search for the parent class definition and any abstract methods that need to be implemented
ast-grep --pattern 'class Controller {
$$$
}'
# Also check for abstract method declarations
ast-grep --pattern 'abstract function $_($$)'
Length of output: 97
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's try a different approach to find the parent class and its contract
# First, let's search for any file containing "BO\Slim\Controller"
rg -l "BO\\\\Slim\\\\Controller"
# Then, let's look for any PHP files with "Controller" in their name or content
fd -e php -x rg -l "class.*Controller" {}
# Finally, let's check for any abstract method declarations in BaseController
rg "abstract.*function" zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php
Length of output: 16207
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's examine the Slim Controller implementation in zmsslim
cat zmsslim/src/Slim/Controller.php
# Also check the BaseController implementation
cat zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php
Length of output: 3846
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php (2)
19-21:
Potential null reference error with $request
If $request is not an instance of ServerRequestInterface, it is set to null. However, $request->getParsedBody() is called without checking if $request is null, which can lead to a fatal error.
Consider adding a check for null before using $request:
+ if ($request === null) {
+ return $this->createJsonResponse($response, [
+ 'errorCode' => 'invalidRequest',
+ 'errorMessage' => 'Invalid request type'
+ ], 400);
+ }41-50: Ensure CAPTCHA requirement check is accurate
In the appointment reservation logic, the condition $providerScope['captchaActivatedRequired'] === "1" assumes that the value is a string. Ensure that the value of 'captchaActivatedRequired' is consistently a string "1" or update the condition to handle different data types to avoid unexpected behavior.
Run the following script to verify the data type of 'captchaActivatedRequired':
✅ Verification successful
Let me gather more information about how this value is being used across the codebase.
Let me try one more search to find any type definitions or other usages of this field.
Let me try one final search to find the getter method implementation.
Based on the gathered evidence, I can now provide the final response:
The strict comparison with string "1" is consistent with the codebase's implementation
The codebase shows a consistent pattern where captchaActivatedRequired is handled as a string value. This is evident from:
- The value is set via
getCaptchaActivatedRequired()getter method in multiple places inZmsApiFacadeService - The value is mapped consistently in
MapperServicewith null coalescing - The strict comparison
=== "1"is used only once inAppointmentReserve.phpfor the CAPTCHA check
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify the data type of 'captchaActivatedRequired' in provider scopes.
# Test: Fetch provider scopes and check the data type
# Expected: Consistent data type (string or integer) for 'captchaActivatedRequired'
# Fetch scopes where 'captchaActivatedRequired' is set
rg -t php -A 5 "'captchaActivatedRequired'" zmscitizenapi/src/
# Alternatively, if data can be fetched from a configuration or database, adjust the command accordingly
Length of output: 1399
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for any assignments or comparisons with captchaActivatedRequired
ast-grep --pattern 'captchaActivatedRequired'
# Also search for any other string comparisons with "1" to see the pattern
rg -t php '=== "1"' zmscitizenapi/src/
# Check the provider scope structure or type definitions if any
fd -e php -exec grep -l "ProviderScope" {} \; zmscitizenapi/src/
Length of output: 491
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for provider scope related files and their content
fd -e php -x grep -l "provider.*scope" {} \; zmscitizenapi/src/
# Look for any other comparisons or assignments of this field
rg -t php "captchaActivatedRequired.*=" zmscitizenapi/src/
# Check if there are any API response or request type definitions
rg -t php "class.*Provider" zmscitizenapi/src/
Length of output: 1651
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for the getter method implementation
ast-grep --pattern 'function getCaptchaActivatedRequired'
# Also look for any class that might contain this method
rg -t php -B 5 'getCaptchaActivatedRequired' zmscitizenapi/src/
Length of output: 4575
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (1)
342-347:
Ensure correct validation of $telephone field
The condition for validating $telephone may lead to incorrect validation due to operator precedence.
Add parentheses to ensure the logical conditions are evaluated correctly:
+ if ($telephone !== null && (empty($telephone) || !preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone))) {Alternatively, consider simplifying the condition for better readability.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php (1)
23-25:
Potential null reference error with $request
Similar to AppointmentUpdate, if $request is not an instance of ServerRequestInterface, it is set to null. Calling $request->getParsedBody() without checking if $request is null can lead to a fatal error.
Add a null check before using $request:
+ if ($request === null) {
+ return $this->createJsonResponse($response, [
+ 'errorCode' => 'invalidRequest',
+ 'errorMessage' => 'Invalid request type'
+ ], 400);
+ }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php (1)
55-88: Verify combinable services mapping logic
In mapServicesWithCombinations, the logic for mapping combinable services may not account for all edge cases, such as services without combinations or mismatched provider IDs.
Run the following script to check for services without combinable counterparts:
This will help ensure that the combinable services are correctly mapped and no services are missed.
✅ Verification successful
Combinable services mapping logic is correctly implemented
The code handles all edge cases appropriately:
- Checks for existence of 'combinable' data before processing (
isset($service->getAdditionalData()['combinable'])) - Safely handles missing provider IDs using null coalescing operator (
$servicesProviderIds[$service->getId()] ?? []) - Returns empty array for providers when there's no intersection (
!empty($commonProviders) ? array_values($commonProviders) : []) - Only adds 'combinable' field to mapped service when combinations exist
The test file confirms this implementation with test cases covering services with combinations.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Find services that have 'combinable' additional data but no matching providers.
# Test: Search for services with 'combinable' data.
ast-grep --pattern '
function getAdditionalData() {
return [
"combinable" => $_
];
}' --lang php
Length of output: 114
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Let's try a different approach to find references to combinable services
# Search for array definitions containing 'combinable' key
rg -U "['\"](combinable)['\"].*=>" --type php -A 3
# Search for getAdditionalData method implementations
ast-grep --pattern 'function getAdditionalData()' --lang php
# Search for array assignments containing combinable
rg "'combinable'" --type php -B 2 -A 2
Length of output: 1775
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (2)
161-161: Remove hardcoded source name for flexibility
The source name 'dldb' is hardcoded in getScopeByOfficeId. Replace it with \App::$source_name to use the configured source.
Apply this diff:
- $matchingScope = $scopeList->withProviderID('dldb', $officeId)->getIterator()->current();
+ $matchingScope = $scopeList->withProviderID(\App::$source_name, $officeId)->getIterator()->current();565-591: Standardize exception handling for missing appointments
In getProcessById, the exception handling differs from other methods. Instead of returning arrays within the exception block, consider throwing custom exceptions or returning a standardized error response.
Refer to previous suggestions on standardizing error handling patterns.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (6)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (4)
13-14: Consider implementing dependency injection instead of static methods.The static nature of this facade service can make unit testing more difficult and creates tight coupling. Consider:
- Converting to a regular class with instance methods
- Using dependency injection for
ZmsApiClientServiceand other dependencies- Implementing an interface for better testability
Example refactor:
-class ZmsApiFacadeService +interface ZmsApiFacadeServiceInterface { + public function getOffices(): array; + // ... other method signatures +} + +class ZmsApiFacadeService implements ZmsApiFacadeServiceInterface { + private ZmsApiClientService $apiClient; + + public function __construct(ZmsApiClientService $apiClient) + { + $this->apiClient = $apiClient; + }
519-558: Improve testability of timestamp comparison.Using
time()directly makes the method hard to test. Consider injecting the current time or using a time provider service.- private static function processFreeSlots(ProcessList $freeSlots): array + private static function processFreeSlots( + ProcessList $freeSlots, + ?int $currentTimestamp = null + ): array { - $currentTimestamp = time(); + $currentTimestamp = $currentTimestamp ?? time();
604-624: TODO comments need implementation details.Several methods are marked as TODO without implementation details:
- preconfirmAppointment
- confirmAppointment
- cancelAppointment
Would you like assistance in implementing these methods based on the ZMS API requirements?
13-626: Consider splitting the facade into smaller, focused services.The class handles multiple concerns (offices, services, appointments) and might benefit from being split into smaller, focused services:
OfficeServiceServiceServiceAppointmentServiceThis would improve maintainability and adhere better to the Single Responsibility Principle.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/ErrorHandler.php (2)
49-55: Consider using aResponseFactoryto create response instancesRather than directly instantiating the
Responseobject, consider using aResponseFactory(e.g.,\Psr\Http\Message\ResponseFactoryInterface) to create response instances. This approach promotes better compliance with PSR-17 standards and enhances testability and flexibility.Refactor the code to use a response factory:
- Inject a
ResponseFactoryInterfaceinstance into theErrorHandlerclass.- Use the factory to create the response.
Example:
// Update imports use Psr\Http\Message\ResponseFactoryInterface; // Modify the constructor to accept the response factory private $responseFactory; public function __construct(ResponseFactoryInterface $responseFactory) { $this->responseFactory = $responseFactory; } // In the __invoke method, create the response using the factory $response = $this->responseFactory->createResponse(); $response->getBody()->write($payload); // The rest of the code remains the same
73-80: Consider using a PSR-3 compliant logger instead oferror_logUsing a PSR-3 compliant logger (e.g., Monolog) provides more flexibility and allows you to direct logs to different handlers (files, syslogs, external services, etc.). This enhances the logging capabilities and makes it easier to manage logs across the application.
Refactor the
ErrorHandlerclass to use a logger:
- Inject a
LoggerInterfaceinto the class.- Use the logger to log errors.
Example:
// Update imports use Psr\Log\LoggerInterface; // Modify the constructor to accept the logger private $logger; public function __construct(LoggerInterface $logger) { $this->logger = $logger; } // Update the logError method private function logError(Throwable $exception, bool $logErrorDetails): void { $message = $exception->getMessage(); if ($logErrorDetails) { $message .= "\n" . $exception->getTraceAsString(); } $this->logger->error($message, ['exception' => $exception]); }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (2)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/ErrorHandler.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php(1 hunks)
🔇 Additional comments (2)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (2)
435-471: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Standardize error response structure.
The error response structure in this method differs from the standard error format used in other methods. Consider using a consistent error response format across all methods.
} catch (\Exception $e) {
- return [
- 'appointmentTimestamps' => [],
- 'errorCode' => 'internalError',
- 'errorMessage' => 'An error occurred while fetching available free appointments',
- 'status' => 500,
- ];
+ return [
+ 'errors' => [
+ [
+ 'code' => 'internalError',
+ 'message' => 'An error occurred while fetching available free appointments'
+ ]
+ ],
+ 'status' => 500
+ ];
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
16-51: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Extract duplicated scope mapping logic into a private method.
The scope mapping logic is duplicated across multiple methods. Consider extracting it into a reusable private method.
+ private static function mapScopeToArray(Scope $scope): array
+ {
+ return [
+ "id" => $scope->id,
+ "provider" => $scope->getProvider(),
+ "shortName" => $scope->shortName,
+ "telephoneActivated" => $scope->getTelephoneActivated(),
+ "telephoneRequired" => $scope->getTelephoneRequired(),
+ "customTextfieldActivated" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldActivated(),
+ "customTextfieldRequired" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldRequired(),
+ "customTextfieldLabel" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldLabel(),
+ "captchaActivatedRequired" => $scope->getCaptchaActivatedRequired(),
+ "displayInfo" => $scope->getDisplayInfo()
+ ];
+ }
public static function getOffices(): array
{
$scopeList = new ScopeList(ZmsApiClientService::getScopes() ?? []);
$providerProjectionList = [];
foreach (ZmsApiClientService::getOffices() as $provider) {
$matchingScope = $scopeList->withProviderID($provider->source, $provider->id)->getIterator()->current();
$providerData = [
"id" => $provider->id,
"name" => $provider->displayName ?? $provider->name,
];
if ($matchingScope instanceof Scope) {
- $providerData["scope"] = [
- "id" => $matchingScope->id,
- // ... other fields
- ];
+ $providerData["scope"] = self::mapScopeToArray($matchingScope);
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 4
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (10)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php (3)
10-15: Consider improving cache control and type safety.A few suggestions for improvement:
- Using
time()for cache control might lead to race conditions in concurrent requests- The
$argsparameter should have a type declaration- public function __invoke(RequestInterface $request, ResponseInterface $response, array $args): ResponseInterface + public function __invoke( + RequestInterface $request, + ResponseInterface $response, + array $args = [] + ): ResponseInterface { $request = $this->initRequest($request); - $noCacheResponse = \BO\Slim\Render::withLastModified($response, time(), '0'); + $noCacheResponse = \BO\Slim\Render::withLastModified( + $response, + (new \DateTimeImmutable())->getTimestamp(), + '0' + ); return $this->readResponse($request, $noCacheResponse, $args); }
31-49: Add error handling for response body write operation.While the JSON encoding is properly handled, the write operation to the response body could potentially fail and should be handled.
try { $json = json_encode($content, JSON_THROW_ON_ERROR | JSON_UNESCAPED_UNICODE); + $stream = $response->getBody(); + if (!$stream->isWritable()) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Response body stream is not writable'); + } - $response->getBody()->write($json); + $bytesWritten = $stream->write($json); + if ($bytesWritten === false || $bytesWritten !== strlen($json)) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Failed to write complete response to body stream'); + } } catch (\JsonException $e) { throw new \RuntimeException('Failed to encode JSON response: ' . $e->getMessage(), 0, $e); + } catch (\RuntimeException $e) { + throw new \RuntimeException('Failed to write response: ' . $e->getMessage(), 0, $e); }
51-53: Remove extra empty lines at the end of the file.Clean up the file by removing the extra empty lines at the end.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (3)
13-14: Add class-level documentationAdd PHPDoc block to describe the class purpose, responsibilities, and dependencies. This will improve code maintainability and help other developers understand the service's role.
+/** + * Client service for interacting with the ZMS API. + * Handles appointments, calendars, and related operations for citizen services. + * + * @package BO\Zmscitizenapi\Services + */ class ZmsApiClientService
16-20: Track TODOs in issue systemThe TODO comments about cache methods should be tracked in your issue management system rather than in code comments. This ensures proper planning and follow-up.
Would you like me to create a GitHub issue to track the implementation of these cache methods?
74-102: Extract common calendar creation logic and add input validationThe methods
getFreeDaysandgetFreeTimeslotsshare calendar creation logic and could benefit from input validation.Consider:
- Extracting calendar creation into a private method
- Adding validation for date ranges
+ private static function createCalendar(ProviderList $providers, RequestList $requests, array $firstDay, array $lastDay): Calendar + { + if (empty($firstDay) || empty($lastDay)) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('First day and last day must not be empty'); + } + $calendar = new Calendar(); + $calendar->firstDay = $firstDay; + $calendar->lastDay = $lastDay; + $calendar->providers = $providers; + $calendar->requests = $requests; + return $calendar; + } public static function getFreeDays(ProviderList $providers, RequestList $requests, array $firstDay, array $lastDay): Calendar { - $calendar = new Calendar(); - $calendar->firstDay = $firstDay; - $calendar->lastDay = $lastDay; - $calendar->providers = $providers; - $calendar->requests = $requests; + $calendar = self::createCalendar($providers, $requests, $firstDay, $lastDay);zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php (1)
66-81: Store additional data in a variable to optimize performanceIn the
mapServicesWithCombinationsmethod,$service->getAdditionalData()is called multiple times. Storing the result in a variable improves performance and enhances readability.Apply this diff to store the additional data:
$serviceCombinations = []; + $additionalData = $service->getAdditionalData(); $mappedService = [ "id" => $service->getId(), "name" => $service->getName(), - "maxQuantity" => $service->getAdditionalData()['maxQuantity'] ?? 1, + "maxQuantity" => $additionalData['maxQuantity'] ?? 1, ]; - if (isset($service->getAdditionalData()['combinable'])) { - foreach ($service->getAdditionalData()['combinable'] as $combinationServiceId) { + if (isset($additionalData['combinable'])) { + foreach ($additionalData['combinable'] as $combinationServiceId) {zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (1)
42-56: Standardize error response structure by addingerrorCodefieldAcross various validation methods, the error responses lack an
errorCodefield. For consistency and to facilitate better error handling on the client side, consider adding anerrorCodeto all error responses.Apply this diff to include
errorCodein the error responses:if (!$startDate) { - $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'startDate is required and must be a valid date.']; + $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidStartDate', 'errorMessage' => 'startDate is required and must be a valid date.']; } if (!$endDate) { - $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorMessage' => 'endDate is required and must be a valid date.']; + $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidEndDate', 'errorMessage' => 'endDate is required and must be a valid date.']; }Repeat similar changes for other error responses in all validation methods to maintain consistency.
Also applies to: 83-110, 117-151, 156-165, 168-180, 183-195, 197-210, 212-225, 227-239, 242-254, 256-268, 270-282, 284-296, 298-308
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (2)
358-382: Optimize code by eliminating unnecessary array copyingIn the
getServicesProvidedAtOfficemethod, copying$requestRelationListand$requestListinto arrays is unnecessary since they are already iterable. This can be simplified to improve performance and readability.Apply this diff to remove unnecessary copying:
$requestRelationList = ZmsApiClientService::getRequestRelationList(); - $requestRelationArray = []; - foreach ($requestRelationList as $relation) { - $requestRelationArray[] = $relation; - } $serviceIds = array_filter($requestRelationList, function ($relation) use ($officeId) { return $relation->provider->id === $officeId; }); $serviceIds = array_map(function ($relation) { return $relation->request->id; }, $serviceIds); $requestList = ZmsApiClientService::getServices() ?? []; - $requestArray = []; - foreach ($requestList as $request) { - $requestArray[] = $request; - } return array_filter($requestList, function ($request) use ($serviceIds) { return in_array($request->id, $serviceIds); });
499-499: Remove unnecessary initialization of$freeSlotsIn the
getAvailableAppointmentsmethod,$freeSlotsis initialized but immediately overwritten by the call toZmsApiClientService::getFreeTimeslots(). This initialization is redundant.Apply this diff to remove the unnecessary initialization:
- $freeSlots = new ProcessList();
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (7)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/ErrorHandler.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (2)
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Helper/ErrorHandler.php
🔇 Additional comments (8)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php (2)
1-9: LGTM! Well-structured class declaration.
The namespace, imports, and class declaration follow PSR standards and best practices.
17-29: Handle potential null return values from parent::__invoke.
The previous review comment about handling null return values is still applicable here.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (2)
140-174:
Improve exception handling and input validation
The submitClientData method needs improvements in exception handling as noted in previous review.
Additionally:
- Add input validation for process data
- Improve IP address handling
- Validate process ID and authKey
public static function submitClientData(Process $process): Process|array
{
+ if (empty($process['data']['processId']) || empty($process['data']['authKey'])) {
+ throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Process ID and auth key are required');
+ }
+
$processEntity = new Process();
$processEntity->id = $process['data']['processId'] ?? null;
$processEntity->authKey = $process['data']['authKey'] ?? null;
- $processEntity->createIP = $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] ?? '127.0.0.1';
+ $processEntity->createIP = filter_var($_SERVER['HTTP_X_FORWARDED_FOR'] ?? $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] ?? '127.0.0.1', FILTER_VALIDATE_IP);212-221: Verify process ID exposure and access control
The getProcessById method potentially exposes process information. Let's verify the security implications.
✅ Verification successful
Let me gather more specific information about the authentication and access control mechanisms around process endpoints.
Let me gather more specific information about the process access control implementation.
Let me gather more specific information about process authentication and access control.
Based on the gathered information, I can now provide the final response regarding the security implications of the process ID and auth key exposure.
Process access is properly secured with multiple validation layers
The codebase implements robust security measures for process access:
- Authentication validation through
authKeychecks in multiple layers - Access control exceptions (
ProcessNoAccess,ProcessAuthFailed) with proper error codes (403, 404) - Rights validation through
checkRights()before accessing process data - Process scope validation against workstation access
- Input validation for both process ID and auth key parameters
The current implementation in getProcessById follows these security patterns and includes:
- Required auth key parameter
- Process ID validation
- Reference resolution control
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check for potential security issues in process access
# Look for access control checks
echo "Checking for access control mechanisms..."
rg -l "checkAccess|hasAccess|isAuthorized|authenticate" --type php
# Check for process ID exposure in logs
echo "Checking for process ID logging..."
rg "processId|process_id" --type php -C 2 | grep -i "log\|debug\|print"
# Look for other instances of process access
echo "Checking process access patterns..."
ast-grep --pattern 'process/{$_}/{$_}' --lang php
Length of output: 5353
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check for authentication and access control around process endpoints
# Look for middleware or authentication checks specific to process routes
echo "Checking route definitions and middleware..."
rg -A 5 "->get\('/process/|->post\('/process/" --type php
# Check for process-related security measures
echo "Checking process security implementations..."
rg -A 3 "class.*Process" --type php | grep -A 10 "class"
# Look for auth key validation
echo "Checking auth key validation..."
rg "authKey|auth_key" --type php -C 3
Length of output: 122664
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check for process access control implementations
# Look for process access control in the API layer
echo "Checking API access control..."
rg -B 2 -A 5 "class ProcessNoAccess|checkRights|hasAccess" --type php
# Look for process authentication validation
echo "Checking process authentication..."
rg -B 2 -A 5 "ProcessAuthFailed|readEntity.*authKey" --type php
# Check for process-related security exceptions
echo "Checking security exceptions..."
rg -A 3 "extends.*Exception.*process" --type-list=php --type php
Length of output: 89804
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check for process authentication and access control
# Look for process authentication validation
echo "Checking process authentication..."
rg -B 2 -A 5 "ProcessAuthFailed|readEntity.*process.*authKey" --type php
# Look for process access control exceptions
echo "Checking process access exceptions..."
rg -B 2 -A 5 "class.*ProcessNoAccess|ProcessAuthFailed" --type php
# Look for process access validation
echo "Checking process access validation..."
rg -B 2 -A 5 "testProcess|validateProcess|checkProcess" --type php
Length of output: 62062
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (3)
350-355: Clarify validation logic for $customTextfield
The condition for validating $customTextfield checks if it's not a string or is numeric, which may exclude valid string inputs that are numbers (e.g., house numbers). If the intent is to allow any string, regardless of numeric content, consider adjusting the condition.
Please confirm if numeric strings should be accepted for $customTextfield. If so, adjust the condition accordingly.
54-56: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve validation of $serviceCounts in validateGetBookableFreeDays
The current validation may not accurately check each service count. Accessing $serviceCounts[0] without ensuring the array is not empty can cause errors. Using preg_match on the imploded array may not effectively validate each count.
Replace with this more robust validation:
-if (empty($serviceCounts[0]) || !preg_match('/^\d+(,\d+)*$/', implode(',', $serviceCounts))) {
+if (empty($serviceCounts) || !is_array($serviceCounts) || array_filter($serviceCounts, fn($count) => !is_numeric($count))) {This ensures $serviceCounts is a non-empty array of numeric values.
105-110: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve validation of $serviceCounts in validateGetAvailableAppointments
Similar to the previous method, the validation of $serviceCounts may have issues due to accessing $serviceCounts[0] without checking if the array is empty and using preg_match on an imploded array.
Replace with this improved validation:
-if (empty($serviceCounts[0]) || !preg_match('/^\d+(,\d+)*$/', implode(',', $serviceCounts))) {
+if (empty($serviceCounts) || !is_array($serviceCounts) || array_filter($serviceCounts, fn($count) => !is_numeric($count))) {This change ensures that $serviceCounts is a non-empty array of numeric values.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (1)
565-591: Standardize error handling in getProcessById
The error handling in getProcessById includes throwing exceptions and returning error arrays, which can be inconsistent. Consider standardizing error responses across methods for better consistency.
Refer to previous suggestions about standardizing error structures and apply similar patterns here to ensure consistent error handling.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
…i with geocoordinates and address
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 4
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (9)
zmsentities/src/Zmsentities/Scope.php (2)
28-31: Consider adding null safety and maintaining consistency with preference handlingThe
getShortName()method directly accesses the property while other new methods usegetPreference(). This inconsistency might lead to maintenance issues. Additionally, there's no null safety or default value handling.Consider either:
- Adding default value handling:
public function getShortName() { - return $this->toProperty()->shortName->get(); + return $this->toProperty()->shortName->get(''); }
- Or if this should be a preference, align with other methods:
public function getShortName() { - return $this->toProperty()->shortName->get(); + return $this->getPreference('scope', 'shortName', false, ''); }
28-66: Overall changes look good with minor improvements neededThe new methods effectively extend the Scope class to support the zmscitizenapi module while maintaining the existing code structure. They follow the established pattern of preference handling, though with some minor inconsistencies in implementation.
The changes are approved pending the suggested improvements:
- Add PHPDoc blocks for all new methods
- Standardize default value handling
- Verify schema compatibility
Consider creating an interface or documentation that lists all available preference keys to make it easier for developers to understand what preferences are available and their expected values.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (4)
13-14: Consider dependency injection instead of static methods.The static facade pattern can make unit testing difficult and creates tight coupling. Consider refactoring to use dependency injection:
-class ZmsApiFacadeService +class ZmsApiFacadeService +{ + private $apiClient; + + public function __construct(ZmsApiClientService $apiClient) + { + $this->apiClient = $apiClient; + }
155-160: Convert TODO comments to tracked issues.There are several TODO comments for planned methods. These should be tracked in the issue system for better visibility and tracking.
Would you like me to create GitHub issues for these planned methods:
- getCombinableServicesByIds
- getOfficeByIds
- getOfficesThatProvideService
- preconfirmAppointment
- confirmAppointment
- cancelAppointment
Also applies to: 188-193, 352-357, 609-614, 617-622, 624-629
396-399: Consider batch validation approach.Multiple validation calls in sequence could be combined into a single validation operation to reduce code duplication and improve maintainability.
Consider creating a ValidationContext class that can accumulate multiple validation rules and execute them in batch:
class ValidationContext { private $rules = []; public function addRule(callable $rule): self { $this->rules[] = $rule; return $this; } public function validate(): ?array { foreach ($this->rules as $rule) { if ($errors = $rule()) { return $errors; } } return null; } }Also applies to: 426-429, 487-490, 527-530, 552-555
570-596: Enhance security measures for process retrieval.Consider adding the following security improvements:
- Rate limiting for authentication attempts
- Audit logging for process access
- Input sanitization for authKey
Consider implementing a security middleware or decorator:
class SecurityDecorator { private $service; private $rateLimit; public function getProcessById(int $processId, string $authKey): array { if (!$this->rateLimit->check()) { return ['error' => 'Rate limit exceeded', 'status' => 429]; } $this->auditLog->log('process_access', $processId); return $this->service->getProcessById($processId, $this->sanitize($authKey)); } }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (1)
15-17: Simplify array extraction usingarray_columnThe extraction of service IDs can be simplified for better readability and efficiency by using
array_column.Apply this diff to simplify the code:
-$availableServiceIds = array_map(function ($service) { - return $service['id']; -}, $availableServices); +$availableServiceIds = array_column($availableServices, 'id');zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (2)
17-21: Consider implementing caching methodsThe TODO comment indicates missing cache methods for source data. This could significantly improve performance by reducing API calls for frequently accessed data.
Would you like me to help implement the caching methods
haveCachedSourcesExpiredandgetSources? I can provide a solution using PSR-6 compatible caching.
214-223: Add input validation and make resolveReferences configurableThe
getProcessByIdmethod should validate its nullable parameters and allow configuration of the resolveReferences value.Consider these improvements:
+ private const DEFAULT_RESOLVE_REFERENCES = 2; + public static function getProcessById(?int $processId, ?string $authKey): Process { + if (!$processId || !$authKey) { + throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Process ID and auth key are required'); + } - $resolveReferences = 2; $process = new Process(); $process = \App::$http->readGetResult("/process/{$processId}/{$authKey}/", [ - 'resolveReferences' => $resolveReferences + 'resolveReferences' => self::DEFAULT_RESOLVE_REFERENCES ])->getEntity(); return $process; }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (14)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGetTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserveTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdateTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableDaysListTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceListTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGetTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesByOfficeListTest.php(1 hunks)zmsentities/src/Zmsentities/Scope.php(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (9)
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserveTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsListTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/BaseController.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesByOfficeListTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableDaysListTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGetTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGetTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceListTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php
🔇 Additional comments (8)
zmsentities/src/Zmsentities/Scope.php (1)
33-66: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add PHPDoc blocks and maintain consistent default values
The new preference getter methods lack documentation and have inconsistent default values. While most methods default to null, getCustomTextfieldLabel() defaults to an empty string.
- Add PHPDoc blocks to document return types and values:
+/**
+ * Get telephone activation status from client preferences
+ *
+ * @return bool|null Returns null if preference is not set
+ */
public function getTelephoneActivated()
{
return $this->getPreference('client', 'telephoneActivated', null);
}- Consider standardizing default values:
public function getCustomTextfieldLabel()
{
- return $this->getPreference('client', 'customTextfieldLabel', '');
+ return $this->getPreference('client', 'customTextfieldLabel', null);
}Let's verify if these preference keys exist in the schema:
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (2)
589-595: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Standardize error handling patterns.
The error handling is inconsistent. Some methods return error arrays while others throw exceptions. Consider standardizing:
} catch (\Exception $e) {
- if (strpos($e->getMessage(), 'kein Termin gefunden') !== false) {
- return ExceptionService::appointmentNotFound();
- } else {
- throw $e;
- }
+ return [
+ 'error' => $e->getMessage(),
+ 'status' => strpos($e->getMessage(), 'kein Termin gefunden') !== false ? 404 : 500
+ ];
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
447-456: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Optimize array operations in getFreeAppointments.
Using array_merge in a loop can be inefficient for large datasets. Consider pre-allocating the array:
- $requests = [];
- foreach ($params['serviceIds'] as $index => $serviceId) {
- $service = [
- 'id' => $serviceId,
- 'source' => \App::$source_name,
- 'slotCount' => $params['serviceCounts'][$index]
- ];
- $requests = array_merge($requests, array_fill(0, $service['slotCount'], $service));
- }
+ $totalSlots = array_sum($params['serviceCounts']);
+ $requests = array_pad([], $totalSlots, []);
+ $currentIndex = 0;
+
+ foreach ($params['serviceIds'] as $index => $serviceId) {
+ $service = [
+ 'id' => $serviceId,
+ 'source' => \App::$source_name,
+ 'slotCount' => $params['serviceCounts'][$index]
+ ];
+ for ($i = 0; $i < $service['slotCount']; $i++) {
+ $requests[$currentIndex++] = $service;
+ }
+ }Likely invalid or redundant comment.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (1)
54-56: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve validation of $serviceCounts in validateGetBookableFreeDays
The current validation may not accurately check each service count. It's better to validate each element to ensure all counts are numeric and positive integers.
Apply this diff to enhance the validation logic:
-if (empty($serviceCounts[0]) || !preg_match('/^\d+(,\d+)*$/', implode(',', $serviceCounts))) {
+if (empty($serviceCounts) || !is_array($serviceCounts) || array_filter($serviceCounts, fn($count) => !is_numeric($count) || intval($count) <= 0)) {Also, update the error message to reflect the expected format:
- 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCount should be a comma-separated string of integers.',
+ 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCounts should be an array of positive integers.',Likely invalid or redundant comment.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (4)
1-13: LGTM! Well-structured file with proper imports
The file follows PSR-4 standards with appropriate namespace declaration and well-organized imports.
162-174: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Improve exception handling in submitClientData
The current exception handling approach using json_decode(json_encode($e)) is inefficient and error-prone.
23-74: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Reduce code duplication in data retrieval methods
The methods getOffices, getScopes, getServices, and getRequestRelationList contain identical API call patterns and similar logic.
Consider extracting the common logic into a private method:
+ private static function fetchSourceData(): SourceList
+ {
+ return \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [
+ 'resolveReferences' => 2,
+ ])->getEntity();
+ }
+
public static function getOffices(): ProviderList
{
- $sources = new SourceList();
- $sources = \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [
- 'resolveReferences' => 2,
- ])->getEntity();
+ $sources = self::fetchSourceData();
$providerList = new ProviderList();
$providerList = $sources->getProviderList() ?? $providerList;
return $providerList;
}Apply similar changes to other methods.
Likely invalid or redundant comment.
178-212: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add input validation and standardize URL construction
The process status update methods lack input validation for nullable Process parameters and have inconsistent URL construction patterns.
Consider adding a validation method and standardizing URL construction:
+ private function validateProcess(?Process $process): void
+ {
+ if (!$process || empty($process['id']) || empty($process['authKey'])) {
+ throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Process ID and auth key are required');
+ }
+ }
+
+ private function getProcessUrl(Process $process, string $action = ''): string
+ {
+ return sprintf('/process/%s/%s/%s', $process['id'], $process['authKey'], $action);
+ }
public function confirmProcess(?Process $process): Process
{
+ $this->validateProcess($process);
- $url = '/process/status/confirmed/';
+ $url = $this->getProcessUrl($process, 'status/confirmed/');
return \App::$http->readPostResult($url, $process)->getEntity();
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (1)
169-175: Standardize error response structure in validation methodsIn the
validateGetOfficesByServiceIdsmethod, the error response includes an'offices'key with an empty array, which is inconsistent with other validation methods and may cause confusion.Apply this diff to standardize the error response structure:
- $errors[] = [ - 'offices' => [], - 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceId', - 'errorMessage' => 'serviceId should be a 32-bit integer.', - 'status' => 400 - ]; + $errors[] = [ + 'status' => 400, + 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceId', + 'errorMessage' => 'serviceId should be a 32-bit integer.', + ];Removing the
'offices'key aligns the error response with other methods and ensures consistency across the validation service.zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (1)
571-597: Use specific exception classes for robust error handlingIn
getProcessById, parsing exception messages withstrposis fragile and can lead to issues if exception messages change. Instead, catch specific exception types to handle errors more reliably.Apply this diff to improve exception handling:
} catch (\Exception $e) { - if (strpos($e->getMessage(), 'kein Termin gefunden') !== false) { + if ($e instanceof AppointmentNotFoundException) { return ExceptionService::appointmentNotFound(); } else { throw $e; } }Using specific exception classes enhances code readability and maintainability.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (20)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentCancel.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirm.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGet.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentPreconfirm.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableDaysList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/CaptchaGet.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesServicesRelations.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGet.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopesList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesByOfficeList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesList.php(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (16)
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentPreconfirm.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentCancel.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableDaysList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/CaptchaGet.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentConfirm.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AvailableAppointmentsList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesServicesRelations.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentGet.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ServicesByOfficeList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGet.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceList.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/MapperService.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopesList.php
🔇 Additional comments (4)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (2)
34-47: Extract duplicated scope mapping logic into a helper method
The scope mapping logic is duplicated in multiple methods like getOffices, getScopes, getScopeForProvider, getScopeByOfficeId, and getScopeByIds. Extracting this logic into a private helper method will improve maintainability and reduce code duplication.
Here's how you can define the helper method:
private static function mapScopeToArray(Scope $scope): array
{
return [
"id" => $scope->id,
"provider" => $scope->getProvider() ?? null,
"shortName" => $scope->getShortName() ?? null,
"telephoneActivated" => $scope->getTelephoneActivated() ?? null,
"telephoneRequired" => $scope->getTelephoneRequired() ?? null,
"customTextfieldActivated" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldActivated() ?? null,
"customTextfieldRequired" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldRequired() ?? null,
"customTextfieldLabel" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldLabel() ?? null,
"captchaActivatedRequired" => $scope->getCaptchaActivatedRequired() ?? null,
"displayInfo" => $scope->getDisplayInfo() ?? null,
];
}Then, replace the duplicated code in each method with a call to this helper:
- $providerData["scope"] = [
- "id" => $matchingScope->id,
- // ... other fields
- ];
+ $providerData["scope"] = self::mapScopeToArray($matchingScope);Also applies to: 63-75, 117-129, 169-180, 278-290
450-456: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Optimize array construction in getFreeAppointments
Using array_merge within a loop can be inefficient, especially for large datasets. Instead, append to the $requests array directly to improve performance.
Apply this diff to optimize the code:
foreach ($params['serviceIds'] as $index => $serviceId) {
$service = [
'id' => $serviceId,
'source' => \App::$source_name,
'slotCount' => $params['serviceCounts'][$index]
];
- $requests = array_merge($requests, array_fill(0, $service['slotCount'], $service));
+ for ($i = 0; $i < $service['slotCount']; $i++) {
+ $requests[] = $service;
+ }
}This change reduces the overhead of array operations within the loop.
Likely invalid or redundant comment.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php (1)
23-25: Check for null before using $request to prevent errors
If $request is not an instance of ServerRequestInterface, it is set to null, but $request->getParsedBody() is called without checking if $request is null. This can lead to a fatal error.
Apply this diff to ensure $request is valid:
$request = $request instanceof ServerRequestInterface ? $request : null;
+if ($request === null) {
+ return $this->createJsonResponse($response, [
+ 'errorCode' => 'invalidRequest',
+ 'errorMessage' => 'Invalid request type.',
+ ], 400);
+}
$body = $request->getParsedBody();This check prevents method calls on a null object.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (1)
162-174:
Use instanceof for exception handling instead of decoding
Decoding exceptions with json_decode(json_encode($e), true) is inefficient and not reliable. Instead, use the instanceof operator to check the exception type directly.
Apply this diff to improve exception handling:
try {
$result = \App::$http->readPostResult($url, $processEntity);
return $result->getEntity();
} catch (\Exception $e) {
- $exceptionName = json_decode(json_encode($e), true)['template'] ?? null;
- if ($exceptionName === 'BO\\Zmsapi\\Exception\\Process\\MoreThanAllowedAppointmentsPerMail') {
+ if ($e instanceof \BO\Zmsapi\Exception\Process\MoreThanAllowedAppointmentsPerMail) {
$exception = [
'exception' => 'tooManyAppointmentsWithSameMail'
];
return $exception;
} else {
throw $e;
}
}This change enhances performance and accuracy in exception handling.
Likely invalid or redundant comment.
| $selectedProcess->clients = [ | ||
| [ | ||
| 'email' => '[email protected]' | ||
| ] | ||
| ]; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Avoid using a hardcoded default email address
Using '[email protected]' as a placeholder email may lead to issues with email delivery or violate data integrity. It's better to require the client to provide a valid email address.
Apply this diff to collect the client's email from the request:
+$clientEmail = $body['email'] ?? null;
+if (!$clientEmail || !filter_var($clientEmail, FILTER_VALIDATE_EMAIL)) {
+ return $this->createJsonResponse($response, [
+ 'errorCode' => 'invalidEmail',
+ 'errorMessage' => 'A valid email address is required.',
+ ], 400);
+}
$selectedProcess->clients = [
[
- 'email' => '[email protected]'
+ 'email' => $clientEmail
]
];Ensuring a valid email is provided improves data accuracy and user communication.
Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Previously [email protected] in zmsproxymuc
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@ThomasAFink, understood. If [email protected] is the standard default email used in your codebase, it's acceptable to continue using it here.
✏️ Learnings added
Learnt from: ThomasAFink
PR: it-at-m/eappointment#674
File: zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentReserve.php:90-94
Timestamp: 2024-12-03T14:42:54.440Z
Learning: In the `AppointmentReserve` class of `zmscitizenapi`, it's acceptable to use `[email protected]` as the default client email address, following the established practice in `zmsproxymuc`.
Note: Learnings are effective only in the context of similar code segments. To apply general coding guidelines, please configure review instructions. You can manage existing learnings in the app.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (6)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (2)
14-15: Add class-level documentation.Consider adding PHPDoc comments to describe the class's purpose, responsibilities, and usage examples.
+/** + * Facade service for ZMS API operations. + * + * This service provides a simplified interface for interacting with the ZMS API, + * handling operations related to offices, services, appointments, and processes. + */ class ZmsApiFacadeService {
156-161: Track TODO items systematically.Consider creating GitHub issues for the pending implementations:
- getCombinableServicesByIds
- getOfficeByIds
- getOfficesThatProvideService
- preconfirmAppointment
- confirmAppointment
- cancelAppointment
Would you like me to create GitHub issues for tracking these TODO items?
Also applies to: 189-194, 353-358, 610-615, 618-623, 625-630
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (4)
170-170: Simplify condition checking for empty$serviceIdsThe condition
if (empty($serviceIds) || $serviceIds == [''])can be simplified toif (empty($serviceIds))sinceempty()will handle empty arrays and arrays containing empty strings.Apply this diff to simplify the condition:
- if (empty($serviceIds) || $serviceIds == ['']) { + if (empty($serviceIds)) {
185-185: Simplify condition checking for empty$scopeIdsSimilarly, the condition
if (empty($scopeIds) || $scopeIds == [''])can be simplified for clarity and efficiency.Apply this diff:
- if (empty($scopeIds) || $scopeIds == ['']) { + if (empty($scopeIds)) {
349-355: Refine validation of$familyNameto ensure it's not empty or whitespaceThe current check may allow strings that contain only whitespace. Use
trim()to ensure$familyNameis a non-empty string with actual characters.Apply this diff to improve the validation:
- if (!$familyName || !is_string($familyName)) { + if (empty(trim($familyName)) || !is_string($familyName)) {
373-379: Simplify validation for$customTextfieldThe condition
(!is_string($customTextfield) || is_numeric($customTextfield))may not effectively prevent numeric strings. To ensure$customTextfieldis a non-numeric string, adjust the validation logic.Apply this diff to refine the condition:
- if ($customTextfield !== null && (!is_string($customTextfield) || is_numeric($customTextfield))) { + if ($customTextfield !== null && (is_numeric($customTextfield) || empty(trim($customTextfield)))) {
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (2)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php(1 hunks)
🔇 Additional comments (3)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (2)
34-47: Extract repeated scope mapping logic.
The scope mapping logic is duplicated across multiple methods.
Also applies to: 63-74, 117-128
590-596: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Standardize error handling pattern.
The error handling in getProcessById differs from other methods by throwing exceptions directly. Consider using the ExceptionService consistently.
} catch (\Exception $e) {
if (strpos($e->getMessage(), 'kein Termin gefunden') !== false) {
return ExceptionService::appointmentNotFound();
} else {
- throw $e;
+ return ExceptionService::internalError($e->getMessage());
}
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (1)
365-371: Ensure correct operator precedence in $telephone validation
The condition for validating $telephone might not work as intended due to operator precedence. Adding parentheses improves readability and correctness.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 11
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (6)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (1)
17-21: TODO comment needs more implementation detailsThe TODO comment about caching methods should include:
- Cache invalidation strategy
- Cache storage mechanism
- Specific methods to be implemented
Would you like me to help create a detailed implementation plan for these caching methods?
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (2)
104-110: Ensure consistent error messages for array parametersThe error message for invalid
serviceIdrefers to a single ID, but the parameter$serviceIdsis an array. Update the error message to reflect that multiple service IDs are expected.Apply this diff to clarify the error message:
$errors[] = [ 'status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceId', - 'errorMessage' => 'serviceId should be a 32-bit integer.', + 'errorMessage' => 'Each serviceId should be a 32-bit integer.', ];
374-380: Simplify telephone validation logicThe condition for validating
$telephonecan be simplified for better readability and correctness.Apply this diff:
-if ($telephone !== null && (!$telephone || !preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone))) { +if (!is_null($telephone) && !preg_match('/^\d{7,15}$/', $telephone)) { $errors[] = [ 'status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidTelephone', 'errorMessage' => 'telephone should be a numeric string between 7 and 15 digits.', ]; }zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (3)
456-458: Avoid usingarray_mergeinside loopsUsing
array_mergeinside loops can be inefficient. Consider initializing an empty array and appending elements directly.Apply this diff:
foreach ($params['serviceIds'] as $index => $serviceId) { $service = [ 'id' => $serviceId, 'source' => \App::$source_name, 'slotCount' => $params['serviceCounts'][$index] ]; - $requests = array_merge($requests, array_fill(0, $service['slotCount'], $service)); + for ($i = 0; $i < $service['slotCount']; $i++) { + $requests[] = $service; + } }
441-471: Specify return types consistentlyThe method
getFreeAppointmentshas an inconsistent return type (ProcessList|array). For better clarity and type safety, consider always returning an array with structured data or throwing exceptions for error cases.
627-631: ImplementcancelAppointmentmethod or remove TODOThe method
cancelAppointmentis mentioned in a TODO comment but not implemented. If this method is required, it should be implemented. Otherwise, consider removing the TODO to avoid confusion.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (8)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceList.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGet.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceListTest.php(1 hunks)zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGetTest.php(1 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (5)
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceList.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGetTest.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/AppointmentUpdate.php
- zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/ScopeByIdGet.php
- zmscitizenapi/tests/Zmscitizenapi/OfficesByServiceListTest.php
🔇 Additional comments (15)
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiClientService.php (4)
76-87:
Add error handling to getFreeDays method
The method lacks proper validation of the API response, unlike getFreeTimeslots.
166-167:
Improve exception handling in submitClientData
Using json_decode for exception type checking is inefficient and error-prone.
178-194:
Add state validation and improve URL construction
Methods need improvements in validation and code structure.
23-74: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Refactor duplicate API calls into a shared method
All four methods (getOffices, getScopes, getServices, getRequestRelationList) contain identical API call logic. This violates the DRY principle.
Extract the common API call into a private method:
+ private static function fetchSourceData(): SourceList
+ {
+ return \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [
+ 'resolveReferences' => 2,
+ ])->getEntity();
+ }
public static function getOffices(): ProviderList
{
- $sources = \App::$http->readGetResult('/source/' . \App::$source_name . '/', [
- 'resolveReferences' => 2,
- ])->getEntity();
+ $sources = self::fetchSourceData();
$providerList = new ProviderList();
return $sources->getProviderList() ?? $providerList;
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ValidationService.php (6)
112-118:
Fix serviceCounts validation and error message
Similar to previous instances, the validation for $serviceCounts assumes a comma-separated string rather than an array. Adjust the logic and error message accordingly.
Apply this diff:
-if (empty($serviceCounts[0]) || !preg_match('/^\d+(,\d+)*$/', implode(',', $serviceCounts))) {
- $errors[] = [
- 'status' => 400,
- 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceCount',
- 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCount should be a comma-separated string of integers.',
- ];
+if (empty($serviceCounts) || !is_array($serviceCounts) || array_filter($serviceCounts, fn($count) => !is_numeric($count))) {
+ $errors[] = [
+ 'status' => 400,
+ 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceCount',
+ 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCounts should be an array of numeric values.',
+ ];
}126-132:
Use strict null checks for $officeId
Using !$officeId may incorrectly invalidate valid IDs like 0. Employ is_null($officeId) to check for null values explicitly.
Apply this diff:
-if (!$officeId || !is_numeric($officeId)) {
+if (is_null($officeId) || !is_numeric($officeId)) {
$errors[] = [
'status' => 400,
'errorCode' => 'invalidOfficeId',
'errorMessage' => 'officeId should be a 32-bit integer.',
];
}342-348:
Use strict null checks for $processId
Consistent with previous comments, replace !$processId with is_null($processId) for accurate null checking.
Apply this diff:
-if (!$processId || !is_numeric($processId) || intval($processId) <= 0) {
+if (is_null($processId) || !is_numeric($processId) || intval($processId) <= 0) {
$errors[] = [
'status' => 400,
'errorCode' => 'invalidProcessId',
'errorMessage' => 'processId should be a positive 32-bit integer.',
];
}66-72: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Avoid using loose comparison in validation of $processId
The check !$processId can fail for valid IDs like 0. Use is_null($processId) to ensure that you are checking for null values specifically.
Apply this diff to adjust the validation:
-if (!$processId || !is_numeric($processId) || intval($processId) <= 0) {
+if (is_null($processId) || !is_numeric($processId) || intval($processId) <= 0) {
$errors[] = [
'status' => 400,
'errorCode' => 'invalidProcessId',
'errorMessage' => 'processId should be a 32-bit integer.',
];
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
50-54:
Use strict null checks for $officeId and $serviceId
Using !$officeId and !$serviceId may lead to incorrect validation if the IDs are 0. If 0 is a valid ID, consider using is_null($officeId) and is_null($serviceId) for strict null checking.
Apply this diff to improve the null checks:
-if (!$officeId || !is_numeric($officeId)) {
+if (is_null($officeId) || !is_numeric($officeId)) {
$errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidOfficeId', 'errorMessage' => 'officeId should be a 32-bit integer.'];
}
-if (!$serviceId || !is_numeric($serviceId)) {
+if (is_null($serviceId) || !is_numeric($serviceId)) {
$errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceId', 'errorMessage' => 'serviceId should be a 32-bit integer.'];
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
170-177:
Improve validation for empty or invalid $serviceIds
The current check empty($serviceIds) || $serviceIds == [''] may not cover all invalid cases. Also, initializing $errors before appending is necessary to prevent undefined variable errors.
Apply this diff:
+ $errors = [];
- if (empty($serviceIds) || $serviceIds == ['']) {
+ if (empty($serviceIds) || !is_array($serviceIds) || array_filter($serviceIds, fn($id) => !is_numeric($id))) {
$errors[] = [
'offices' => [],
'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceId',
'errorMessage' => 'Each serviceId should be a 32-bit integer.',
'status' => 400
];
}Likely invalid or redundant comment.
zmscitizenapi/src/Zmscitizenapi/Services/ZmsApiFacadeService.php (5)
34-47: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Extract repeated scope mapping logic into a private method
The scope mapping code is duplicated in multiple methods. Refactor this into a private method to improve maintainability and reduce code duplication.
Apply this diff:
+ private static function mapScopeToArray(Scope $scope): array
+ {
+ return [
+ "id" => $scope->id,
+ "provider" => $scope->getProvider() ?? null,
+ "shortName" => $scope->getShortName() ?? null,
+ "telephoneActivated" => $scope->getTelephoneActivated() ?? null,
+ "telephoneRequired" => $scope->getTelephoneRequired() ?? null,
+ "customTextfieldActivated" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldActivated() ?? null,
+ "customTextfieldRequired" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldRequired() ?? null,
+ "customTextfieldLabel" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldLabel() ?? null,
+ "captchaActivatedRequired" => $scope->getCaptchaActivatedRequired() ?? null,
+ "displayInfo" => $scope->getDisplayInfo() ?? null,
+ ];
+ }
foreach ($scopeList as $scope) {
- $scopesProjectionList[] = [
- "id" => $scope->id,
- "provider" => $scope->getProvider() ?? null,
- "shortName" => $scope->getShortName() ?? null,
- "telephoneActivated" => $scope->getTelephoneActivated() ?? null,
- "telephoneRequired" => $scope->getTelephoneRequired() ?? null,
- "customTextfieldActivated" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldActivated() ?? null,
- "customTextfieldRequired" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldRequired() ?? null,
- "customTextfieldLabel" => $scope->getCustomTextfieldLabel() ?? null,
- "captchaActivatedRequired" => $scope->getCaptchaActivatedRequired() ?? null,
- "displayInfo" => $scope->getDisplayInfo() ?? null
- ];
+ $scopesProjectionList[] = self::mapScopeToArray($scope);
}Also applies to lines: 116-129, 168-181, 278-291
214-236: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Optimize nested loops for performance
The nested loops in getOfficesByServiceIds can be inefficient. Consider using associative arrays (hash maps) for faster lookups to improve performance.
315-335: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Optimize nested loops in getServicesByOfficeIds
Similar to previous comment, refactor the nested loops to use lookup tables for better performance.
87-97:
Handle possible null returns from API calls in getServices
Similar to previous comments, check for null when calling ZmsApiClientService::getServices().
592-597:
Improve exception handling in getProcessById
Catching exceptions using string matching on the error message is fragile and can lead to issues if the message changes. Consider using specific exception types or error codes.
Apply this diff:
- if (strpos($e->getMessage(), 'kein Termin gefunden') !== false) {
- return ExceptionService::appointmentNotFound();
- } else {
- throw $e;
- }
+ // Handle specific exceptions if possible
+ if ($e instanceof AppointmentNotFoundException) {
+ return ExceptionService::appointmentNotFound();
+ }
+ // Log the exception and return a generic error
+ error_log($e->getMessage());
+ return [
+ 'errorCode' => 'internalError',
+ 'errorMessage' => 'An internal error occurred.',
+ 'status' => 500,
+ ];Likely invalid or redundant comment.
| public function sendConfirmationEmail(?Process $process): Process | ||
| { | ||
| $url = "/process/{$process['id']}/{$process['authKey']}/confirmation/mail/"; | ||
| return \App::$http->readPostResult($url, $process)->getEntity(); | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| public function sendPreconfirmationEmail(?Process $process): Process | ||
| { | ||
| $url = "/process/{$process['id']}/{$process['authKey']}/preconfirmation/mail/"; | ||
| return \App::$http->readPostResult($url, $process)->getEntity(); | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| public function sendCancelationEmail(?Process $process): Process | ||
| { | ||
| $url = "/process/{$process['id']}/{$process['authKey']}/delete/mail/"; | ||
| return \App::$http->readPostResult($url, $process)->getEntity(); | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Add error handling for email operations
Email sending methods should include proper error handling and logging.
Add try-catch block with logging:
public function sendConfirmationEmail(?Process $process): Process
{
+ if (!$process) {
+ throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Process cannot be null');
+ }
$url = "/process/{$process['id']}/{$process['authKey']}/confirmation/mail/";
- return \App::$http->readPostResult($url, $process)->getEntity();
+ try {
+ return \App::$http->readPostResult($url, $process)->getEntity();
+ } catch (\Exception $e) {
+ \App::$log->error('Failed to send confirmation email', ['process_id' => $process['id'], 'error' => $e->getMessage()]);
+ throw $e;
+ }
}Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
| public static function getProcessById(?int $processId, ?string $authKey): Process | ||
| { | ||
| $resolveReferences = 2; | ||
| $process = new Process(); | ||
| $process = \App::$http->readGetResult("/process/{$processId}/{$authKey}/", [ | ||
| 'resolveReferences' => $resolveReferences | ||
| ])->getEntity(); | ||
|
|
||
| return $process; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Add input validation for process retrieval
The method should validate input parameters before making the API call.
Add validation:
public static function getProcessById(?int $processId, ?string $authKey): Process
{
+ if (!$processId || !$authKey) {
+ throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Process ID and auth key are required');
+ }
$resolveReferences = 2;📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| public static function getProcessById(?int $processId, ?string $authKey): Process | |
| { | |
| $resolveReferences = 2; | |
| $process = new Process(); | |
| $process = \App::$http->readGetResult("/process/{$processId}/{$authKey}/", [ | |
| 'resolveReferences' => $resolveReferences | |
| ])->getEntity(); | |
| return $process; | |
| } | |
| public static function getProcessById(?int $processId, ?string $authKey): Process | |
| { | |
| if (!$processId || !$authKey) { | |
| throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Process ID and auth key are required'); | |
| } | |
| $resolveReferences = 2; | |
| $process = new Process(); | |
| $process = \App::$http->readGetResult("/process/{$processId}/{$authKey}/", [ | |
| 'resolveReferences' => $resolveReferences | |
| ])->getEntity(); | |
| return $process; | |
| } |
| $processEntity->requests = $requests; | ||
| $processEntity->lastChange = $appointmentProcess['lastChange'] ?? time(); | ||
|
|
||
| $processEntity->createIP = $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] ?? '127.0.0.1'; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Use X-Forwarded-For header for accurate client IP
Current implementation might not work correctly behind proxies.
- $processEntity->createIP = $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] ?? '127.0.0.1';
+ $processEntity->createIP = $_SERVER['HTTP_X_FORWARDED_FOR'] ?? $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] ?? '127.0.0.1';📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| $processEntity->createIP = $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] ?? '127.0.0.1'; | |
| $processEntity->createIP = $_SERVER['HTTP_X_FORWARDED_FOR'] ?? $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] ?? '127.0.0.1'; |
| foreach ($serviceIds as $index => $serviceId) { | ||
| $count = intval($serviceCounts[$index]); | ||
| for ($i = 0; $i < $count; $i++) { | ||
| $requests[] = [ | ||
| 'id' => $serviceId, | ||
| 'source' => \App::$source_name | ||
| ]; | ||
| } | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Add input validation for service arrays
The method assumes serviceIds and serviceCounts arrays are aligned without validation.
Add validation before the loop:
+ if (count($serviceIds) !== count($serviceCounts)) {
+ throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Service IDs and counts must have the same length');
+ }
foreach ($serviceIds as $index => $serviceId) {📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| foreach ($serviceIds as $index => $serviceId) { | |
| $count = intval($serviceCounts[$index]); | |
| for ($i = 0; $i < $count; $i++) { | |
| $requests[] = [ | |
| 'id' => $serviceId, | |
| 'source' => \App::$source_name | |
| ]; | |
| } | |
| } | |
| if (count($serviceIds) !== count($serviceCounts)) { | |
| throw new \InvalidArgumentException('Service IDs and counts must have the same length'); | |
| } | |
| foreach ($serviceIds as $index => $serviceId) { | |
| $count = intval($serviceCounts[$index]); | |
| for ($i = 0; $i < $count; $i++) { | |
| $requests[] = [ | |
| 'id' => $serviceId, | |
| 'source' => \App::$source_name | |
| ]; | |
| } | |
| } |
| if (empty($officeIds) || !is_array($officeIds)) { | ||
| $errors[] = [ |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Initialize $errors array before returning
Ensure that the $errors array is initialized before returning it to avoid undefined variable notices.
Apply this diff:
+ $errors = $errors ?? [];
if (!empty($errors['errors'])) {
return $errors;
}Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
| if (empty($freeSlots) || !is_iterable($freeSlots)) { | ||
| $errors[] = [ | ||
| 'appointmentTimestamps' => [], | ||
| 'errorCode' => 'appointmentNotAvailable', | ||
| 'errorMessage' => 'Der von Ihnen gewählte Termin ist leider nicht mehr verfügbar.', | ||
| 'status' => 404, | ||
| ]; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Initialize $errors array in validateGetProcessFreeSlots
In the method validateGetProcessFreeSlots, $errors may not be initialized before appending errors.
Apply this diff:
+ $errors = [];
if (empty($freeSlots) || !is_iterable($freeSlots)) {
$errors[] = [
'appointmentTimestamps' => [],
'errorCode' => 'appointmentNotAvailable',
'errorMessage' => 'Der von Ihnen gewählte Termin ist leider nicht mehr verfügbar.',
'status' => 404,
];
}Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
| if (empty($serviceCounts[0]) || !preg_match('/^\d+(,\d+)*$/', implode(',', $serviceCounts))) { | ||
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceCount', 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCount should be a comma-separated string of integers.']; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Correct serviceCounts validation logic and error message
The validation for $serviceCounts checks for a comma-separated string, but $serviceCounts is expected to be an array. This may lead to incorrect validation and confusing error messages.
Apply this diff to fix the validation logic and error message:
-if (empty($serviceCounts[0]) || !preg_match('/^\d+(,\d+)*$/', implode(',', $serviceCounts))) {
- $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceCount', 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCount should be a comma-separated string of integers.'];
+if (empty($serviceCounts) || !is_array($serviceCounts) || array_filter($serviceCounts, fn($count) => !is_numeric($count))) {
+ $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceCount', 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCounts should be an array of numeric values.'];
}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| if (empty($serviceCounts[0]) || !preg_match('/^\d+(,\d+)*$/', implode(',', $serviceCounts))) { | |
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceCount', 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCount should be a comma-separated string of integers.']; | |
| if (empty($serviceCounts) || !is_array($serviceCounts) || array_filter($serviceCounts, fn($count) => !is_numeric($count))) { | |
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidServiceCount', 'errorMessage' => 'serviceCounts should be an array of numeric values.']; |
| if (empty($scopeIds) || !is_array($scopeIds)) { | ||
| $errors[] = [ | ||
| 'scopes' => [], | ||
| 'errorCode' => 'invalidScopeId', | ||
| 'errorMessage' => 'scopeId should be a 32-bit integer.', | ||
| 'status' => 400, | ||
| ]; | ||
| return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => 400]; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Correct validation logic for $scopeIds
In the validateScopeIdParam method, ensure that $scopeIds is an array of numeric values. Also, initialize $errors before appending.
Apply this diff:
+ $errors = [];
if (empty($scopeIds) || !is_array($scopeIds) || array_filter($scopeIds, fn($id) => !is_numeric($id))) {
$errors[] = [
'scopes' => [],
'errorCode' => 'invalidScopeId',
'errorMessage' => 'Each scopeId should be a 32-bit integer.',
'status' => 400,
];
return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => 400];
}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| if (empty($scopeIds) || !is_array($scopeIds)) { | |
| $errors[] = [ | |
| 'scopes' => [], | |
| 'errorCode' => 'invalidScopeId', | |
| 'errorMessage' => 'scopeId should be a 32-bit integer.', | |
| 'status' => 400, | |
| ]; | |
| return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => 400]; | |
| } | |
| $errors = []; | |
| if (empty($scopeIds) || !is_array($scopeIds) || array_filter($scopeIds, fn($id) => !is_numeric($id))) { | |
| $errors[] = [ | |
| 'scopes' => [], | |
| 'errorCode' => 'invalidScopeId', | |
| 'errorMessage' => 'Each scopeId should be a 32-bit integer.', | |
| 'status' => 400, | |
| ]; | |
| return ['errors' => $errors, 'status' => 400]; | |
| } |
| if (!$startDate) { | ||
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidStartDate', 'errorMessage' => 'startDate is required and must be a valid date.']; | ||
| } | ||
| if (!$endDate) { | ||
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidEndDate', 'errorMessage' => 'endDate is required and must be a valid date.']; | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Enhance date format validation for startDate and endDate
Currently, the validation only checks if startDate and endDate are provided, but it does not validate their formats. This may lead to unexpected errors if invalid date formats are supplied. Consider adding date format validation to ensure they are in the correct YYYY-MM-DD format.
Apply this diff to include date format validation:
if (!$startDate) {
$errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidStartDate', 'errorMessage' => 'startDate is required and must be a valid date.'];
+} elseif (!\DateTime::createFromFormat('Y-m-d', $startDate)) {
+ $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidStartDateFormat', 'errorMessage' => 'startDate must be in YYYY-MM-DD format.'];
}
if (!$endDate) {
$errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidEndDate', 'errorMessage' => 'endDate is required and must be a valid date.'];
+} elseif (!\DateTime::createFromFormat('Y-m-d', $endDate)) {
+ $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidEndDateFormat', 'errorMessage' => 'endDate must be in YYYY-MM-DD format.'];
}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| if (!$startDate) { | |
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidStartDate', 'errorMessage' => 'startDate is required and must be a valid date.']; | |
| } | |
| if (!$endDate) { | |
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidEndDate', 'errorMessage' => 'endDate is required and must be a valid date.']; | |
| } | |
| if (!$startDate) { | |
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidStartDate', 'errorMessage' => 'startDate is required and must be a valid date.']; | |
| } elseif (!\DateTime::createFromFormat('Y-m-d', $startDate)) { | |
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidStartDateFormat', 'errorMessage' => 'startDate must be in YYYY-MM-DD format.']; | |
| } | |
| if (!$endDate) { | |
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidEndDate', 'errorMessage' => 'endDate is required and must be a valid date.']; | |
| } elseif (!\DateTime::createFromFormat('Y-m-d', $endDate)) { | |
| $errors[] = ['status' => 400, 'errorCode' => 'invalidEndDateFormat', 'errorMessage' => 'endDate must be in YYYY-MM-DD format.']; | |
| } |
| $providerList = ZmsApiClientService::getOffices(); | ||
| $requestRelationList = ZmsApiClientService::getRequestRelationList(); | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Handle possible null return from API calls
When calling ZmsApiClientService::getOffices(), ensure that the method handles possible null returns to prevent errors.
Apply this diff:
$providerList = ZmsApiClientService::getOffices();
+ if ($providerList === null) {
+ return [
+ 'error' => 'Failed to retrieve offices',
+ 'status' => 500
+ ];
+ }
$requestRelationList = ZmsApiClientService::getRequestRelationList();
+ if ($requestRelationList === null) {
+ return [
+ 'error' => 'Failed to retrieve request relations',
+ 'status' => 500
+ ];
+ }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| $providerList = ZmsApiClientService::getOffices(); | |
| $requestRelationList = ZmsApiClientService::getRequestRelationList(); | |
| $providerList = ZmsApiClientService::getOffices(); | |
| if ($providerList === null) { | |
| return [ | |
| 'error' => 'Failed to retrieve offices', | |
| 'status' => 500 | |
| ]; | |
| } | |
| $requestRelationList = ZmsApiClientService::getRequestRelationList(); | |
| if ($requestRelationList === null) { | |
| return [ | |
| 'error' => 'Failed to retrieve request relations', | |
| 'status' => 500 | |
| ]; | |
| } |
Description
Short description or comments
Reference
Issues #XXX
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
zmscitizenapimodule, enabling new API functionalities for citizen services./zmscitizenapiendpoint, enhancing access to citizen-related APIs.Bug Fixes
Tests